New: essential-reading teaching for Chapter 7. The prescribed textbook topics are explained in original plain English, with a statutory issue map, an applied problem, FAQs and reasoned MCQs.
Open the source-integrated guideNew: beginner-first companion for Chapter 7. A plain-English lecturer-style explanation, statutory map, worked IRAC example, FAQs and MCQs with explanations.
Start the easy-to-read guideCHAPTER SEVEN · WEEK 7 LECTURE
Financing a Company: Equity, Debt and Fundraising
CHAPTER 7 · LECTURER'S FUNDRAISING EXAMPLES · ADDITIONAL EXPLANATORY TEACHING
How Companies Raise Money — Shares, Loans, Investor Protection and Real-World Prospectuses
A company may have a valuable idea but not enough money to build it. The first decision is whether to ask other people to become owners or to borrow from creditors. From this simple choice follow some of the most important legal questions in corporate law: who controls the company, who takes the risk of failure, whether investors receive enough information, and whether the company is permitted to use or return its capital. The accompanying lecture images show the lecturer moving between share-offer documents, ASIC registers and the statutory rules. They provide a practical starting point for reading the existing Chapter 7.
7A.1 The actual economic choice: ownership or a claim for repayment?
Imagine Gold Coast Surf Technology Pty Ltd needs $1 million to manufacture new electric surfboards. If it issues shares, the people who contribute money become members. They generally receive a residual investment: the economic upside depends on how the business performs, and dividends are not automatic. Depending on share terms, they may vote on matters reserved to members. When the company is wound up, creditors are dealt with before surplus value can be distributed to shareholders. Equity therefore exposes an investor to business risk but may also give an ownership stake in the company's success.
Alternatively, the company may borrow $1 million from a bank or another investor. The lender does not automatically become a member. It normally receives an enforceable promise to repay the principal, and may also be entitled to interest, security, financial covenants and remedies for default. A lender with properly created and perfected security may be better protected than an unsecured lender, but the precise insolvency ranking depends on applicable security and insolvency law, not merely the label 'bank'.
Worked calculation — what is dilution?
Before an issue, 100 shares exist. Ava holds 60 and Ben holds 40. Ava has 60 ÷ 100 = 60% of the issued shares. The company issues 50 new ordinary shares to an investor for cash. There are now 100 + 50 = 150 shares. Ava still has 60 shares, but her share of the total is now 60 ÷ 150 = 40%. Ben has 40 ÷ 150 = 26.67%, and the new investor has 50 ÷ 150 = 33.33%. The pre-existing holders did not surrender a share, yet their proportional voting and economic position has changed. Whether issuing those shares is lawful also depends on corporate governance, share terms, the constitution and directors' proper purpose; a mathematically accurate calculation is not a substitute for those questions.
7A.2 Different classes of shares — the company can offer different bargains
Not all shares have identical rights. Ordinary shares typically participate in the company's residual fortunes. Preference shares may have priority over ordinary shares in receiving specified dividends or return of capital. Some preference shares may carry restricted voting rights, and some may be redeemable. Read the actual terms of issue: the word 'preference' does not guarantee that every preference share has the same rights or that payment is unconditional.
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 254A(1)(a)–(c) confirms the company's share-issue powers include bonus shares, preference shares (including redeemable preference shares) and partly-paid shares. Section 254A(2)(a)–(e) requires the rights attached to preference shares about repayment of capital, participation in surplus assets and profits, cumulative and non-cumulative dividends, voting, and priority of payment to be set out in the constitution (if any) or approved by special resolution. Section 254A(3)(a)–(c) addresses when redemption may occur. For actual redemption, consult ss 254J–254L: an issue power is not the same thing as unrestricted permission to redeem.
7A.3 Changing class rights — who must agree?
Suppose the company has Class A shares carrying two votes per share and Class B shares carrying one. Directors propose to change the Class A terms so that they carry only one vote. That may be a variation of rights attached to a class. A formal rights change should not be confused with the fact that a new issue dilutes a shareholder's percentage. First identify the right, then decide whether the proposal legally varies it.
Under s 246B, the starting question is whether the company's constitution sets out a procedure for varying or cancelling the class rights. If so, the statutory regime points to that procedure. If not, the Act supplies a pathway involving a special resolution of the company and either a special resolution of the class or written consent of members entitled to at least 75% of votes in that class. Other provisions in ss 246B–246G may be engaged, including treatment of some transactions as variations, notification and court challenge rights. A lawyer should not answer this problem by saying that a bare board resolution is necessarily sufficient.
