Week 5 — Members’ meetings and dividends: full teaching companion
Distinguish the statutory procedures, understand why they differ, and apply them in tutorial-style problems.
1. A student’s map: director meetings are not member meetings
The lecturer's Week 5 Part 2 recording begins with a deceptively simple question: which company organ is holding the meeting? A board meeting is a meeting of the directors, who generally manage the company's affairs. A general meeting is a meeting of the members, whose statutory and constitutional powers include particular decisions such as appointing or removing directors. Confusing them produces a wrong answer even when the case law is correct.
Use Chapter 2G.1 (ss 248A–248G) to locate the standard rules for directors' meetings. For members' meetings go to Chapter 2G.2—especially ss 249A onward for resolutions, calling, notice, attendance and voting. These are different legal routes, not interchangeable numerical labels.
2. How members obtain a general meeting: four distinct routes
First: ask the board. It may agree voluntarily to convene a meeting. Section 249C provides a replaceable rule concerning a director's power to call a members' meeting; the listed-company rule is separately addressed in s 249CA. Always check the constitution, the company's status and the applicable rule.
Second: require directors to act. Under Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 249D(1), members with at least 5% of the votes that may be cast at the general meeting may request a meeting. A 5% holding refers to voting power, not necessarily 5% of the number of people in the membership register. A valid request must also meet the form requirements in s 249D. Directors generally must call it within 21 days and arrange for it to occur within two months of the request.
Third: respond to directors' failure. If directors do not call the meeting within 21 days, Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 249E(1) gives the majority (by votes) of the members who made the s 249D request a route to convene it, subject to further requirements. Carefully explain the timing and the expense provisions; do not simply say ‘the shareholders can do anything’.
Fourth: call the meeting directly. Under Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 249F, members with at least 5% of the votes that may be cast at a general meeting may themselves call it; they must bear the expense of doing so. This is a separate path from s 249D, with different procedural consequences.
Examination trap — the historic 100-member rule. The lecturer warns that older notes may say that 100 members can force the directors to call a meeting. That alternative was removed from s 249D. But the 100-member route remains relevant to proposing a resolution for an existing general meeting under Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 249N(1)(b). Calling a meeting and placing business on the agenda are not the same entitlement.
Worked application: 1,000,000 votes, 40,000 voting rights
An activist group holds 40,000 of the 1,000,000 votes that could be cast. Divide 40,000 by 1,000,000 and multiply by 100: the group has 4%. It cannot satisfy a 5% threshold for s 249D or s 249F on those figures alone. If further supporters give it 20,000 more votes, the group holds 6%; subject to satisfying the statute's other requirements, it can consider those routes. It may alternatively examine s 249N if it wants a resolution put at the next qualifying general meeting.
3. Unanimous paper resolutions are not normal meeting votes
For a proprietary company with more than one member, Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 249A permits a circulating resolution without a physical meeting when the statutory signature conditions are met. It is not merely a majority written vote. A one-member company can use the signed written record procedure in Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 249B. The reason is practical: forcing one member to attend a ‘meeting’ with themselves would add ritual without meaningful deliberation.
4. Dividends: three questions before anybody receives money
The narrated Week 5 dividends lecture emphasises that announcing a dividend, legally creating a debt, and actually paying cash are distinct events. First determine who can authorise the dividend under the constitution and Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 254U. Second apply Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 254T (the relevant assets/liabilities, fairness to shareholders and creditor-prejudice constraints). Third assess when a debt arises under Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 254V.
Under s 254V(1), a decision fixing the amount or payment date does not alone create a debt: generally the debt arises on the fixed payment date and the decision may be revoked beforehand. But s 254V(2) supplies a different rule when the constitution provides for declaration of dividends—the debt arises when declared. For a solvency problem, the date on which enforceable payment obligations arise may therefore change the outcome. Section 254W also governs dividend rights; share class terms cannot be ignored.
Rule. Examine ss 254T, 254U and especially 254V(1)–(2), together with the constitution and directors' duties.
Application. If the directors merely determined a dividend under the ordinary s 254U procedure and the payment date has not arrived, the decision may be revocable under s 254V(1). If the constitution provides for declaration of a dividend that has occurred, s 254V(2) may produce an immediate debt; the outcome changes. A positive bank balance alone does not demonstrate compliance with s 254T or solvency.
Conclusion. Do not give a categorical yes/no until you obtain the constitution, resolution, dates, financial figures and creditor position.
5. Active learning — every answer explained
FAQ: Why is the ability to call a meeting not the ability to win the vote?
Meeting rights are procedural rights; they allow a matter to be considered. The eventual resolution still needs to satisfy the separate voting rules and subject-matter requirements. The lecturer's emphasis is that a 5% group may obtain a hearing without controlling 50% or 75% of voting power.
MCQ 1 — A 6% shareholder group wants the directors to call a meeting. Which provision should its adviser consider first?
A. s 248D B. s 249D C. s 254T D. s 131
MCQ 2 — Which is correct about the old 100-member route?
A. It still independently triggers s 249D B. It applies only to loans C. It remains relevant to s 249N resolutions D. It replaces the 5% voting rule everywhere