New: essential-reading teaching for Chapter 2. The prescribed textbook topics are explained in original plain English, with a statutory issue map, an applied problem, FAQs and reasoned MCQs.
Open the source-integrated guideNew: beginner-first companion for Chapter 2. A plain-English lecturer-style explanation, statutory map, worked IRAC example, FAQs and MCQs with explanations.
Start the easy-to-read guideORIGINAL PUBLISHED INTERIOR · 26 OCTOBER 2026
Chapter 2 — Incorporation and Its Effects
Preservation note. The material below is a readable text extraction from the existing original book, kept in the same page order without editorial rewriting. Its complete, original approved page layout and link annotations are preserved in the PDFs. Open the complete reading edition.
Original book page 59
CHAPTER 2 • INCORPORATION AND ITS EFFECTS
Separate Legal Personality, Limited
Liability, the Corporate Veil, Corporate
Groups and Company Types
Week 2 Forum / Lecture
Tutorial 2 - Week 3
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Chapter purpose. Chapter 1 showed how ownership, management and liability
operate when people carry on business personally or in partnership. Chapter 2 asks
what changes when the law recognises a new corporate person. We begin with the
separation of ownership and control, then build the doctrine from registration through
Salomon, limited liability, company property, multiple legal capacities, veil cases,
corporate groups and company classifications. Every authority is tied back to a practical
issue students must learn to spot.
Teaching flow: why corporate law is needed -> identify members, directors, officers
and creditors -> ask "in what capacity?" -> registration creates the company ->
company owns assets and contracts -> members receive limited liability -> Salomon
proves the separation -> Lee and Macaura show its consequences -> veil cases test
misuse -> corporate groups expose the tension between entity law and commercial
reality.
2.1 Why Corporate Law exists: separation of ownership
and control
The Week 2 Forum opens with a corporate-governance problem rather than a statute. In a
large company, the people providing the capital can be different from the people controlling
the day-to-day decisions. Shareholders are the members and investors. Directors and senior
management exercise corporate decision-making powers. Once ownership and control are
separated, incentives can diverge.
The Wall Street example used in class is memorable because it asks a simple question:
what happens when managers spend money that economically belongs to an enterprise in
which they own only a small stake? A private jet, excessive perks or wasteful expenditure
may benefit managers while reducing value available to investors. That is an agency
problem. Corporate law therefore does more than create companies. It supplies governance
CORPORATE LAW
58 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 60
rules that allocate powers, impose duties and protect participants against the risks generated
by separating economic ownership from managerial control.
Contrast the partnership. In an ordinary partnership, the partners are generally both owners
and managers, and they also face personal exposure to partnership liabilities. Those
features create powerful incentives to monitor the business. The company allows those
functions to be separated: capital can come from one group, management from another, and
liability can be concentrated in the corporate entity.
Issue-spotting trigger. When a problem involves a shareholder complaining about a
director, or a director using company money or opportunities, ask whether the real
problem is the separation of ownership and control. Later directors' duties are legal
responses to that structural risk.
2.2 Who is who inside and outside the company?
Corporate Law becomes much easier once students stop treating "the company" as a loose
collection of people. The company is itself a legal person. Around that person are human
beings and other entities occupying different legal roles.
Role
Corporate-law significance
Members /
shareholders
Members form one formal organ of the company. In a for-profit company with
shares, members are shareholders. They exercise rights such as voting and
receiving distributions when lawfully declared, but they do not own each individual
asset of the company.
Directors /
board
Directors are key decision-makers. The board acts as the company's management
organ under the statutory and constitutional framework. Directors owe duties that
later chapters examine in detail.
Officers /
management
Senior executives and officers may exercise important corporate power even if they
are not shareholders.
Creditors
Banks, landlords, suppliers and other creditors are ordinarily outsiders to the
internal governance structure. They contract with the company and depend on the
company's assets and legal protections applicable to creditors.
The company
The separate legal entity that owns the assets, incurs liabilities, enters contracts and
is sued or sues in its own name.
CORPORATE LAW
59 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 61
2.3 The most useful question in Corporate Law: "In what
capacity?"
One human being can wear several legal hats. A founder may be the sole shareholder, sole
director, employee and secured creditor of the same company. Corporate Law does not
collapse those roles merely because the same person occupies them.
Capacity method. Before analysing conduct, ask: In what capacity was the person
acting? Then ask: what powers attach to that role, what duties attach to that role, and
what legal consequences follow? This avoids confusing a shareholder's rights with a
director's powers, an employee's contract with a member's investment, or a creditor's
security with a shareholder's residual interest.
This question becomes the key to Salomon and Lee. It also foreshadows conflicts of interest:
the law often cares not merely who a person is, but the legal capacity in which the person
acquired information, made a decision, received a benefit or assumed an obligation.
2.4 Company versus corporation
The Corporations Act uses both terms. For most of this subject, "company" and "corporation"
can be used conversationally in similar ways, but they are not technically identical. A
company is a specific statutory form registered under the Corporations Act. "Corporation" is
broader and can include other bodies corporate. That distinction matters whenever a
statutory provision applies to a "company" but not necessarily to every corporation, or vice
versa.
Exam trigger. If a question turns on statutory scope, read the defined term in s 9 and
the broader concept of corporation in s 57A rather than assuming the words are
interchangeable in every provision.
2.5 Registration: the legal "birthday" of the company
The Forum describes incorporation as the company's birthday. The metaphor is useful
because registration marks the point at which the law recognises a new legal person.
CORPORATE LAW
60 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 62
Section 119 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). A company comes into existence as a body
corporate at the beginning of the day on which it is registered. This is the statutory
bridge between an application to ASIC and the existence of the legal person.
Section 114 is also important because a company needs at least one member. Modern
Australian law therefore accommodates the one-person company: the same individual can
be sole member and sole director while the company remains legally distinct.
Section 124(1). The company has the legal capacity and powers of an individual, both
inside and outside the jurisdiction, and also the powers of a body corporate. Paragraphs
(a)-(c), for example, include powers concerning shares, debentures and options. The
practical point is that the company can own property, enter contracts, borrow, lend,
issue securities and litigate in its own name.
This is why a founder can contract with the company they control. A sole trader cannot
meaningfully contract with themselves as two separate legal persons. A shareholder can
contract with the company because the shareholder and company are legally distinct.
2.6 The company as a "pot of funds" and a "nexus of
contracts"
The Forum gives two complementary ways to picture the company. First, the company is a
pot of funds: the legal entity in which the business assets sit. The cash, equipment,
intellectual property, vehicles and contractual rights belong to the company. Second, the
company can be understood as a nexus of contracts: employees, lenders, suppliers,
customers and landlords generally contract with the corporate entity rather than with every
shareholder and director personally.