7A.4 Reducing share capital — why creditors matter
Companies may wish to return excess paid-up capital to members, cancel shares or restructure a bloated capital base. But the company is a separate legal person and its assets are a source of payment for creditors. Historically, the common law was wary of returning subscribed capital to shareholders while leaving creditors exposed. The case of Trevor v Whitworth (1887) 12 App Cas 409 is an important historical illustration of the capital-maintenance principle; it is not a substitute for the current statutory pathways authorising reductions and buy-backs.
Section 256A states the purpose of the rules: addressing insolvency risks, ensuring fairness between shareholders and requiring disclosure of material information. Section 256B(1) addresses the conditions for a reduction of share capital that is not otherwise authorised by law, including that the reduction must be fair and reasonable to shareholders as a whole, must not materially prejudice the company's ability to pay creditors, and must be approved under s 256C. Section 256C prescribes shareholder-approval procedures, including differences between equal and selective reductions. In every problem identify the type of reduction before applying the relevant approval pathway.
Example: a company with $2 million in cash and no immediate business expansion plans proposes to return $500,000 to shareholders. A director may think that the payment is sensible, but the adviser must first examine liabilities, cash-flow projections, how different shareholders are treated, relevant approval and disclosure procedures, and directors' solvency obligations. The simple statement that the company 'has enough cash today' is not the same as a complete statutory or commercial assessment.
7A.5 Financial assistance — when the company helps someone buy its own shares
Imagine the purchaser of a majority shareholding asks the target company to guarantee the purchaser's acquisition loan. The target's assets would then support the purchaser's debt. That raises a distinct question: is the company providing financial assistance for the acquisition of shares in itself or a holding company?
Section 260A(1)(a)–(c) sets out three alternative pathways: the assistance must not materially prejudice the interests of the company or its shareholders or its ability to pay creditors; or it must be approved under s 260B; or it must fall within s 260C's exemptions. The alternatives are not three cumulative requirements. Sections 260A(2)–(3) explain that assistance can occur before or after acquisition and can involve different means of acquiring shares. Section 260B includes voting, disclosure and ASIC-notification procedures; s 260C contains defined exemptions. Separate questions about directors' duties, solvency and purpose still matter even when a statutory route is available.
In Connective Services Pty Ltd v Slea Pty Ltd [2019] HCA 33, the High Court addressed whether company-funded legal proceedings to enforce pre-emptive share rights could amount to financial assistance. The significance for students is that financial assistance is not confined to a simple cheque written to the purchaser; examine the substance and effect of what the company actually does. The court's analysis also makes it important to assess the alleged prejudice in context, rather than presume that any assistance is automatically prohibited.
7A.6 Loan capital and debentures — not another kind of shareholder
The lecture shifts from share capital to loan capital, explaining that people who advance money are creditors even if they receive formal, tradable securities. A debenture is a form of debt security of a company or other body meeting the Act's definition, subject to the statutory exclusions and detail in s 9. A debenture can be secured or unsecured. The company's general power to issue debentures is recognised in s 124(1)(b), but the power to issue is not a waiver of fundraising disclosure or debenture-holder-protection obligations.
Chapter 2L imposes important protections on some debenture offers. In specified circumstances, s 283AA(1) requires a trust deed and eligible trustee, with ss 283AB–283AC supplying related requirements. Do not say that every ordinary loan or every debenture automatically attracts identical procedures: check the transaction and applicable statutory triggers.
7A.7 Public fundraising — prospectuses, ASIC searches and real documents
The lecturer demonstrates real-world fundraising materials using prospectus-style documents, public company share classes and the ASIC website. Those examples are teaching illustrations: foreign companies' offerings may be governed by overseas rules, so a SpaceX or Anthropic share document is not evidence that the corresponding Australian statutory requirements have been met.
In Australia, Chapter 6D provides the central fundraising disclosure regime. As a starting point, s 706 requires disclosure for an offer of securities that needs disclosure under the chapter. Section 708 provides exceptions, including specified small-scale, sophisticated or professional investor offers if all conditions are met. The legal task is to classify the issuer, the security, the offer and the offerees before concluding whether a prospectus or another disclosure document is required. ASIC's fundraising guidance explains the types of disclosure documents; ASIC Regulatory Guide 254 (April 2026) explains procedures for offering securities under disclosure documents.
When researching a public offer, the lawyer should locate the issuer's current documents, confirm who is making the offer, examine the terms of the securities, search the relevant company register, and assess risk disclosure. ASIC register results help identify corporations and recorded information; they are not themselves an endorsement of the company or investment.
