Corporate Law · By Dr Adrian Adams · Original-source teaching companion

Week 7 Tutorial — Promoters, secret profits and contracts before registration

Chapter 6 doctrine taught through the live tutorial timeline, fully reasoned applications and explanatory answers.

1. The opening question in the live Week 7 tutorial: When?

The Week 7 live tutorial applies Chapter 6, not the separate fundraising chapter. The lecturer repeatedly returned to a timeline. A company is a separate legal person only from registration. Therefore, before identifying duties, contractual liability or remedies, establish the date of registration and the date of every contract, commission and relevant decision. This simple chronology determines whether promoter law and pre-registration contract rules are relevant.

Issue-spotting timeline: BEFORE registration → promoter activity, possible fiduciary duties and a pre-registration contract. AT registration → the company comes into existence. AFTER registration → ask if the company ratified a prior contract and consider the ordinary rules governing directors, contracts and outsiders.

2. Why does a secret $12,000 commission matter?

The tutorial discusses a proposed business where a person helping establish the company may receive a $12,000 commission from arranging business premises. A student can make the mistake of beginning with whether the lease was cheap or expensive. The immediate issue is more fundamental: did the person personally benefit from a decision in which they owed loyalty to the company being promoted? A secret financial incentive can create an incentive to choose a transaction for personal gain rather than the proposed company's interests.

Promoters may owe fiduciary duties in relation to promoting a company. Under the equitable no-conflict and no-secret-profit principles, a promoter may need to disclose a material interest and obtain appropriately informed approval. Gluckstein v Barnes [1900] AC 240 is a classic secret-profit authority; Erlanger v New Sombrero Phosphate Co (1878) 3 App Cas 1218 is important to the concept of promoter disclosure and informed corporate approval. These cases are relevant not because their facts are identical to a modern property lease, but because they explain why personal gain and concealed conflicts are legally significant.

Tutorial-derived problem A — A person who helped set up a company receives an undisclosed $12,000 payment for procuring premises. Does the company have a claim?
Issue. Was the recipient a promoter at the relevant time, and was the payment a secret profit or a conflict involving promoter loyalty?
Rule. A person who undertakes the formation of a company may be subject to equitable fiduciary obligations in the promoter role. The no-profit and no-conflict principles require attention to informed consent and full disclosure; consider Gluckstein v Barnes and Erlanger.
Application. Start with dates: when was the company registered, when was the contract arranged and when did the commission arise? Determine who authorised the deal, whether the payment was disclosed to independent decision-makers, and whether meaningful informed consent occurred. An apparently advantageous lease does not necessarily erase an unauthorised secret profit. Equally, the fact of a commission alone does not prove every element of a fiduciary claim without examining the person's role and the authorisation process.
Conclusion/remedies. If an undisclosed fiduciary profit is established, relief may include an account of profits and other equitable remedies depending on facts. Advise on the evidence needed rather than promising a particular remedy.

3. Pre-registration contracts: the company cannot be bound before it exists

Section Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 131(1) deals with a person entering or purporting to enter a contract on behalf of or for the benefit of a company before registration. A subsequently registered company, or one reasonably identifiable with it, can become bound if it ratifies within the agreed time or a reasonable time. Do not say that registration itself automatically ratifies every contract.

Under Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 131(2), the person may be liable in damages to the other contracting party if the company is not registered or, once registered, does not ratify the contract or enter into a substitute within the relevant time. The statutory compensation mechanism is specific; do not confuse liability under s 131 with an ordinary contract signed after incorporation. Subsections (3)–(4) also provide court powers relevant to damages and the company's involvement. Section Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 132 addresses release from liability and the absence of a right to indemnity, while Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 133 addresses the operation of this statutory Part.

Tutorial-derived problem B — Before Coastal Fitness is registered, a founder signs a two-year lease ‘for Coastal Fitness Pty Ltd’. The company is registered later but never ratifies the lease. Who can the landlord pursue?
Issue. Whether the company became bound through timely ratification, and what liability the person signing the pre-registration contract may owe.
Rule. Apply s 131(1) to registration and ratification, then s 131(2) to the signer's potential damages liability if ratification or a substitute contract does not occur in the required time. Examine the possibility of orders under s 131(3) and any signed release under s 132.
Application. Prove the signature and registration dates and the parties' agreement concerning the deadline for ratification. Mere later registration is insufficient; on the stated facts, there is no ratification. Unless a different statutory or factual outcome applies, the person who purported to contract for the unborn company may be liable to the landlord in the statutory measure of damages.
Conclusion. The landlord should examine the s 131 claim against the signatory, while counsel must still inspect the exact documents, registration identity and any substitute contract or release.

4. After registration: do not confuse corporate capacity and an individual's authority

A registered company has statutory capacities under Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 124; but whether a human being can bind it is a separate question. Look at the person's actual authority, apparent authority, contracting method, and the statutory assumptions in Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 128–129, while considering Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 130. For execution of documents, see Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 127; a company may be bound in other legally recognised ways, and the absence of one signature pattern does not itself resolve every authority question.

5. Active learning and examiner's method

FAQ — Why is the registration date more important than the company's business name?

The name on the paper does not establish that a legal person existed when the document was signed. The law asks whether there was a registered company to contract, and, if not, whether the s 131 later-ratification mechanism applies.

MCQ 1 — A company is registered but does not ratify an earlier contract. Which statement is generally most accurate?

A. Registration alone binds the company   B. Section 131 may impose liability on the person who purported to contract   C. The landlord automatically has no remedy   D. Section 181 governs all pre-registration contracts

Answer: B. Section 131 requires analysis of the later registration, ratification and time limit; the signatory may become liable under s 131(2). The other answers skip essential statutory steps.

MCQ 2 — A promoter secretly receives a payment even though the proposed company obtains a competitive price. Is the competitive price necessarily a complete defence?

A. Yes   B. No; the undisclosed benefit and informed consent must still be analysed   C. Only if the commission was under $20,000   D. Only public companies can claim

Answer: B. Fiduciary law examines loyalties, conflicts and unauthorised benefits, not just whether the company suffered a readily measurable price disadvantage.

Short answer — Create a five-step client interview checklist

(1) Obtain the actual registration certificate and date; (2) date all negotiations, contract signatures and payments; (3) identify precisely who acted as promoter, director or agent at each stage; (4) obtain the constitution, disclosures, meeting minutes and purported ratification documents; (5) separate remedies arising under equitable promoter law, s 131 and ordinary post-registration authority rules. This sequencing converts a confusing factual narrative into legally distinct questions.
Source and verification note. This companion paraphrases the supplied recordings and teaches the associated law. It does not purport to reproduce the original tutorial question sheets word for word. Automated transcripts contain recognition errors; statute and case propositions must be checked against primary law before final publication. Source files are in the separate private audit archive, not publicly hosted here.