These models are useful because they explain why third-party claims ordinarily focus on the
corporate entity. If a supplier sells computers to a university company, the contract is with the
company, even though human staff negotiated it. If a company is negligent, the company can
incur tort liability. Human actors may also be personally liable on independent legal grounds,
but the company's legal personality remains the starting point.
2.7 Perpetual succession
A company's existence is not tied to the life of its founder. Shareholders can sell shares,
directors can resign or die, and management can be replaced without the corporate person
CORPORATE LAW
61 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 63
automatically ending. The company continues until deregistration or another legal event
terminates it. This continuity is one reason companies are suited to long-lived enterprises
and large pools of investment.
2.8 Limited liability: do not say "the company has limited
liability"
This is a precision point emphasised in the Forum. The company itself is fully responsible for
its own debts. Limited liability ordinarily protects the members from being required to
contribute beyond the statutory limit merely because they are members.
Section 516. In a company limited by shares, a member generally need not contribute
more on a winding up than the amount, if any, unpaid on the shares for which the
member is liable. Fully paid shares therefore normally leave no further contribution
merely because the company cannot pay its creditors. Partly paid shares can still be
called up to the unpaid balance.
That distinction is easier to understand if we compare a partnership. A general partner may
face exposure to partnership obligations extending far beyond the amount initially invested. A
shareholder who has fully paid for shares can lose the value of the investment, but ordinarily
is not required to satisfy the company's remaining debts merely because of shareholder
status.
Important qualification. Limited liability is not universal immunity. A shareholder or
director can separately become liable by giving a personal guarantee, personally
committing a tort, breaching a duty, entering a contract personally or falling within a
statutory liability regime. Always identify the independent legal basis for personal
liability.
2.9 Why limited liability matters economically
Limited liability changes the allocation of risk. Investors can commit a defined amount of
capital and diversify across enterprises without exposing all personal assets to every
company's debts. That can encourage investment, liquidity and entrepreneurship. But the
risk does not disappear. If the company fails, creditors may absorb losses.
That trade-off matters especially when comparing sophisticated contractual creditors with
involuntary tort creditors. A bank can investigate a company, price risk, obtain security or
CORPORATE LAW
62 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 64
demand a guarantee. A person injured by a corporate activity may never have had any
opportunity to negotiate risk allocation. Corporate groups intensify that fairness problem.
The Forum also discusses company taxation and franking credits as commercial context. For
this Corporate Law chapter, the safe teaching point is that a company is a separate taxpayer
and tax policy can influence financing and distribution choices. Detailed tax rates and the
personal tax treatment of dividends belong to Taxation Law and should be checked against
current tax legislation rather than treated as a fixed Corporate Law rule.
2.10 Salomon: the case that makes the separate entity
real
Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] AC 22
Facts. Aron Salomon operated a successful boot and shoe business. He incorporated a
company and sold the business to it. At the time, company legislation required seven
members. Salomon held almost all the shares while family members held the small
number needed to satisfy the formal requirement. Part of the price was represented by
secured debentures issued to Salomon, making him both the controlling shareholder
and a secured creditor.
What went wrong. The company later became insolvent. Its assets were insufficient to
satisfy all creditors. Because Salomon held security, recognising his creditor rights
would leave the unsecured creditors with little or nothing.
Issue. Could the court disregard the company and treat Salomon and the company as
effectively the same person because he controlled almost everything?
Decision. No. The House of Lords treated the properly incorporated company as a
legal person distinct from Salomon. Parliament had specified the incorporation
requirements, and they had been met. Salomon could therefore simultaneously be
shareholder, controller and creditor. His secured creditor rights were not erased simply
because he controlled the company.
Why the case matters. Salomon is not merely a slogan for separate personality. It
proves that legal capacity follows the company even when economic control is
concentrated in one individual. It also teaches the "multiple hats" method: the same
person can hold several legally distinct relationships with the company.
CORPORATE LAW
63 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 65
Exam use. Cite Salomon when someone argues that ownership or control alone makes
the shareholder personally liable for the company's obligations, or when a controller has
entered a genuine contract with the company.
2.11 Lee: one person can be controller and employee
Lee v Lee's Air Farming Ltd [1961] AC 12
Facts. Lee held 2,999 of the company's 3,000 issued shares, was its governing director
and also worked as a pilot for the company. He died in an aircraft accident while
performing that work, and his widow pursued workers' compensation.
Issue. Could Lee genuinely be an employee of a company he overwhelmingly owned
and controlled?
Decision. Yes. The company was a separate legal person capable of entering an
employment contract with Lee. His director/shareholder capacities did not prevent him
from also acting as employee.
Why it matters. Lee converts the abstract idea of separate personality into an
examination technique. Ask what hat the person was wearing at the relevant time.
2.12 Macaura: separate personality can hurt the
shareholder too
Macaura v Northern Assurance Co Ltd [1925] AC 619
Facts. Macaura transferred timber to a company but kept the insurance in his own
name. The timber was destroyed by fire.
Issue. Did Macaura's ownership of the company's shares give him a legal or equitable
ownership interest in the company's timber sufficient for the insurance claim?
Decision. No. The timber belonged to the company, not to Macaura as shareholder.
Why it matters. This case stops students from treating separate personality as a one-
way protection device. The shareholder gains limited liability but also loses direct
ownership of company assets. A share is an interest in the company under its legal
CORPORATE LAW
64 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 66
framework, not a fractional title to every truck, bank account or parcel of timber owned
by the company.
2.13 The corporate veil: start with respect for the entity
The "corporate veil" is a metaphor for the legal separation between the company and those
behind it. The normal rule is respect for the separate entity. Courts do not disregard
incorporation merely because one person owns all the shares, exercises control, or because
ignoring the company would appear fairer.
Modern authority warns that "piercing the veil" should not become a loose label for every
situation where someone associated with a company is liable. Often the correct explanation
is ordinary contract, agency, tort, equity, directors' duties or statute. The legal basis must be
identified precisely.
2.14 Gilford Motor and Jones v Lipman: using a company
to evade an existing obligation
Gilford Motor Co Ltd v Horne [1933] Ch 935
Facts. Horne was bound by a post-employment restraint preventing specified
competitive conduct. After leaving his employer, he carried on the competing activity
through a company.
Issue. Could the company form be used to continue conduct Horne had contractually
promised not to undertake?
Outcome. Injunctive relief was granted against Horne and the company. The company
was being used as the vehicle for the continuing breach.
Why it matters. This is the direct authority for the Stella Designs tutorial problem. The
important idea is not that every controlled company loses separate personality. It is that
equity will not necessarily allow a company to be interposed as a device for evading a
pre-existing obligation.
Jones v Lipman [1962] 1 WLR 832
Facts. Lipman contracted to sell land, then transferred it to a company in an attempt to
avoid completing the sale.