7A.8 Key cases — what each teaches and when to use it
Trevor v Whitworth (1887) 12 App Cas 409 — historical capital maintenance
Issue: Could a company acquire its own shares in the circumstances governed by the historical English legislation? Reasoning and result: The House of Lords treated the unauthorised purchase as inconsistent with the capital-maintenance rules then applicable. Why it matters: It explains the origin of the concern that capital returned to members may deprive creditors of a pool of assets. Use: Introduce the policy behind ss 256A–256C, not as the controlling present-day Australian procedure for reductions or buy-backs.
Connective Services Pty Ltd v Slea Pty Ltd [2019] HCA 33 — what financial assistance can involve
Facts: Share-transfer arrangements and pre-emption rights produced litigation about the companies' decision to fund proceedings relating to a share acquisition. Issue: Whether those proceedings involved financial assistance contrary to s 260A. Reasoning: The High Court examined what counted as assistance and the statutory requirement of material prejudice. Why it matters: Company resources can be deployed to assist an acquisition in ways more subtle than directly lending purchase money. Use: In a s 260A problem analyse the practical effect, prejudice comparison and the three lawful routes, not only the name of the transaction. Read the official High Court judgment.
7A.9 How to answer a corporate finance problem: a legal decision pathway
- Client and objective: Is the client the company, board, shareholder, proposed investor, lender or regulator? What outcome do they seek?
- Classify the instrument: Ordinary shares, preference shares, redeemable preference shares, loan, debenture, convertible security or combination?
- Check powers and authority: Does the company have capacity (s 124)? Who authorised the transaction? Are any constitutional restrictions or directors' duties engaged?
- Check capital rules: Is it an issue, variation of rights, reduction, buy-back, redemption or financial assistance? Different parts of the Act apply.
- Check disclosure: If offering securities, does Chapter 6D require disclosure and does an exception apply? What ASIC filings or procedures are necessary?
- Apply actual facts: Calculate dilution, identify voting changes, test prejudice to creditors, inspect transaction documents and compare positions before and after the proposal.
- Counterarguments and remedy: What can the other party say? Can defects be cured by approval or alternative structuring? Are injunctions, penalties, rescission or director liability relevant?
- Give practical advice: Give the client a conditional conclusion, outstanding evidence required and risk-aware next steps.
7A.10 Original teaching problems and full explanatory IRAC answers
These are new original practice problems written for this teaching integration. They supplement, and do not replace or purport to reproduce, the Bond University tutorial question sheets.
Practice problem 1 — Ordinary shares and dilution
Sun Coast Robotics Pty Ltd has 120 ordinary shares: Elena owns 72 and Tom 48. The board proposes to issue 80 further ordinary shares to a new investor to finance a factory. Tom says the board cannot dilute him without his consent. Advise the company and Tom.
Issue. How will the ownership percentages change, and is dilution itself unlawful? Rule. The company has statutory share-issue capacity under s 124(1)(a), subject to its constitution, any applicable statutory pre-emptive rights or other restrictions, governance and the directors' duties, including proper purpose under s 181(1)(b). Application. Before the issue Elena owns 72/120 = 60% and Tom 48/120 = 40%. Afterwards there are 200 shares. Elena owns 72/200 = 36%, Tom owns 48/200 = 24%, and the new investor 80/200 = 40%. Tom's percentage falls by 16 percentage points, but percentage change alone does not establish legal invalidity. We need the constitution, issue terms, applicable company type, directors' deliberations and purpose. If the dominant purpose was legitimately raising capital, that supports validity; if the dominant purpose was manipulating votes, proper-purpose concerns arise. Conclusion. The maths is clear, but the legal conclusion is conditional. Advise the board to document financing need, alternatives, approvals and why the issue is a proper exercise of power.
Practice problem 2 — Variation of class voting rights
Ocean Energy Ltd has ordinary A shares with two votes each and B shares with one. The directors resolve to make A shares one-vote shares without consulting members. The constitution does not specify a variation procedure. A class holder objects.
Issue. Can the rights attached to A shares be changed by board resolution alone? Rule. Section 246B and the related provisions govern variation or cancellation of rights attached to a class. Absent a constitution procedure, the statutory company and affected-class approval pathway (or qualifying class written consent) must be examined. Application. Removing one of two votes is a change to an identified right attached to the class, not simply a reduced percentage caused by new shares. A unilateral board resolution does not demonstrate the required statutory approvals. The legal adviser must check notice, class approval, the applicable majority thresholds and any challenge rights under the connected provisions. Conclusion. The purported change cannot be accepted as valid merely because the board favours it; the company should stop implementing it pending compliance and review of the constitution and ss 246B–246G.
