CORPORATE LAW · BY DR ADRIAN ADAMS

Plain-English explanation → statutory test → practical use

Case and legislation teaching atlas

The chapter teaching remains the primary text. This companion explains the legal function of frequently used provisions and decisions and helps students connect them to problems. It is original teaching prose; it does not replace reading the actual law or judgment.

Authority hierarchy: always cross-check against the current authorised Corporations Act (Federal Register of Legislation). AustLII is a useful unofficial per-section navigation source and may have a different update date. Older English cases and some unreported decisions have AustLII search links rather than direct full-text judgments. Those destinations have not all been independently browser-tested.

Statutory provisions: what each means, and why it belongs in your answer

CHAPTER 1 • STATUTORY ISSUE

ASIC Act 2001 (Cth), ss 8–12A

Establishes and regulates aspects of ASIC’s functions and powers. Always identify the precise statutory power needed for the advice; do not assume the regulator can perform any requested act.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 1 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Constitution s 51(xx)

A constitutional foundation for Commonwealth laws concerning certain corporations. In a problem, identify whether the constitutional source of federal legislative authority matters.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 1 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Partnership Act 1891 (Qld), ss 5–6

Identifies partnership relationships and evidentiary considerations. Compare whether the participants are carrying on business in common with a view to profit instead of assuming that sharing receipts is enough.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 2 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 112

Identifies company types. Ask which type the client has chosen and what special restrictions or rights follow.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 2 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 113

Proprietary-company restrictions, including membership and fundraising aspects. Check actual statutory elements when a proprietary company solicits investment.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 2 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 119

A company comes into existence when registered. That date determines why pre-registration contracts need their own statutory rules.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 2 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 124(1)

Corporate legal capacity and powers. A registered company can own property, incur debts and contract separately from its members.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 2 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 125

Effects of constitutional restrictions on corporate powers. Distinguish breach of internal limits from the external validity of transactions.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 3 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 117

The registration application and information required for ASIC registration. Identify essential formalities before assuming a company was formed.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 3 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 118

ASIC’s registration process and the certificate. Consult this when proving incorporation.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 3 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 134–135

Company internal management can use replaceable rules, a constitution or a combination. Determine which governance source applies before citing a default rule.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 3 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 136

Adoption, modification and repeal of constitutions. Check the required member decision and limitations.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 3 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 140

Statutory contractual effect of the constitution and replaceable rules. Analyse who seeks to enforce which right and in what capacity.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 3 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), Schedule, Part 2.5

Corporate criminal responsibility requires attribution rules and the particular offence. Do not assume a company is automatically guilty when an employee offends.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 4 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 9: director / officer

Definitions can extend beyond formal appointments. Examine actual conduct, functions and influence with the reasoning in Drysdale, Grimaldi and ASIC v King.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 4 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 198A

Replaceable rule on management of company business by or under directors. Identify what powers the board may exercise and the effect of any different constitution.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 4 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 201A, 201B

Minimum directors and appointment eligibility. Check the company type before applying a general requirement.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 4 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 203D

Special member-based removal procedure for directors of public companies. Determine company type, notice and any applicable restrictions.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 4 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 180(1)

Care and diligence standard for directors and officers. Compare the decision-maker’s conduct with the objective statutory benchmark.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 4 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 180(2)

Business judgment rule. Apply its conditions sequentially; do not treat it as a blanket permission to ignore statutory duties.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 249B

Written member resolutions in proprietary companies. Check whether this alternative to a general meeting is available and properly carried out.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 249C

Directors’ ability to call meetings. Identify who is exercising the power and any required procedure.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 249D(1)

Members with at least the relevant 5% voting entitlement can require directors to call a general meeting; determine aggregate qualifying votes and the requested resolutions.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 249E

If directors do not call a requested meeting in time, qualifying members may have a statutory calling mechanism, with procedural and cost consequences.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 249F

Members holding at least the statutory threshold can call a general meeting themselves; determine the correct source of power and cost rules.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 249H–249L

Meeting notice periods, recipients and content. Identify whether the company is listed and what special business or resolution appears.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 249N–249P