CORPORATE LAW
65 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 67
Outcome and significance. The court granted relief against both Lipman and the
company. The case reinforces the principle that incorporation cannot automatically be
used as a device to defeat an existing equitable or contractual obligation.
2.15 Other wrongdoing and the need to identify the real
legal basis
The Week 2 materials also refer to Re Darby [1911] 1 KB 95, involving use of a company in a
fraudulent scheme, and Green v Bestobell Industries Pty Ltd [1982] WAR 1, where a
company knowingly participated in a director's breach. These examples are useful, but
students should resist turning them into a broad rule that "bad conduct means the veil is
lifted." The stronger method is to identify the specific doctrine - fraud, knowing participation,
breach of duty, injunction, statute or another established basis.
2.16 Insolvent trading: a statutory example of personal
exposure
Section 588G is introduced in the Forum as an example of Parliament imposing personal
responsibility on directors in connection with insolvent trading. The detailed elements and
defences belong to the later insolvency/directors' duties material, but the conceptual lesson
belongs here: limited liability does not mean directors can knowingly cause the company to
incur debts in circumstances where the statutory regime imposes personal consequences.
Do not write: "s 588G pierces the veil." Better: "The separate company remains the
debtor, but the statute imposes an additional personal liability regime on directors when
its elements are satisfied." That language is more precise.
2.17 Corporate groups: why businesses build layers of
companies
Large enterprises often use holding companies and subsidiaries to separate geography,
intellectual property, finance, business lines and risk. A bank group might have different
operating subsidiaries in different countries, a separate intellectual-property entity and a
riskier agricultural-finance subsidiary. The commercial logic is risk partitioning: failure in one
CORPORATE LAW
66 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 68
business line should not automatically consume the assets of every other company in the
group.
But this creates a tension. Commercially, employees and customers may experience the
group as one enterprise with one brand and central management. Legally, each company is
ordinarily a separate person. That mismatch becomes especially difficult for creditors who do
not know which entity they were truly dealing with or for tort victims harmed by an
undercapitalised subsidiary.
2.18 Briggs: control of a subsidiary is not enough
Briggs v James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd (1989) 16 NSWLR 549
Context. The litigation arose from an asbestos-related claim involving companies within
the James Hardie group and raised questions about whether liability could extend
beyond the company that had directly employed the worker.
Key point. Rogers AJA rejected the idea that complete dominion or control by a parent
is, by itself, enough to disregard a subsidiary's separate personality. That would be far
too broad because parent companies commonly control subsidiaries.
Why it matters. Briggs exposes the policy tension. Strict entity law provides certainty
and permits risk partitioning, but it can produce harsh outcomes for involuntary creditors
who never negotiated with the group about which corporate "pot" would bear the risk.
2.19 Qintex: commercial reality can become confused
when groups ignore their own boundaries
Qintex Australia Finance Ltd v Schroders Australia Ltd (1990) 3 ACSR 267
Context. The case involved dealings across the Qintex group where corporate
identities were handled imprecisely in commercial communications and transactions.
Why it matters. The case illustrates the practical tension between strict legal
boundaries and business practices that treat a group as one operation. Students should
not leap from that tension to a general "group liability" rule. Instead, identify the actual
contracting party, the evidence of authority, representations, mistake or other doctrine
that determines liability.
CORPORATE LAW
67 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 69
2.20 Corporate groups and statutory intervention
The Corporations Act sometimes treats group relationships specially. Sections 588V-588X,
for example, create a statutory regime concerning holding-company liability associated with
insolvent trading by a subsidiary. That is a targeted legislative exception to the ordinary
entity-by-entity starting point, not a general rule that every parent guarantees every
subsidiary.
Later directors' duties also require attention to the interests of the particular company whose
board the director serves. Group commercial interests can be relevant, but the legal person
remains central.
2.21 Company classifications: the information students
must attach to the doctrine
Once students understand why the company exists and how separate personality works,
classifications become easier because they answer specific questions: what is the member's
liability, is the company public or proprietary, how large is it, and how is it related to other
companies?
Type / rule
Key provision
Why it matters
Types of
company
s 112
Classifies companies by liability and public/proprietary
status.
Company limited
by shares
ss 112, 516
Standard for-profit form; member contribution on winding
up generally limited to unpaid share capital.
Company limited
by guarantee
s 9 definition; s 112
Common not-for-profit form; members undertake a
specified guarantee payable on winding up rather than
holding shares.
No liability
company
s 112(2)
Special form connected with mining purposes and
statutory conditions.
Proprietary
company
ss 45A, 113
Closely held company; s 113 limits non-employee
shareholders and restricts fundraising requiring Chapter
6D disclosure, subject to exceptions.
Minimum
membership
s 114
A company must have at least one member.
Directors
s 201A
CORPORATE LAW
68 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 70
Proprietary companies need at least one director, with the
residency requirement in the provision; public companies
require at least three directors, at least two ordinarily
resident in Australia.
Names
ss 148-150
Connects the company's legal type to naming
requirements, including "Pty" and "Ltd" and limited
exceptions.
Large / small
proprietary
company
s 45A +
Corporations
Regulations reg
1.0.02B
Classification affects reporting. Current prescribed
thresholds are $50m consolidated revenue, $25m
consolidated gross assets and 100 employees; at least
two criteria determine large/small status.
Do not memorise these classifications as isolated trivia. Ask what legal consequence the
classification carries: fundraising, reporting, director numbers, member liability or naming.
2.22 Issue-spotting map for Chapter 2
Fact trigger
Issue
Law / authority
Founder says "I own 100%, so the
company is me."
Separate personality
despite control.
ss 114, 119; Salomon.
Controller also works for the company.
Multiple legal capacities.
Lee.
Shareholder claims direct ownership
of company property.
Asset ownership.
ss 119, 124; Macaura.
Creditor wants shareholder to pay
company debt.
Company debt versus
member liability.
Salomon; s 516; identify any
guarantee or separate basis.
Company created after an individual
becomes bound by a restraint.
Evasion of existing
obligation.
Gilford Motor; Jones v Lipman.
Director incurs debts while company is
insolvent.
Statutory personal liability.
s 588G and later insolvency
provisions.
Parent controls subsidiary and creditor
seeks parent assets.
Corporate group separate
personality.
Salomon; Briggs; targeted
statutory exceptions.
Group communications blur which
entity is contracting.
Identity of contracting
party / commercial reality.
Qintex; contract and authority
principles.
CORPORATE LAW
69 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 71
2.23 Frequently Asked Questions
FAQ 1 - Why does Corporate Law separate ownership and control?
It allows investors to supply capital while directors and managers specialise in running
the enterprise. The trade-off is an agency problem: managers may not always have the
same incentives as investors.
FAQ 2 - What is the company's "birthday"?
The beginning of the day of registration under s 119, when the company comes into
existence as a body corporate.