Practice problem 3 — A return of capital and creditors
Harbour Equipment Ltd proposes to return $900,000 capital to its shareholders. It has $1.2 million cash, but $700,000 supplier invoices fall due within three months. The directors approve the payment because 'cash exceeds current debts'. Advise.
Issue. Is the capital reduction lawfully authorised and prudently funded? Rule. The purpose provision s 256A identifies creditor protection, shareholder fairness and adequate information. Section 256B(1) imposes statutory requirements for reductions not otherwise authorised; s 256C deals with approval. Solvency and directors' duties may raise independent issues. Application. The proposal would leave $300,000 immediately after payment, less than invoices due soon, before allowing for operating costs. The simple numerical comparison is a warning of material prejudice to paying creditors; however cash-flow projections and precise liabilities must be established. The problem says nothing about fairness among members or the appropriate shareholder approval. The directors' assertion therefore fails to address critical elements. Counterargument. If substantial reliable receivables will be realised before liabilities fall due, cash-flow evidence may alter the assessment, but speculation is inadequate. Conclusion. Do not proceed on the current information; obtain forecasts, confirm reduction type, obtain proper approvals and assess fairness and creditor impact.
Practice problem 4 — Company guarantee for a share purchaser
Two investors buy control of Coastal Bio Pty Ltd. The bank asks Coastal Bio itself to guarantee the investors' acquisition debt. The board says shareholders voted in favour, so the deal must be lawful.
Issue. Does the guarantee involve regulated financial assistance under s 260A, and has a lawful route been satisfied? Rule. Under s 260A(1) assistance may be permissible where the no-material-prejudice route applies, or the precise shareholder approval procedure under s 260B is met, or an exemption under s 260C applies. The statutory pathways are alternatives. Application. A guarantee of a purchaser's debt can expose the company's assets to the acquisition risk. The fact that shareholders held a vote is not enough without evidence of compliance with s 260B's voting exclusions, disclosure, required notices and ASIC lodgments, where that route is used. Nor does approval answer every question about directors' duties or insolvency. The company should compare its ability to pay creditors and shareholder interests before and after the assistance. Authority. Connective Services teaches that the substance of assistance must be assessed. Conclusion. The proposal is not automatically lawful; test each statutory route and the associated procedural requirements before any guarantee is executed.
Practice problem 5 — Debentures and fundraising disclosure
Sunrise Medical Technologies Ltd proposes to raise $4 million from 90 Australian retail investors by offering debentures advertised online. Management calls them 'membership bonds' and says no prospectus or trustee is necessary because the investors are supporters of the business.
Issue. What is the instrument, and what disclosure and debenture-holder protections may apply? Rule. The legal character of the instrument, not its marketing nickname, controls. Section 124(1)(b) recognises company debenture-issue powers; Chapter 6D, particularly ss 706 and 708, governs securities-offer disclosure; Chapter 2L, including s 283AA, may require a trust deed and trustee for specified debenture offers. Application. Repayment promises ordinarily indicate a debt security, not an ownership interest. Ninety public investors and online advertising make reliance on the familiar s 708(1) small-scale personal offer exception problematic, particularly because that exception carries defined numerical and other conditions. The issuer must identify the precise offer structure and offerees. If disclosure is required, a compliant document and ASIC lodgment should be planned; check whether s 283AA is triggered and any applicable exceptions. Conclusion. Do not use the proposed advertising or proceed without transaction-specific analysis and review of the current ASIC fundraising guidance.
7A.11 Frequently asked questions — answered, with the reasons
1. Are shareholders creditors because they paid money to the company?
Not ordinarily. Subscribing for shares creates a membership interest, not a simple contractual obligation to repay the subscription. Shareholders participate through rights attached to shares. The company may separately borrow from a shareholder, creating a distinct creditor claim.
2. Does a preference share guarantee a dividend?
No. Its terms may give priority in specified circumstances, but actual distributions remain subject to legal restrictions and the instrument's terms. Read s 254A and the agreed rights rather than assume a guarantee.
3. Why can dilution occur even when no existing shares are transferred?
Because each existing holding becomes a smaller fraction of a larger total after new shares are issued. Percentages depend on both the numerator (shares held) and denominator (total issued shares).
4. Is dilution the same as variation of class rights?
No. A holder may retain the same rights per share while voting percentages change. A direct alteration to voting rights attached to a class may engage ss 246B–246G. Analyse both questions separately.
5. Why does capital reduction law protect creditors?
Returning assets to members can make it harder for the company to repay those who have supplied goods or lent money. Sections 256A–256C address insolvency risks, fairness and approval processes.