Members’ rights to propose resolutions and have accompanying statements circulated, subject to statutory conditions.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 249Q–249S

Purpose, holding and reasonable participation in meetings. Analyse actual access and opportunity to participate, including technology.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 249X–250C

Proxy rights and appointment formalities. Verify what the proxy may do and whether voting directions bind.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 254SA

A starting provision for the dividend rules. Read it with ss 254T–254W; do not treat a single subsection as the entire distribution regime.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 254T(1)(a)–(c)

Three cumulative tests concerning assets versus liabilities, fairness among shareholders, and material prejudice to creditors. Analyse each test and directors’ duties separately.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 5 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 254U–254W

Directors’ powers to determine dividends and related rights and payments. Check constitutional and class-right terms alongside statute.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 6 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 126

Company contracting through an authorised individual. Analyse agency authority and the identity of the person acting.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 6 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 127(1)–(4)

Formal company execution without or with a seal, deeds and alternative methods. Test the actual signature pattern and document form.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 6 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 128–129

Outsider statutory assumptions about internal regularity and officers. Determine if the outsider can rely on them; do not ignore knowledge/suspicion limits.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 6 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 130

Constructive notice rule for public company documents in the statutory framework. Do not infer actual knowledge merely because a document was lodged.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 6 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 131

Pre-registration contracts: examine later registration, ratification and liability of the person who acted before the company existed.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 6 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 132–133

Related controls and consequences around pre-registration contract liability. Explain what the company and contracting promoter did, and when.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 6 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 711(2)–(4)

In regulated prospectus circumstances, disclosure of promoters’ and other identified parties’ interests and benefits may be required. Ask whether a prospectus is required.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 7 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 254A–254D

Issue rights, terms and pre-emption; before modelling dilution, identify which class of shares is being issued and any existing members’ rights.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 7 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 1070A

Shares are personal property and can be transferred or transmitted subject to governing rules. Do not confuse shares with company-owned assets.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 7 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 260A

Financial assistance related to acquisitions of company shares is restricted by statutory conditions. Identify the relevant assistance, prejudice and approvals.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 7 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 256A–256D

Capital reductions require rules and procedures; distinguish lawful capital-management decisions from prejudicial distributions.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 7 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act Part 6D.2

Disclosure requirements for offers of securities. Determine whether an exemption applies before saying a prospectus is mandatory.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 7 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 708

Exemptions from regulated fundraising disclosure, dependent on the transaction and investors. Evaluate facts carefully.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 7 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act Part 2J.1

Share capital transactions, including buybacks and reductions, carry substantive and procedural protections.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 8 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 181(1)(a)

Directors and officers must act in good faith in the company’s best interests. Examine the interests of this specific company, not merely a nominating shareholder.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 8 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 181(1)(b)

Powers must be exercised for a proper purpose. Identify the particular power, its permitted purposes and directors’ substantial actual purpose.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 8 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 182–183

Restrictions on improper use of position and information. These are separate pathways from s 181 and require distinct factual analysis.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 8 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 184

Potential criminal offences for specified dishonest or reckless conduct. Apply the exact mental elements before alleging criminal liability.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 8 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 187

Wholly owned subsidiary best-interests provision with statutory conditions. A 60/40-owned subsidiary cannot simply assume it applies.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 8 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 1317E–1317J

Civil penalty consequences, pecuniary penalties and standing require the exact applicable statutory mechanism and current version.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 8 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 1324

Statutory injunction provisions potentially relevant to threatened or actual contraventions. Standing and remedy requirements matter.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 9 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 191

Disclosure of a material personal interest by a director, subject to specified exceptions; analyse the exact interest and required notice.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 9 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 194

Proprietary-company interests and voting rules where applicable. Do not automatically apply public-company restrictions.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 9 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act s 195

Public-company restrictions on conflicted directors participating in board decisions, subject to statutory exceptions.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

CHAPTER 9 • STATUTORY ISSUE

Corporations Act ss 182–183

A conflicted director’s use of position and company information may create distinct duties and remedies.

How to apply: write the provision’s actual elements, connect each element to a specific fact, discuss counterarguments and finish with the legal consequence. Do not cite the section as a conclusion by itself.