FAQ 3 - Can one person own and direct the whole company?
Yes. Section 114 allows at least one member, and a proprietary company can have one
director subject to s 201A. Separate personality still applies.
FAQ 4 - What does "in what capacity?" mean?
Identify whether the person was acting as member, director, officer, employee, creditor
or another role. The applicable powers and duties depend on that capacity.
FAQ 5 - Are shareholders the owners of company assets?
No. The company owns its property. Macaura is the classic illustration.
FAQ 6 - Does a company have limited liability?
The company is responsible for its debts. Limited liability ordinarily describes the
member's capped contribution merely as member.
FAQ 7 - Why is Salomon more than a case name?
Because it shows that a properly registered company remains separate even when one
person overwhelmingly owns and controls it, and that the controller can have a
separate creditor relationship with the company.
FAQ 8 - Why is Lee important after Salomon?
It shows the capacity principle in practice: the controller could also be an employee.
FAQ 9 - Why is Macaura important?
It shows the cost of separation: shareholders do not directly own corporate property.
FAQ 10 - When can the corporate veil be ignored?
Only on a recognised legal basis. Do not use "veil piercing" as a general fairness
doctrine. Gilford Motor and Jones v Lipman illustrate relief where a company was used
to evade an existing obligation.
CORPORATE LAW
70 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 72
FAQ 11 - Does parent-company control make the parent liable?
No, not by itself. Briggs is important precisely because control is normal in corporate
groups.
FAQ 12 - Why do groups use subsidiaries?
To organise different businesses, jurisdictions, assets, financing and risks. The legal
benefit of separation creates the creditor-policy problem discussed in Briggs and
Qintex.
FAQ 13 - Are directors protected by limited liability if they breach duties?
Separate personality does not excuse personal wrongdoing. Directors can be
personally liable on independent statutory, contractual, tortious or equitable grounds.
FAQ 14 - Why distinguish proprietary and public companies?
The classification affects fundraising, reporting, director requirements, governance and
disclosure.
FAQ 15 - Do I need to memorise every company type?
Know the main forms and attach each to its legal consequence. Understanding beats
isolated memorisation.
2.24 Multiple Choice Questions
The strongest explanation of separate legal personality is:
A. Directors own the company assets.
B. Registration creates a legal person distinct from members and directors.
C. A company is only a contract among shareholders.
D. The company and its controlling shareholder are always one person.
Answer: B. Section 119 and Salomon provide the foundation.
Why is the question "in what capacity?" so important?
A. It identifies which legal role, powers and duties attach to the conduct.
B. It tells you the person's tax bracket.
C. It determines whether the company is listed.
D. It makes Salomon irrelevant.
Answer: A.
Which case most directly shows a controlling shareholder/director can also be an
employee?
1.
2.
3.
CORPORATE LAW
71 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 73
A. Macaura
B. Lee v Lee's Air Farming
C. Briggs
D. Qintex
Answer: B.
Which case shows that a shareholder does not directly own company property?
A. Gilford Motor
B. Salomon only
C. Macaura
D. Canny Gabriel
Answer: C.
A shareholder has fully paid shares. The company fails owing $4m. With no guarantee or
wrongdoing, which statement is best?
A. The shareholder must pay the whole $4m.
B. The company owes the debt; the member's contribution is ordinarily limited under s
516.
C. The directors automatically owe the $4m.
D. The corporate veil disappears on insolvency.
Answer: B.
Stella signs a restraint, then creates a company solely to perform the restrained activity.
Which authority is closest?
A. Gilford Motor Co Ltd v Horne
B. Lee
C. Macaura
D. Canny Gabriel
Answer: A.
Which is the safest statement about veil piercing?
A. Courts ignore companies whenever justice requires.
B. Control alone is enough.
C. A recognised legal basis must be identified; the metaphor should not replace analysis.
D. It only applies to public companies.
Answer: C.
4.
5.
6.
7.
CORPORATE LAW
72 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 74
Why is Briggs significant?
A. It says every corporate group is one legal person.
B. It rejects parent control alone as a sufficient basis to disregard subsidiary personality.
C. It abolishes limited liability.
D. It concerns partnership authority.
Answer: B.
Qintex is useful because it illustrates:
A. how commercial group practice can blur the identity of the contracting company
B. how a partnership forms
C. the tax rate on dividends
D. how ASIC appoints directors
Answer: A.
A company limited by guarantee is most commonly associated with:
A. a not-for-profit organisation without share capital
B. a listed mining company
C. an ordinary partnership
D. a sole trader
Answer: A.
A proprietary company generally cannot have more than how many non-employee
shareholders for s 113 purposes, subject to statutory qualifications?
A. 5
B. 20
C. 50
D. 1000
Answer: C.
The current proprietary-company size thresholds are found in:
A. only s 119
B. s 45A together with Corporations Regulations reg 1.0.02B
C. s 516 only
D. Partnership Act s 5
Answer: B.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
CORPORATE LAW
73 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 75
CORPORATE LAW
CHAPTER 2 — COURSE READINGS AND
TEACHING INTEGRATION
The company’s birth is a change in legal identity, not merely a
trading-name choice
Incorporation creates a distinct legal person: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 119.
This matters because the assets and liabilities of a company belong to that
company, not automatically to the humans who control it. The practical client
question is whose money, property, contract or wrong is in issue. Section 124
supplies the company’s legal capacity. A lawyer should not jump from a director’s
influence to personal liability without identifying a separate legal basis.
Salomon: the cornerstone and its limits
In Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] AC 22, incorporation was not ignored
simply because the founder held almost all the shares and controlled
management. The company was distinct from Mr Salomon, who could also be its
creditor. The authority prevents the court from treating concentrated ownership
as sufficient, by itself, to collapse legal personality. It does not give a director
immunity for an independent tort, an enforceable personal guarantee or a specific
statutory liability. Those are separate analytical questions.
Limited liability is the member’s exposure, not the company’s exposure
The company itself owes its debts in full. A member’s liability merely as a
member of a company limited by shares is normally confined to unpaid share
capital, including the statutory winding-up rule in s 516. Separate personality
identifies whose obligation exists; limited liability limits the shareholder’s
contributory exposure. A personally guaranteed company loan is a different
obligation and is not defeated by this protection.
Macaura and Lee reveal the benefits and risks of separate personality
Lee v Lee’s Air Farming Ltd [1961] AC 12 shows how one human may occupy
different legal capacities in relation to a company, including shareholder, director
and employee. Macaura v Northern Assurance Co Ltd [1925] AC 619 shows the
other side: a shareholder did not own the company’s insured property merely
because he controlled the company. In professional advice, ask whether each
contract or asset was actually transferred to the company, not only whether the
74 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 76
CORPORATE LAW
beneficial owner intended to conduct business through it.