6. Does shareholder approval automatically make financial assistance lawful?
No. An approval-based route must satisfy the exact requirements of s 260B, including procedure and notification requirements. Other duties and legal restrictions may continue to apply.
7. Must all three s 260A alternatives be satisfied?
No. Section 260A(1) uses alternatives: non-prejudicial assistance, approval under s 260B, or exemption under s 260C. A careful answer identifies which route is relied on and proves its elements.
8. Does every debenture automatically have security?
No. Debt instruments may be secured or unsecured. Read the terms and applicable security law, not the title alone.
9. Must every Australian fundraising offer have a prospectus?
No. Whether disclosure is required depends on the offer and statutory exceptions. Even where disclosure is needed, the correct disclosure document type must be determined under the Act and ASIC guidance.
10. Why did the lecturer show ASIC website searches?
To demonstrate that lawyers verify the identity and recorded status of entities and examine primary fundraising documents. Registration alone should not be mistaken for an ASIC guarantee that an investment is sound.
7A.12 Multiple-choice questions — answers and explanations
MCQ 1. Which description best fits equity? A. A promise of fixed repayment only. B. A membership investment with rights under the share terms. C. Always a secured debt. D. A statutory tax debt.
Correct: B. Shares usually create ownership/membership rights. A describes a debt feature; C wrongly assumes security; D is unrelated.
MCQ 2. A shareholder owns 20 of 100 shares. Another 100 same-class shares are issued to outsiders. Ignoring other differences, their new percentage is: A. 20%. B. 10%. C. 40%. D. 5%.
Correct: B. The holding is 20 out of 200, so 20 ÷ 200 = 10%. The numerator is unchanged; the denominator doubled.
MCQ 3. Which provision directly deals with the specified matters that must be set out or approved for preference shares? A. s 254A(2). B. s 119. C. s 131. D. s 588G alone.
Correct: A. Section 254A(2)(a)–(e) identifies repayment, surplus, dividend, voting and priority matters. The other sections concern distinct areas.
MCQ 4. The board unilaterally reduces the number of votes attached to Class A shares. What is the most relevant initial statutory issue? A. s 246B. B. s 9 tax definition only. C. s 131 pre-registration contract. D. s 250S notice of adjournment only.
Correct: A. Start with variation of class rights. A class vote change is not simply the same as dilution.
MCQ 5. Why are ss 256A–256C important? A. They forbid every share issue. B. They provide the framework for relevant capital reductions and protect creditors/shareholders. C. They regulate tort damages only. D. They automatically guarantee dividends.
Correct: B. The statutory design balances capital restructuring with fairness and solvency; the other options confuse separate topics.
MCQ 6. Which is correct about s 260A(1)? A. All three routes must be simultaneously met. B. Only a board minute is required. C. It has alternative non-prejudice, approval and exemption routes. D. It never covers guarantees.
Correct: C. Read the disjunctive 'or' structure of paragraphs (a)–(c). A guarantee can be relevant assistance, depending on facts.
MCQ 7. A debenture holder is ordinarily: A. Automatically a company director. B. A creditor with rights under the instrument. C. A voting shareholder merely because the paper says 'bond'. D. Always an unsecured employee.
Correct: B. Debt claims are distinct from share membership. The instrument and legal regime control repayment, security and ranking.
MCQ 8. Which two sections are foundational to determining the need for fundraising disclosure? A. ss 706 and 708. B. ss 119 and 120. C. ss 203D and 249D. D. ss 180 and 181 only.
Correct: A. Section 706 provides a key general requirement; s 708 contains exceptions. Other sections may matter elsewhere but do not replace the offer-disclosure test.
MCQ 9. A prospectus shown from a US company proves compliance with Australian fundraising law. A. True. B. False.
Correct: B. Foreign documents illustrate commercial techniques but can be governed by different laws. Always apply the Australian Act to an Australian offer.
MCQ 10. Which approach best meets the teaching goal of a High Distinction legal answer? A. List several section numbers without analysis. B. Give a conclusion with no facts. C. Identify each issue, explain relevant subsections and cases, apply competing facts, and qualify the conclusion. D. Copy a lecture slide word-for-word without connecting it to the problem.
Correct: C. A high-level answer demonstrates legal reasoning, not name-dropping or unsupported certainty.
7A.13 Short-answer questions — fully explained model answers
SAQ 1. Explain in simple language why lenders can be entitled to payment before shareholders receive surplus capital.
A lender is ordinarily a creditor with a legal claim to repayment. A shareholder is a member whose investment is residual: payment of remaining value depends on what assets are left after creditors and the applicable winding-up rules. The separation protects the agreed bargain and explains why debt may appear safer than equity. The precise ranking of different creditors, including security holders, must be determined under the applicable law.