Leading cases: facts, rule and when to use them

CHAPTER 2 • Direct judgment

Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd

Facts and issue. A family-controlled business was incorporated, and creditors challenged whether the company was truly distinct from its controlling shareholder.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The House of Lords treated a properly incorporated company as a separate legal person. Control by one shareholder does not alone make the company the shareholder’s agent.

When to use the case. Use when asked who owns company assets or owes company debts. Then separately consider guarantees, statutory duties and exceptional remedies.

CHAPTER 2 • Direct judgment

Lee v Lee’s Air Farming Ltd

Facts and issue. A controlling shareholder also worked as the company’s pilot and died while flying. His widow claimed compensation arising from an employment relationship.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. Separate personality meant the individual could have an employment relationship with his company despite controlling it.

When to use the case. Apply when a problem incorrectly assumes an owner cannot also be an employee; inspect the actual employment and insurance scheme.

CHAPTER 2 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Macaura v Northern Assurance Co Ltd

Facts and issue. An owner insured timber in his own name after transferring it to the company. The timber was destroyed by fire.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. A shareholder’s interest in shares is not legal or beneficial ownership of the company’s assets; the personal insurance claim failed in that setting.

When to use the case. Ask precisely whose property was insured, mortgaged or transferred; do not equate 100% share ownership with personal ownership of land or timber.

CHAPTER 2 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Gilford Motor Co Ltd v Horne

Facts and issue. A former employee subject to a restraint used a company as part of an arrangement to solicit his former employer’s customers.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The corporate form did not prevent an injunction where the company was used as a device to evade the existing obligation.

When to use the case. Avoid saying the veil is lifted whenever conduct seems unfair. Identify the prior duty, the device and the remedy.

CHAPTER 2 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Jones v Lipman

Facts and issue. A seller tried to avoid completing a land sale by transferring the land to a company he controlled.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The court regarded the company arrangement as a means of evading an existing contractual obligation, supporting specific performance.

When to use the case. Use in exceptional evasion scenarios; distinguish straightforward company debt from deliberate attempts to defeat a particular right.

CHAPTER 3 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Royal British Bank v Turquand

Facts and issue. An outsider relied on company borrowing despite an internal approval requirement said not to have been satisfied.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The indoor management doctrine protects outsiders entitled to assume regular internal procedures in proper circumstances.

When to use the case. Start with actual authority, then internal regularity and the statutory assumptions under ss 128–129; check notice or suspicion.

CHAPTER 3 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Eley v Positive Government Security Life Assurance Co Ltd

Facts and issue. An individual sought to rely on a company article appointing him solicitor in his external professional capacity.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The constitutional contract does not automatically make outside professional rights enforceable as membership rights.

When to use the case. Use with s 140 to separate rights claimed as a member from rights under a distinct service contract.

CHAPTER 3 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Hickman v Kent or Romney Marsh Sheep-Breeders Association

Facts and issue. A member’s dispute with an association raised whether an arbitration clause in the constitutional rules governed the disagreement.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The membership-focused constitutional arrangements could be enforceable for matters arising in the relevant capacity.

When to use the case. Compare with Eley: ask whether the claimant invokes rights as a member and whether the statutory contract covers the issue.

CHAPTER 3 • Direct judgment

Tesco Supermarkets Ltd v Nattrass

Facts and issue. A company faced proceedings linked to a misleading price indication in a store and argued that proper systems existed.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The decision distinguished a company’s directing mind and delegated employees in the particular statutory context.

When to use the case. When attributing conduct or knowledge to a company, identify the actual statute and its attribution rules rather than applying one universal test.

CHAPTER 4 • Law report citation verified; neutral citation not independently confirmed

Corporate Affairs Commission v Drysdale

Facts and issue. A person continued acting as a director despite the expiry or invalidity of formal authority to hold that office.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The High Court examined the reality of occupying and discharging director functions, underpinning liability of a de facto director.

When to use the case. Use with s 9 when formal appointment records conflict with conduct. The established report citation is (1978) 141 CLR 236; do not assume an unverified neutral citation.