Stella Designs: analyse the restraint and the company separately
The Stella problem must begin with the contractual rights of Louise Vuilton
against Stella, and only then ask whether Stella Designs Pty Ltd could be
restrained as a vehicle for evasion. Gilford Motor Co Ltd v Horne [1933] Ch 935 is
relevant because an individual bound by a pre-existing restraint used an
incorporated entity in a way that undermined that obligation. But the company
does not automatically become a party to Stella’s contract. A court would first
consider the underlying restraint’s enforceability, the evidence of purpose and
conduct, and the appropriate injunction. The reasoning is more precise than
asserting a free-standing veil-piercing power whenever a corporate structure
produces an unattractive result.
Corporate groups: why Rogers AJA resists a broad enterprise theory
Briggs v James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd (1989) 16 NSWLR 549 illustrates the conflict
between separate group entities and practical control of subsidiary activities,
especially for involuntary tort claimants. Rogers AJA cautioned against treating
parental control, which is ordinary in corporate groups, as sufficient in itself to
pierce the veil. A lawyer should investigate direct parent conduct, assumption of
responsibility, contractual or statutory liability, tort duties and admissible
evidence, rather than treating group membership as an automatic basis for
judgment against every entity in the group.
Involuntary creditors and legal-policy analysis
A tort claimant injured by an undercapitalised subsidiary could not choose the
corporate entity with which to contract. That creates a fairness argument for
broader group responsibility. Conversely, automatic group liability may weaken
predictability for investors, creditors and separately capitalised enterprises. The
Week 2 tutorial intentionally invites an argued position; a high-quality discussion
separates what existing law provides from what a policy reform might sensibly
adopt. The strongest answer explains both the economic advantages and the
distributional costs before stating a reasoned view.
Pinpoint assigned readings and verification limits
Week 2 assigns Chapple et al, Company Law (3rd ed) Chapter 2 from p 50
(section 2.2) to p 74; Redmond pp 161–173; and Gilford Motor Co Ltd v Horne
[1933] Ch 935. Optional readings include Farrar and Hanrahan pp 39–43 and
75 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 77
CORPORATE LAW
53–59, Saul Fridman’s discussion of piercing the veil and Qintex, and Redmond
pp 186–192 concerning corporate groups. These locations are preserved as a
course-reading map. The slides are available, but the complete text of these
additional extract pages is not established by the attached records; teaching built
from them has therefore not been claimed as if every passage were examined.
76 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 78
CORPORATE LAW
The prescribed company-law reading:
personality, classification and legal
consequences
The Chapter 2 extract provided from Chapple and co-authors covers book pages
50–70. It develops the categories of corporations, the registration sequence, separate
legal personality, corporate groups, and limited liability. The best way to learn these
topics is to ask the same question repeatedly: which legal person has the right,
duty, asset or liability? A company is not simply an administrative label placed over
its shareholders. It is a separate legal person capable of holding property and
contracting; this is the reason one must not confuse the company's assets with the
assets of its controller.
What kind of entity are we advising?
Begin with the legal definitions. Section 9 of the Corporations Act 2001 defines a
company by reference to registration under that Act, while s 57A defines the broader
term ‘corporation’ for relevant statutory purposes. Section 112 identifies available
types of registration, including companies limited by shares, limited by guarantee,
unlimited companies and no-liability companies. Sections 45A and 113 matter when
determining whether the vehicle is proprietary and whether the applicable reporting
and membership requirements are met. A proprietary company generally cannot have
more than 50 non-employee shareholders; one should also check its fundraising
restrictions and exceptions before promising investors an ordinary public share
offering.
The distinction between public and proprietary is not the same as listed versus
unlisted. A public company may be unlisted; a listed company must also comply with
the rules and standards of its approved financial market. For some public companies,
additional investor disclosure, governance and meeting obligations arise. A public
company limited by guarantee often serves a non-distribution or community purpose,
but its liability structure is different from that of a company limited by shares. A
no-liability company is a specialised statutory form and should not be described as a
general device for escaping commercial obligations. When advising, state the required
liability regime before selecting the type of company.
77 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 79
CORPORATE LAW
Small and large proprietary companies: apply both statutory
elements and current thresholds
The distinction in s 45A is a classification test, not an opinion about whether a
business is ‘large’ in everyday language. The statutory framework uses consolidated
revenue, consolidated gross assets and employee numbers, with prescribed amounts
under the regulations. For current ASIC guidance, a proprietary company is large for a
financial year if it meets at least two of three criteria: revenue of $50 million or more,
gross assets of $25 million or more, or 100 or more employees (including controlled
entities on the prescribed basis). If a company meets only one threshold, it does not
become large under this two-of-three test simply because that one figure is very
substantial. See ASIC, ‘Company financial reports’ and ‘Are you a large or small
proprietary company’. Recheck the thresholds and reporting rules for the particular
financial year and any special direction or crowd-sourced-funding condition.
For example, if an organisation has revenue of $58 million, assets of $19 million and
88 employees, one threshold is satisfied, not two. The method is arithmetic but the
legal significance is regulatory: different financial reporting, lodgement and auditing
requirements may follow. In a model answer, identify the year, consolidate the relevant
entities, test each paragraph separately, count the criteria reached and only then
reach a classification conclusion. It is not enough to write ‘s 45A applies’ without
showing the calculation.
Registration creates a new legal person: why ss 117–119 matter
The textbook introduces the steps involved in starting a company, but legal advice
requires the actual statutory sequence. Section 117 provides for an application and its
prescribed particulars. Section 118 concerns the registration decision and certificate; s
119 identifies the legal significance of registration: the company comes into existence
as a body corporate on registration. This timing can decide who is liable under a
pre-registration arrangement. A promoter signing before that date cannot assume a
non-existent company was already the contracting party. Sections 131–133 address
the special consequences of pre-registration contracts, including the circumstances in
which persons involved may remain exposed and when a company may ratify. The
client should gather the signed contract, registration date, written consents and
evidence of ratification rather than merely saying the company later traded under that
name.
78 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 80
CORPORATE LAW
Once registered, the company normally has broad legal capacity under s 124. That
does not mean a director has unlimited authority to deploy that capacity: the next
analytical step is internal management, delegated authority and the constitution. Also
distinguish a company's capacity from the liability rules for an actual transaction. In
modern law an objects clause is not generally a simple weapon for denying the
company's contractual capacity; see s 125 and the context of any constitutional
limitations. Chapter 3 teaches the constitution and replaceable rules that govern this
internal allocation of power.
Salomon: facts, issue and reasoning
In Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] AC 22, Mr Salomon transferred an existing
business to a duly incorporated company in which he held a controlling interest. When
the company failed, the attempt to treat it merely as his alias would have denied the
legal consequences of registration. The House of Lords upheld the separate
personality of the incorporated company. The principle is not that Mr Salomon had
acted fairly in every commercial sense; it is that registration under the
governing company statute created a legal person distinct from its members.