SAQ 2. What documents would a lawyer seek before approving preference shares?
Request the constitution, board and member resolutions, proposed terms of issue, investor offer materials and existing share-class terms. Check whether s 254A(2)(a)–(e) is satisfied and whether the issue affects existing class rights or triggers other statutory requirements. Explain to the client exactly which dividend, voting, repayment and redemption rights are being promised, and whether any payment is conditional.
SAQ 3. Differentiate dilution from variation of class rights in a worked example.
If an investor has 10 ordinary shares out of 100 and another 100 ordinary shares are issued, their percentage falls from 10% to 5% while the ordinary share voting entitlement per share may remain unchanged: that is dilution. If the company instead amends the terms so that ordinary shares have no votes, that may be a variation of the rights attached to that class, engaging the procedure in ss 246B–246G. Students should distinguish the value of a fraction from the legal rights attached to its units.
SAQ 4. State the three key creditor/shareholder policy concerns in a proposed capital reduction.
First, a return of capital must not create unacceptable insolvency risk; second, shareholders should be treated fairly according to the relevant statutory standard; third, shareholders must have material information to decide whether to support the transaction. Section 256A frames the policy; the operative rules are in ss 256B and 256C and related provisions.
SAQ 5. Why is a directors' statement that 'the bank approved the guarantee' insufficient for s 260A?
The bank's consent is not the statutory test. A target company's guarantee for a purchaser's acquisition debt may be financial assistance. The company must demonstrate one of the s 260A(1)(a)–(c) pathways, complete any required s 260B procedure or show a qualifying s 260C exemption, and address separate directors' duties and solvency considerations. The interests of the lending bank are not identical to the interests of the company, its shareholders or its creditors as a group.
SAQ 6. Why should a lawyer inspect the prospectus and ASIC records instead of relying on investment advertising?
Advertising highlights attractive parts of an offer; legal due diligence checks what investors are actually promised, what risks are disclosed, what entity is offering the security, and whether the statutory disclosure regime is satisfied. ASIC searches may establish registered details and filings but not commercial success or investment suitability. This separates verifiable facts from marketing claims.
SAQ 7. Identify an example of when Chapter 7 connects with directors' duties in Chapter 8.
Directors may have a genuine need to raise cash by issuing shares. If their actual purpose is principally to entrench themselves or defeat a competing voting bloc, the proper-purpose duty under s 181(1)(b), explained further in Chapter 8, may arise. The company must examine directors' reasons, board documents, financing alternatives and the timing of the issue rather than infer legality from the mere existence of an available share-issue power.
A company can have a brilliant business idea and still fail because it cannot pay for its next stage of growth. Corporate finance begins with a remarkably practical question: where will the money come from, what is the company promising in exchange, and what rights will the financier receive? This chapter teaches those questions from first principles before connecting them to the exact Australian legal framework.
7.1 Why finance is a legal question, not merely an accounting question
Imagine a Queensland company that designs electric surfboards. It needs $600,000 to manufacture its first large commercial order. The directors can ask investors to subscribe for new shares. Those investors become members and may receive voting rights, dividends if validly payable and a residual claim on surplus assets if the company is wound up. Alternatively, the company can borrow the money from a bank. The bank becomes a creditor: it expects repayment of the principal plus agreed interest, regardless of whether shareholders receive any dividend.
These options cannot be compared simply by looking at the dollars entering the company's bank account. Issuing shares can dilute existing members' economic and voting influence. Borrowing creates repayment obligations and may require security over company property. Both decisions may affect control, solvency, governance, the duties of directors and the information that must be disclosed to prospective investors. As you work through any financing problem, ask whether the transaction gives a person a membership interest, a debt claim, or some combination.
new members; ownership rights
creditors; repayment rights
7.2 Share capital: what, exactly, is a share?
The lecturer begins with share capital because it is a familiar financing mechanism and the foundation for understanding the proper-purpose duty in Chapter 8. A company raises equity capital by issuing shares in return for money or property. The new shares represent a bundle of rights determined by statute, the constitution, the terms of issue and the relevant share class. They are intangible personal property, not a direct slice of the company's factory, cash or equipment. The separate legal personality principle from Chapter 2 remains crucial: assets bought with shareholders' contributions belong to the company, not to the shareholders individually.