CHAPTER 4 • Direct judgment

Grimaldi v Chameleon Mining NL (No 2)

Facts and issue. A corporate adviser participated in company affairs and transactions raising questions of office, influence and improper benefit.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The Full Federal Court explained the fact-sensitive de facto director/officer tests and fiduciary consequences; no single badge decides the matter.

When to use the case. Test actual performance of board-level functions, relationship to directors and material influence; then analyse duties and remedies separately.

CHAPTER 4 • Direct judgment

ASIC v King

Facts and issue. An executive in a wider group exercised substantial influence over a subsidiary’s financial affairs despite not holding a formal officer title in it.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The High Court interpreted the statutory definition of “officer” by substance, not merely formal appointment.

When to use the case. Use s 9 officer definition to assess capacity to affect financial standing. Do not equate title with legal status.

CHAPTER 4 • Direct judgment

Buzzle Operations Pty Ltd (in liq) v Apple Computer Australia Pty Ltd

Facts and issue. A major supplier’s extensive commercial involvement with a reseller raised allegations that it controlled the reseller’s directors.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. Commercial influence or intense contractual monitoring does not automatically make a supplier a shadow director; the facts and direction of board behaviour matter.

When to use the case. Distinguish external leverage from directors being accustomed to act on instructions. Cite the procedural stage and specific judgment accurately.

CHAPTER 4 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Automatic Self-Cleansing Filter Syndicate Co Ltd v Cuninghame

Facts and issue. Members sought to direct directors to sell an undertaking, contrary to the distribution of power under the company constitution.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The allocation of management powers to directors could not simply be displaced by an ordinary shareholder resolution.

When to use the case. Begin with constitution and s 198A where applicable; ask whether members have a special-resolution or other statutory route.

CHAPTER 4 • Direct judgment

Walker v Wimborne

Facts and issue. Directors allowed the finances of related companies to become intertwined, raising questions about whether one company could support others at its expense.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The separate legal interests of each company matter even within a corporate group.

When to use the case. Identify the particular company owed the duty, financial benefit and detriment; do not describe the whole group as one legal person.

CHAPTER 5 • Direct judgment

Gambotto v WCP Ltd

Facts and issue. Majority holders sought a constitutional amendment enabling compulsory acquisition of minority-held shares.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The High Court imposed strict limits on amendments seeking to expropriate minority interests.

When to use the case. Analyse purpose, proper process and fairness when amendments affect a minority’s shares; do not assume majority votes automatically suffice.

CHAPTER 5 • Direct judgment

Australasian Centre for Corporate Responsibility v Commonwealth Bank of Australia

Facts and issue. A shareholder advocacy group sought to put climate-related matters before a company meeting and challenged restrictions on resolutions.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The litigation explored the distinction between member discussion and attempts to direct board management.

When to use the case. In shareholder-meeting problems, separate procedural rights to propose or discuss matters from the legal power to direct corporate policy.

CHAPTER 6 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Erlanger v New Sombrero Phosphate Co

Facts and issue. Promoters arranged for a new company to acquire an island and mining interests at a profit, in circumstances raising disclosure and independent approval questions.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. Promoters stood in a fiduciary position and needed proper disclosure; an inadequately independent board could not necessarily validate the transaction.

When to use the case. Look for promoter involvement, undisclosed profits, independence of decision-makers, rescission and practical remedy limits.

CHAPTER 6 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Gluckstein v Barnes

Facts and issue. A syndicate promoted a company acquiring a property and concealed a separate financial gain in the transaction.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The undisclosed promoter profit was recoverable despite other disclosed aspects of the transaction.

When to use the case. Separate genuinely disclosed profit from hidden profit, identify to whom disclosure was adequate and formulate an account-of-profits remedy.

CHAPTER 6 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Tracy v Mandalay Pty Ltd

Facts and issue. People involved in a scheme profited through transactions with a newly formed company although some did not personally organise its formation.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The High Court recognised that passive beneficiaries of promotion arrangements could be promoters in the relevant circumstances.

When to use the case. Avoid limiting promoter duties to the person who lodged the registration form; examine economic participation and formation benefit.