This distinction matters in every question asking whether a creditor may recover
company debts directly from a member. Begin with separate personality, then identify
a separate basis for member liability such as a personal guarantee, wrongdoing or an
applicable statutory rule.
In Lee v Lee's Air Farming Ltd [1961] AC 12, a controller could also contract with the
company in another legal capacity. The case illustrates why the director, shareholder
and employee roles are not always mutually exclusive. In Macaura v Northern
Assurance Co Ltd [1925] AC 619, the company's ownership of property defeated an
individual's attempt to claim under insurance of that property in his own name. These
authorities reinforce different practical consequences of the same concept: ask who
contracted, who employed, who owned the insured property, and who holds the
cause of action. The answer can change according to the transaction even where
one individual controls all the votes.
79 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 81
CORPORATE LAW
Corporate groups: different entities, not one enterprise merely
because they trade together
The prescribed pages consider corporate groups, which may have one parent
controlling several subsidiaries. Sections 46–50 of the Corporations Act address
certain subsidiary and related-body-corporate concepts, while s 50AA concerns
control in relevant contexts. But the existence of group control does not of itself
transfer every subsidiary debt or tort obligation to the parent. Legal analysis must
identify the defendant, the relevant conduct and an actual legal route to liability. Briggs
v James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd (1989) 16 NSWLR 549 (check the correct report
pagination for the cited passage) is especially useful in asking whether a claimant can
bypass separate personality merely because a group operates as an economic unit. A
general moral concern for injured involuntary creditors is important policy context but
does not automatically supply a legal cause of action.
The distinction is especially practical when a holding company sets group strategy but
a subsidiary operates a factory. A claimant needs to know who designed the relevant
safety system, who employed the workers, which company owed any statutory duty,
and whether the parent itself undertook or controlled relevant actions. The optional
Elise Bant article considered in Chapter 3 invites a further, careful question about
direct parental conduct through group systems; that is conceptually different from
automatically disregarding separate personality. Do not confuse potential direct liability
with a general ‘group veil-piercing’ doctrine.
80 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 82
CORPORATE LAW
Gilford Motor and the limits of veil arguments
In Gilford Motor Co Ltd v Horne [1933] Ch 935, a former employee subject to a
restrictive covenant used an incorporated business in circumstances supporting an
inference that the vehicle was part of evading that contractual obligation. The case is
relevant when the facts show a company interposed to mask or facilitate a prohibited
act; it is not authority for ignoring all companies merely because they have one
dominant shareholder. Other doctrines—agency, personal tort liability, statutory
liability and injunctions—must be examined according to their own elements. In your
Tutorial 2 scenario concerning Stella and Stella Designs Pty Ltd, ask whether the
restrictive promise binds Stella personally, what conduct the new company actually
undertook, whether there is evidence of deliberate evasion, and which equitable or
common-law remedy the plaintiff seeks. The remedy and factual evidence need to be
tied to the cause of action, not declared from the case name alone.
The correct contrast is therefore straightforward: Salomon is the starting presumption
of separate personality; Gilford Motor addresses unusual evasion facts; group cases
prevent unjustified aggregation of corporate defendants; and individual statutes or tort
duties may impose liability on a person in their own right. This is the legal reasoning
students need instead of a list of disconnected ‘exceptions’.
Applying the reading to the Retrofit and Tutorial 2 examples
The prescribed reading follows the fictional Retrofit business to illustrate the
advantages and burdens of selecting a corporate vehicle. Treat the example as a
client conference: Julian should identify the scale of the proposed operation, access to
capital, need for continuity, expected creditors, employees, desired control and
proposed succession. A single-director proprietary company may suit a controller
seeking a separate contracting vehicle, but it does not erase personal guarantees or
the obligations attached to being director. If Julian borrows secured money, document
who grants security and whether the lender also demands a guarantee. If a worker is
injured, identify the duty-bearing operating entity and any person who owed their own
duty. If Juliet or another investor buys shares, identify the rights attached to the shares
and the constitutional restrictions on transfers.
The concluding advice is reasoned, not categorical: incorporation often facilitates
continuity, investment and risk allocation, but also creates governance, disclosure and
81 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 83
CORPORATE LAW
maintenance obligations. A company is not the right answer to every business
problem. For your original Tutorial 2, use the cases to answer each particular legal
claim, and clearly distinguish the company as an entity from its members, directors,
employees and affiliated companies. Set out the statutory paragraph, state the case
principle, apply the relevant evidence, acknowledge the strongest contrary view and
finish with the parties who may be sued and the relief sought.
Source alignment: Chapple et al, Company Law (3rd ed, 2023), supplied extract pp 50–70 (PDF pp
1–21); Lecture Two, original Tutorial 2 and prescribed supplementary readings. Company-size
figures are checked against current ASIC guidance, not assumed to be frozen at the book's 2023
publication date.
Primary legislative research: Corporations Act 2001, Federal Register of Legislation. For statutory
detail, use the provisions identified above and check the version operative on the material date.
82 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 84
CORPORATE LAW
ORIGINAL TUTORIAL 2 — QUESTIONS IN FULL
The following questions are reproduced verbatim from the uploaded official
tutorial handout, including its own explanatory notes.
Corporate Law
Tutorial 2 – Incorporation and its effects
What does it mean that a corporation is a separate legal entity? What are some of
the consequences, both in the context of (a) Salomon’s case and (b) otherwise?
Describe how ‘limited liability’ works in the context of companies. What is the
interaction between limited liability and the separate legal entity principle?
Stella is head shoe designer at Louise Vuilton (LV), a well-known Australian luxury
brand. As part of her employment contract with LV, Stella agreed to a six-month
non-compete agreement after leaving LV. During the non-compete period, Stella may
not design shoes for a competitor. The purpose of the non-compete agreement is to
prevent Stella from designing similar shoes for a competitor before LV releases
them.
Stella’s popular designs have led to a spike in LV’s profits. When LV refuses to give
Stella a substantial bonus to reward her for her success, Stella quits. She has copies
of her most recent designs on her computer.
Stella incorporates a company, Stella Designs Pty Ltd (“Stella Designs”). Stella and
her husband, Evan, are the only shareholders and directors of Stella Designs. Within
weeks of leaving LV, Stella enters into an agreement under which Stella Designs will
provide shoe designs to LV competitor Christina Diorra (CD). Women’s Wear Daily
reports rumours that Stella is going to provide CD the LV designs from her computer.
LV wants to apply for an injunction to enforce the non-compete agreement and
prevent Stella Designs from providing shoe designs to Diorra. Stella claims that
Stella Designs, unlike Stella, is not bound by the agreement not to design shoes for a
competitor of LV. Will LV be able to enforce the non-compete agreement against
Stella Designs?