For example, suppose the company has 1,000 ordinary shares on issue and one investor owns 250. Assuming equal rights in that class, the investor owns 25% of those shares. If the company issues 1,000 additional ordinary shares to a new investor, the original investor still holds 250 shares, but now owns only 250 out of 2,000, or 12.5%. Their shares have not been taken away; their proportional interest has changed. This is dilution. It can be economically and politically important because voting influence may be reduced.
Before issue: 250 ÷ 1,000 × 100 = 25%.
After 1,000 new shares are issued: total shares = 1,000 + 1,000 = 2,000. The holder still has 250 shares. Therefore 250 ÷ 2,000 × 100 = 12.5%.
Why this matters: a board may genuinely need capital, but using an issue to manipulate who controls voting power raises the separate proper-purpose question considered in Chapter 8.
The central statutory starting points are Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 124 and 254A. Section 124 gives a company the legal capacity and powers of an individual, together with corporate powers including issuing shares and borrowing. Section 254A makes clear that the issue power extends to bonus shares, preference shares and partly-paid shares. Those categories are different commercial tools; none automatically overrides constitutional or statutory constraints.
7.3 Fully paid, partly paid and no-liability shares
A fully paid share is one for which the agreed issue price has been paid. The holder generally owes nothing more on that share. A partly paid share is issued with an amount still outstanding, which the company may be able to call for payment according to the issue terms and statute. Section 254A(1)(c) recognises partly-paid shares; ss 254M–254N deal with calls and related matters. Section 516 concerns the extent of liability of members on winding up, subject to the relevant statutory qualifications.
Suppose 100 shares have an issue price of $10 each, with $6 payable on issue and $4 uncalled. The investor initially pays 100 × $6 = $600. The unpaid amount is 100 × $4 = $400. If a valid call is made for that balance, the investor may have to pay the remaining $400. This is not an additional share subscription: it is completing the price of the existing shares.
The lecturer also identifies the specialist no liability company, associated with a distinct statutory regime. Do not assume its treatment of unpaid amounts is the same as for an ordinary proprietary or public company. First identify the company type under the Act, then read the applicable provisions.
7.4 Classes of shares and preference shareholders
Companies may issue different classes to attract different investors. Ordinary shares frequently carry the standard voting and residual economic rights. Preference shares may grant priority in payment of dividends or return of capital, or restrict voting rights. The label alone does not establish the details. Under s 254A(2), the rights attached to preference shares concerning repayment of capital, participation in profits and surplus assets, dividends, voting and priority must be specified in the constitution (if any) or otherwise approved by special resolution. Section 254A also recognises redeemable preference shares.
For a client, ask for the constitution, shareholder agreements, issue terms and register. A preference share may promise a fixed dividend rate, but this does not mean every payment is automatically payable regardless of the statutory dividend requirements or the terms of issue. Analyse the legal conditions for payment rather than treating a preference share as interchangeable with a bank loan.
Assume the terms of issue provide for a non-cumulative 6% preference dividend calculated on $200,000 paid-up preference capital, subject to lawful declaration/payment. The annual contractual measure is $200,000 × 0.06 = $12,000.
If dividend conditions are not satisfied, the figure does not itself establish a current right to payment. A cumulative entitlement may have different carry-forward consequences under the precise share terms. Always obtain those terms.
The Week 7 lecture flags variation of class rights under ss 246B–246C. These provisions protect holders when the rights associated with their class are varied. The lecturer marks the detailed mechanics as not examinable for that lecture. For professional practice, however, the point is important: a board cannot assume that members' class rights can be changed merely by issuing a general announcement. Check the constitution and statutory approval process.
7.5 Reductions of capital, share buy-backs and financial assistance
Early company law strongly resisted returning issued share capital to members, partly to protect creditors who had relied on the company's asset base. The historic decision Trevor v Whitworth (1887) 12 App Cas 409 provides the background. Modern Australian legislation permits capital reductions and buy-backs on defined conditions. The lecturer links this to ss 256A–256B and 257A–257J: the essential themes are creditor protection, fairness between shareholders and proper corporate procedure.
Consider a solvent company with excess capital proposing to buy back shares from one founder. That changes not just the cash balance, but potentially control and the interests of those left in the company. The lawyer should check whether the buy-back is authorised, whether it materially prejudices creditors, what disclosures and approvals are necessary, and whether all members are treated lawfully. Do not give a one-line answer that any profitable company may repurchase its own shares.
A related issue arises when a company finances another person's acquisition of shares in the company. Section 260A places conditions on such financial assistance, including lack of specified material prejudice, prescribed shareholder approval or an exemption. A loan used to help someone buy the company may be a legitimate commercial transaction, but the company should not risk its assets for an acquisition without reviewing the statutory requirements. The lecture names ASIC v Adler [2002] NSWSC 171 and Connective Services Pty Ltd v Slea Pty Ltd [2019] HCA 33 as relevant authorities. These advanced topics are labelled not examinable in the lecturer's Week 7 deck; they remain valuable context for client advice.