CHAPTER 6 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Freeman & Lockyer v Buckhurst Park Properties (Mangal) Ltd

Facts and issue. An architect dealt with an individual effectively acting as managing director with board acquiescence, despite lack of formal appointment.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The company’s representation through its conduct can support apparent authority where established through those entitled to make it.

When to use the case. Identify representation from the company, reliance, and the agent’s apparent scope; the agent’s own assertion is insufficient.

CHAPTER 6 • Direct judgment

Crabtree-Vickers Pty Ltd v Australian Direct Mail Advertising and Addressing Co Pty Ltd

Facts and issue. A commercial transaction raised whether an intermediary’s words or dealings could bind the company through ostensible authority.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The High Court emphasised the need for an attributable representation of authority; an agent cannot manufacture their own authority.

When to use the case. Ask who made the representation and whether that person had authority to make it before relying on appearances.

CHAPTER 6 • Direct judgment

Northside Developments Pty Ltd v Registrar-General

Facts and issue. Company land was mortgaged in circumstances involving an unusual transaction and suspected failure to obtain proper company approval.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. Outsider assumptions have limits, including circumstances putting the outsider on inquiry; reliance is not unlimited.

When to use the case. Evaluate transaction benefit, unusual signatures or roles, red flags, actual knowledge and statutory ss 128–129 assumptions.

CHAPTER 7 • Direct judgment

Sons of Gwalia Ltd v Margaretic

Facts and issue. An investor sought to prove compensation connected with a company’s securities alongside other creditors in insolvency.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The High Court considered the status of a shareholder-related damages claim under then-applicable statutory law; legislative responses require careful current-law checking.

When to use the case. Do not transplant the historical result uncritically; identify the current statutory provisions and whether a claim is debt, equity or subordinated.

CHAPTER 8 • Direct judgment

Howard Smith Ltd v Ampol Petroleum Ltd

Facts and issue. Directors issued new shares during a control contest, altering voting power, while arguing the transaction had commercial benefits.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The Privy Council emphasised that directors’ share-issue power must be exercised for permitted purposes; changing control can be an improper substantial purpose.

When to use the case. State the precise power, legitimate capital objective, actual decisive purpose and evidence; separate honest belief from objective permitted purpose.

CHAPTER 8 • Direct judgment

Whitehouse v Carlton Hotel Pty Ltd

Facts and issue. A family company’s governing director allotted special voting shares to influence who would control the company after his death.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The High Court treated an improper purpose in share allotment as a ground for avoiding the allocation, even where a director claimed to act for future company stability.

When to use the case. Apply to voting dilution and control disputes, exploring dominant or substantial purpose and the effect on the relevant class of shares.

CHAPTER 8 • Direct judgment

ASIC v Adler

Facts and issue. Related-party transactions used corporate funds in circumstances attracting civil penalty proceedings and multiple directors’ duty questions.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The case illustrates the need to identify distinct duties, conflicts, benefits, processes and available remedies.

When to use the case. Separate ss 180–183 and related-party provisions rather than asserting every breach follows automatically from a poor investment.

CHAPTER 9 • Direct judgment

Chan v Zacharia

Facts and issue. Former medical practice partners disputed a lease opportunity obtained by one of them after dissolution.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The High Court addressed fiduciary loyalty, conflicts and appropriation of an opportunity arising from the relationship.

When to use the case. In Chapter 9 use as supporting fiduciary principle, while keeping the corporate statutory regime and the actual company relationship distinct.

CHAPTER 9 • AustLII search / citation verification needed

Kinsela v Russell Kinsela Pty Ltd

Facts and issue. A company experiencing serious financial difficulty made arrangements benefitting insiders, putting creditor interests at issue.

Decision and reasoning in plain English. The case informs how corporate interests must be considered when financial distress affects creditors.

When to use the case. Use cautiously: distinguish solvent from insolvent or near-insolvent circumstances, and identify which remedy and claimant is legally available.

Further case authorities in the original book

These remain in the preserved original manuscript and source index. A full judgment-by-judgment account of their facts and holdings has not been independently completed in this supplement:

Source-integrity rule: never present an AustLII search URL as a verified judgment. For full publication certification, verify exact judge, court, citation, relevant holding and currency of every paragraph-level reference.