CORPORATE LAW · BY DR ADRIAN ADAMS

Supplementary original teaching exercises

Explained FAQs, MCQs and short-answer answers

These questions were developed as extra practice for the study guide. They are not represented as the university’s original tutorials. The original Week 8 → Week 9 tutorial remains available separately, with its original questions and comprehensive answers.

Original Week 8 forum → Week 9 tutorial with model answers · All available tutorial sources · Statute and case explanations

Chapter 1 — additional applied learning

FAQ: Why is a partnership not simply a small company?

A partnership generally involves carrying on business in common with a view to profit under the applicable partnership law; a registered company is a separate legal person. Partnership liability, ownership and governance therefore differ.

MCQ-style true/false or issue selection

Question: A consultant trades with a friend under a shared name and both split profits. Is limited liability automatic?

Show answer and why

No. First test whether a partnership exists under the relevant Partnership Act and whether incorporation occurred. The use of a trading name is not a certificate of incorporation.

Short-answer question

Question: Explain why separate legal personality changes risk allocation.

Show complete reasoning

Registration creates the separate company person; it can own assets and incur debts. The members normally hold shares rather than the assets. Personal guarantees and wrongdoing remain separate liability questions.

Read complete Chapter 1 teaching · Study guide

Chapter 2 — additional applied learning

FAQ: Can the sole shareholder own the company’s land personally?

No. Owning all the shares does not itself transfer company assets to the shareholder. Salomon and Macaura help keep ownership categories distinct.

MCQ-style true/false or issue selection

Question: A shareholder says: “I own 100%, so I can use the company’s warehouse as security for my personal loan without the company’s consent.” Is that safe?

Show answer and why

No. The company owns the warehouse. Authority, directors’ duties and related-party rules must be considered; ownership of shares is not personal title to land.

Short-answer question

Question: Why can the controlling shareholder also be an employee?

Show complete reasoning

Separate personality lets the company contract with an individual who also owns shares. Lee illustrates the point, subject to the relevant employment facts and statutes.

Read complete Chapter 2 teaching · Study guide

Chapter 3 — additional applied learning

FAQ: Is a company constitution an ordinary service contract with every outsider?

No. Section 140 creates specified statutory contractual relationships. Eley illustrates why an external capacity is different from membership rights.

MCQ-style true/false or issue selection

Question: A constitution names a member as perpetual company lawyer. Can the member automatically sue for lifetime fees under s 140?

Show answer and why

Not simply on that basis. Ask whether the claimed right is as a member; a separate service contract may be required.

Short-answer question

Question: What should you check first when the board ignores a replaceable rule?

Show complete reasoning

Whether the rule applies, whether a constitution altered it, whether a mandatory statutory provision controls and who has standing to enforce it.

Read complete Chapter 3 teaching · Study guide

Chapter 4 — additional applied learning

FAQ: Is a person without the director title always free of directors’ duties?

No. Section 9 and the cases on de facto directors, shadow directors and officers look beyond labels to functions and influence.

MCQ-style true/false or issue selection

Question: An investor tells directors precisely how to vote each month; they comply without independent judgment. Is the investor certainly a shadow director?

Show answer and why

Not certainly. Apply statutory definition, any exclusions, evidence of repeated directions, and the nature of advice. Mere commercial leverage may be insufficient.

Short-answer question

Question: What is the business judgment rule NOT?

Show complete reasoning

It is not an automatic defence to every breach. Section 180(2) has conditions and concerns the s 180 care-and-diligence duty, not all other director obligations.

Read complete Chapter 4 teaching · Study guide

Chapter 5 — additional applied learning

FAQ: Can a shareholder with 5% automatically dismiss the board?

No. A qualifying 5% may have a meeting requisition right under s 249D. Removal then depends on the separate removal rules, valid meeting process and votes.

MCQ-style true/false or issue selection

Question: Members with exactly 5% of eligible votes request a meeting but the directors dislike the proposal. May directors disregard the request simply for that reason?

Show answer and why

No automatic discretion follows from disliking the proposal. Check the formal s 249D requirements, the nature of the proposed resolution and the calling timetable.

Short-answer question

Question: Why is accounting profit not enough to declare a dividend?

Show complete reasoning

Section 254T imposes statutory restrictions. The board must also assess class rights, creditors and directors’ duties. Profit is neither the complete permission nor the only relevant consideration.

Read complete Chapter 5 teaching · Study guide

Chapter 6 — additional applied learning

FAQ: What is the difference between a promoter’s duty and the pre-registration contract rules?

Promoter fiduciary duties concern loyalty, conflict and disclosure during company formation. Sections 131–133 allocate contractual consequences where someone contracts before the company exists.

MCQ-style true/false or issue selection

Question: A promoter buys an asset for $70,000, sells it to the new company for $120,000 and hides the profit. What matters most?

Show answer and why

Identify promoter status, undisclosed conflict/profit, independent disclosure and approval, and remedies such as account or rescission. Separately check the contract timeline.

Short-answer question

Question: Can an agent prove their own apparent authority simply by saying “I am authorised”?

Show complete reasoning

No. The representation generally must be attributable to the company through someone with relevant authority. Examine Freeman & Lockyer and Crabtree-Vickers.

Read complete Chapter 6 teaching · Study guide

Chapter 7 — additional applied learning

FAQ: Does borrowing money dilute ownership?

An ordinary loan does not by itself create new shares; an equity issue can alter voting proportions. However convertible instruments and covenants require their own terms analysis.

MCQ-style true/false or issue selection

Question: There are 100 voting shares, and the company issues 100 more to an outside investor. An existing 40-share holder then owns what percentage?

Show answer and why

40 ÷ 200 × 100 = 20%. The holder’s shares stayed at 40 but the denominator doubled; discuss pre-emption and proper-purpose duties before assuming the issue was lawful.

Short-answer question

Question: Why can a securities offer need disclosure even if the money is urgently needed?

Show complete reasoning

Corporate fundraising protects investors through regulated offers. First test the offer type and statutory exemptions; urgency does not itself eliminate compliance.

Read complete Chapter 7 teaching · Study guide

Chapter 8 — additional applied learning

FAQ: Why can an honest director breach the proper-purpose duty?

Honesty and proper purpose are separate requirements. A director may genuinely believe the company benefits while using a specific power for an object outside its lawful purpose.

MCQ-style true/false or issue selection

Question: Directors issue shares primarily to stop a takeover, but also raise a small amount of useful cash. Is the issue automatically valid?

Show answer and why

No. Identify the power and its permitted uses, analyse substantial actual purpose with Howard Smith and Whitehouse, and consider remedies and the evidence of motive.

Short-answer question

Question: Does s 187 protect every subsidiary director who follows parent-company instructions?

Show complete reasoning

No. The provision is conditional, including a wholly owned subsidiary requirement. Examine the ownership and statutory elements rather than presuming group interests prevail.

Read complete Chapter 8 teaching · Study guide

Learning outcomes should be tested against the current legislation and actual judgments. These are supplementary examples, not official Bond University marking solutions or a guarantee of any particular assessment grade.