Hint: you should use IRAC to answer this question. Think conceptually about what is
going on in this question.
Class Discussion -- Corporate Groups: Many large corporations create complex
layers of subsidiaries known as “corporate groups”. This is done to take advantage of
the Salomon principle, although it is often significant on a commercial basis that one
83 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 85
CORPORATE LAW
is dealing with a corporate group and all of the resources implied by the group
structure. Corporate law is predominantly, however, focused on the individual
company level rather than the corporate group level.
In Briggs v James Hardie and Co Pty Ltd (1989) 16 NSWLR 549, Rogers AJA stated
(at 577) that:
[I]n my view the proposition advanced by the plaintiff that the corporate veil may be
pierced where one company exercises complete dominion and control over another
is entirely too simplistic. The law pays scant regard to the commercial reality that
every holding company has the potential and, more often than not, in fact, does,
exercise complete control over a subsidiary.
Justice Rogers stated this in rejecting the suggestion that he should adopt enterprise
theory, which states that in the corporate group context, the legal status of individual
subsidiaries should be disregarded because ‘the conglomerate is a long way from
the original concept of a corporation’ (James Hardie at 576). As a renowned
company law theorist, Columbia Law professor Adolf Berle, Jr, wrote in his 1947
article, ‘The Theory of Enterprise Entity’,
The so-called ‘artificial personality’ was designed to be the enterpriser of a project.
Multiplicity of artificial personalities within an enterprise unit would probably have
been impossible under most early corporation laws. …
The corporation is emerging as an enterprise bounded by economics, rather than as
an artificial mystic personality bounded by forms of words in a charter, minute books,
and books of accounts. (all quoted in James Hardie at 576).
Professor Berle’s argument was pointing to the reality that a corporate group
internally looks upon itself as a single entity, often with little regard for the corporate
form except where paperwork is involved. Subsidiaries might be formed for legal
reasons (eg, legal rules preventing a company from transacting business in a certain
jurisdiction unless incorporated there; tax purposes) that have nothing to do with
attempts to ring-fence liability. For tax purposes, in many contexts, corporate groups
are looked at on an enterprise basis, and corporate groups must often present
consolidated financial statements to provide a true understanding of how the
business is doing.
Nevertheless, as Justice Rogers pointed out, the law of corporate groups still reflects
the separate legal entity principle of Salomon rather than commercial reality.
I would like you to reflect upon the implications of our system’s adoption of the
separate legal entity principle in the corporate group context. What do you think are
the pros and cons of the law (a) adopting an enterprise liability approach or (b)
84 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 86
CORPORATE LAW
sticking with the current strict adherence to the separate legal entity principle in the
context of corporate groups? Does the law get it right? Why or why not?
Please also separately consider whether the SLE principle is fair in the context of
involuntary tort creditors who have the misfortune of being harmed by the “wrong”
company in a corporate group. You may wish to refer to Justice Rogers’ analysis at
pp. 578 (bottom paragraph) to 580 in Briggs v James Hardie to assist your thinking
about this issue. A PDF of Briggs is posted in the Additional Materials section.
Ultimately, in the Briggs case, the asbestosis victim (Briggs) was given leave to
proceed against James Hardie as well as the defunct subsidiary on the basis that
James Hardie’s ultimate liability (ie, whether the corporate veil would be lifted in that
instance) would be determined at a later date after all of the evidence had been
gathered.
Please be prepared to talk about this material provided in class this week. Keep in
mind: there is no single right or wrong answer. We really want to hear what YOU
think about this stuff, not Chat-GPT. Please do not use AI to write an answer for you.
Reminder: it is a violation of the Student Code of Conduct to upload course materials
into AI.
85 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 87
CORPORATE LAW
TUTORIAL 2 — EXTENDED LEGAL REASONING
Separate person and limited exposure are two distinct legal
propositions
Apply s 119 and *Salomon* when determining the legal owner of a right or
liability. Apply s 516 to a member’s ordinary obligation to contribute unpaid share
capital in winding up. Where someone claims that ownership confers direct
ownership of company assets, *Macaura* supplies a useful corrective. A bank
guarantee signed personally is an additional source of personal exposure and is
not negated by either doctrine.
Stella — the evidence needed before an injunction
Read the restraint agreement and determine whether it is valid as a restraint of
trade under the applicable law. Establish dates of termination, creation of Stella
Designs, the six-month period, possession and use of confidential designs,
decisions by Stella and Evan, contracts with Diorra and the intended remedy.
*Gilford Motor v Horne* provides an analogy for interposing a company to evade
a pre-existing restraint. *Salomon* remains the prima facie separate-person rule,
so there must be evidence justifying equitable restraint against the new company.
The final advice should distinguish an order against Stella from an order against
Stella Designs and address evidence and urgency.
Briggs — legal rule versus reform preference
The legally sound starting point is each member company’s separate personality:
parent influence by itself does not automatically make the parent liable for a
subsidiary’s tort. In *Briggs*, Rogers AJA rejected the simplistic
dominion-and-control proposition and allowed factual development of the
potential claim. An adviser for an asbestosis claimant must identify any direct
duty or act of James Hardie, available statutory causes, and evidence on
operational involvement; an adviser for a corporate group must document
genuine subsidiary decision-making and contractual allocation. A preference for
enterprise liability is a policy argument, not a description of present law.
The detailed original chapter model answers and worked IRAC application
remain included in the immediately following existing chapter pages. Read both
layers together: the verbatim questions, the reasoning method and the individual
worked answers.
86 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 88
2.25 Tutorial 2 - Complete Teaching Answers
Question 1 - What does it mean that a corporation is a separate legal entity? What are
the consequences in Salomon and otherwise?
A company is a legal person distinct from its members and directors. Section 119 marks
the point of legal birth, while s 124 gives the company the legal capacity and powers of
an individual plus corporate powers. The immediate consequences are that the
company can own property, contract, sue and be sued, employ people, issue securities
and continue despite changes in participants.
Salomon proves that the separation applies even where control is concentrated.
Salomon could be shareholder, director and secured creditor because those capacities
were legally distinct. Lee extends the logic to employment: a controlling shareholder/
director could also be an employee. Macaura demonstrates the reverse consequence:
company property is not shareholder property. The correct exam habit is therefore to
identify the legal person and then the capacity in which each human actor was acting.
Question 2 - How does limited liability work and how does it interact with separate
personality?
Separate personality answers whose obligation is it? Limited liability answers how far
must a member contribute merely because they are a member? In a company limited
by shares, s 516 generally caps the member's contribution on winding up at the unpaid
amount on the shares. If the shares are fully paid, there is ordinarily no additional
contribution solely because the company cannot pay.
The company itself remains fully liable for its debts. Personal liability can still arise on
an independent basis - guarantee, tort, breach of duty, contract or statute. This
distinction is essential because saying "the company has limited liability" obscures who
the law is actually protecting.
Question 3 - Stella Designs: can LV enforce the non-compete against the company?
The starting point is Salomon: Stella Designs is a separate legal person and did not
itself sign Stella's employment contract. Stella's ownership and control alone do not
make every personal obligation automatically bind the company.
CORPORATE LAW
87 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 89
However, the facts closely resemble Gilford Motor. Stella was already subject to the six-
month restraint, retained copies of recent LV designs, incorporated a company she and
her husband control, and within weeks arranged for that company to supply shoe
designs to a direct competitor during the restraint period. LV can argue the company is
being used as the vehicle through which Stella proposes to carry out the very activity
she promised not to undertake. Assuming the restraint is otherwise valid and
enforceable, an injunction against Stella and Stella Designs is strongly arguable. The
full IRAC model appears at the end of this chapter.
Question 4 - Corporate groups: enterprise liability versus strict separate personality,
and involuntary tort creditors.
Argument for strict separate personality. Entity-by-entity law produces certainty.
Each company has identifiable assets, creditors, contracts and governance. Investors
and lenders can price risk, and businesses can isolate projects and jurisdictions. If
parent control alone created liability, almost every subsidiary structure would become
unstable because control is normal in groups.
Argument for enterprise liability. Commercial reality may be very different. Groups
can operate with one brand, treasury, management team and strategy while allocating
high-risk activities to thinly capitalised subsidiaries. Treating the enterprise as one unit
can better reflect who created and benefited from the risk.
Involuntary tort creditors. The fairness argument is strongest here. A bank can
demand security or a parent guarantee. An asbestos victim cannot bargain about which
subsidiary should injure them. Briggs exposes that difficulty while still rejecting control
as an automatic basis for group liability.
Balanced conclusion. Australian law generally preserves separate personality but
uses targeted statutory and general-law responses in particular circumstances.
Sections 588V-588X are an example of Parliament imposing holding-company
consequences in a defined insolvency context. This targeted approach avoids treating
every group as one company while recognising that strict entity law can create creditor
problems.
CORPORATE LAW
88 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 90
2.26 Full Constructed IRAC Model Answer - Stella
Designs and the Non-Compete
Issue
The principal issue is whether Louise Vuilton (LV) can obtain injunctive relief preventing
Stella Designs Pty Ltd from supplying shoe designs to Christina Diorra during the six-
month period in which Stella personally agreed not to design shoes for an LV
competitor. The corporate-law sub-issue is whether Stella may rely on the separate
legal personality of Stella Designs to do indirectly through the company what she has
already agreed not to do personally. A preliminary assumption is that the restraint itself
is otherwise valid and enforceable under the applicable restraint-of-trade law.
Rule / Law
The starting point is the separate legal entity principle. Under s 119 Corporations Act
2001 (Cth), Stella Designs came into existence as a body corporate on registration.
Under s 124, it has its own legal capacity. Salomon establishes that a company remains
legally distinct from its shareholders and controllers even where ownership and control
are concentrated. Accordingly, Stella Designs is not automatically bound by every
contract Stella has made merely because Stella controls it.
However, equitable relief can extend to a company used as the vehicle for evading an
existing obligation. In Gilford Motor Co Ltd v Horne [1933] Ch 935, a former employee
subject to a restraint used a company to carry on the prohibited competing activity. The
court granted injunctive relief against both the individual and company. Jones v Lipman
[1962] 1 WLR 832 similarly demonstrates that a company cannot necessarily be
interposed as a device to defeat an existing contractual obligation.
The correct reasoning is narrower than saying the company and Stella are generally
"the same person". The company remains separately incorporated. The question is
whether equity should restrain the company because it is being used to facilitate the
continuing breach of Stella's pre-existing obligation.
Application
Stella has a legitimate starting argument. Her employment contract was with her
personally. Stella Designs was incorporated later and did not sign the restraint. Under
Salomon, the fact that Stella and Evan are the only shareholders and directors does not
by itself collapse the company's separate personality.
CORPORATE LAW
89 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 91
However, the factual sequence strongly favours LV. Stella was already bound for six
months not to design shoes for an LV competitor. She left LV after a dispute over
remuneration, retained copies of recent LV designs, then incorporated Stella Designs.
Within weeks, Stella caused Stella Designs to enter an arrangement to provide shoe
designs to Christina Diorra, an LV competitor, during the exact restraint period.
Those facts closely parallel the concern in Gilford Motor. The company appears not
merely to be an unrelated enterprise in the same market, but a legal vehicle through
which Stella intends to perform the very competitive design activity she personally
agreed not to undertake. The timing, Stella's control, the identity of the competitor and
Stella's possession of recent LV designs reinforce that inference.
Counterargument for Stella Designs. Stella Designs can argue that it is a
genuine separate company, Evan is also a shareholder/director, and the company
entered its own agreement with CD. It can emphasise that control alone is
insufficient to disregard separate personality and that courts should not use veil
language simply because the outcome seems unfair.
That counterargument is important but does not fully answer LV's narrower case. LV
need not prove that Stella Designs is identical to Stella for every purpose. It can seek
equitable relief directed to stopping use of the company as the channel for the
continuing breach of the restraint.
The media report that Stella may provide LV's actual designs to CD adds urgency, but it
is only a rumour unless supported by admissible evidence. LV would need proper
evidence if it relies on threatened misuse of designs or confidential information.
Nevertheless, the risk of unreleased designs being supplied may support the argument
that damages would be inadequate and that preventative relief is appropriate.
Remedy / Consequence
LV should seek an injunction restraining Stella from breaching the valid restraint and
ask that the order also restrain Stella Designs from being used to carry out the
prohibited activity. If relief is sought before final trial, LV must also satisfy the
requirements governing interlocutory injunctions. The order should be framed around
the prohibited conduct rather than making an unnecessarily broad declaration that
Stella and the company are one legal person for all purposes.
Strong Conclusion
Assuming the six-month restraint is legally valid and enforceable, LV has a strong
argument for injunctive relief against Stella and Stella Designs. Separate personality
under s 119 and Salomon remains the starting rule, so Stella's control alone is
CORPORATE LAW
90 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 92
insufficient. But the immediate incorporation of Stella Designs, the company's proposed
supply of shoe designs to LV's direct competitor during the restraint period and Stella's
possession of LV's recent designs make Gilford Motor a close analogy. The stronger
conclusion is that Stella should not be permitted to use the company as the vehicle for
evading the existing restraint.
Exam lesson
Do not jump straight to "piercing the veil." Write the reasoning in order: separate
personality -> identify the pre-existing obligation -> identify the company's role in
the alleged evasion -> apply Gilford Motor -> address the Salomon
counterargument -> identify the precise equitable remedy.
CORPORATE LAW
91 | CORPORATE LAW