7.6 Debt capital: creditors are not shareholders
Debt finance begins when a company obtains funds subject to an obligation to repay. The lender is not automatically a member and ordinarily has no member vote merely by lending. The interest rate, repayment date, events of default and security are established by the loan agreement and any applicable law. The lecturer's important contrast is that debt interest can be owed even when the company has made no profit, while dividends are governed by the separate law of distributions to members.
A company borrows $500,000 for one year at 8% simple annual interest. Interest = principal × annual rate × time = $500,000 × 0.08 × 1 = $40,000.
The contractual amount due at the end, assuming no interim payments or fees, is $500,000 + $40,000 = $540,000. This is an illustrative simple-interest example, not an assertion that real bank facilities use simple interest or that tax is treated identically.
Section 124(1) expressly supports corporate powers to borrow, issue debentures and grant security interests. A debenture is a particular debt security within the statutory definition in s 9. Debenture holders are creditors; they may be secured or unsecured, and certain instruments can be convertible into shares. The lecturer directs attention to the statutory rules for describing debentures in s 283BH and, where relevant, requirements for trustees and trust deeds. The word bond may be used commercially, but the statutory character of the instrument must be checked from its terms.
A security interest gives a creditor rights relating to identified assets if obligations are not met. Security raises questions about what property is covered, whether the interest is enforceable and perfected, and its priority against other claimants. The Week 7 slide identifies the topic but does not supply a full PPSA tutorial; this book therefore treats priority mechanics as further research rather than pretending the course explained every rule. For clients, obtain loan agreements, security documents and relevant registrations before advising.
7.7 Insolvency changes how financing risk is understood
When a company fails, creditors generally assert claims to payment before shareholders receive any residual distribution. A shareholder who subscribed $100,000 in ordinary shares may lose that investment entirely if the company's assets are exhausted meeting liabilities. By contrast, a lender has a creditor claim, although actual recovery depends on security, priority and available assets. That is why the distinction between equity and debt is not a vocabulary exercise—it can determine who bears losses when a business collapses.
Directors deciding whether to incur further debt must also consider duties under ss 180–181 and the insolvent trading rules in s 588G where applicable. The detailed statutory insolvency topic belongs to later course material; at this stage learn to recognise the warning sign: the company needs finance, repayment obligations are accumulating and management cannot simply assume future sales will solve a current inability to pay debts.
7.8 Fundraising under Chapter 6D
Australian fundraising law tries to resolve an information problem. The directors usually know more about the company's financial condition, business model, assets and legal risks than a potential outside investor. Chapter 6D of the Corporations Act requires disclosure for many offers of securities so investors can make informed decisions. The starting questions are whether there is an offer of securities for issue (s 706), whether an offer for sale triggers disclosure (s 707), and whether an exemption applies, including those in s 708. Only after those questions should the adviser choose the appropriate document and consider advertising restrictions.
The lecture emphasises the distinction between public companies, which may seek public investment subject to applicable regulation, and proprietary companies, which face restrictions including s 113(3). Do not infer that a proprietary company is forbidden from every private share issue; the issue is whether the company engages in activity requiring disclosure under Chapter 6D. A proper answer must examine the offering, company type and exemption.
One familiar exception under s 708 concerns qualifying small-scale personal offers. Subject to the detailed statutory rules and exclusions, these involve a 20-investor ceiling and a $2 million ceiling over a relevant 12-month period. The personal-offer requirement matters: sending a public online invitation is not automatically converted into a personal offer because only a few investors respond. Other exemptions concern certain sophisticated or professional investors, senior managers and particular existing-security-holder transactions. None should be applied without testing its conditions.
Assume a qualifying company has already issued securities under relevant personal offers to 18 investors for a total of $1.70 million during the relevant 12 months. It proposes a further qualifying personal offer accepted by one new investor for $250,000. Investor count: 18 + 1 = 19. Amount raised: $1.70m + $0.25m = $1.95m. Both ceilings are below the threshold, so the arithmetic alone does not disqualify the offer.
Now suppose the proposed investor subscribes $400,000. Amount = $1.70m + $0.40m = $2.10m, exceeding $2m even though the investor count is only 19. The small-scale exemption cannot be assumed to apply. Separate exceptions, aggregation rules and anti-avoidance provisions must still be assessed. This example is about method, not blanket legal approval.
7.9 Prospectus and other disclosure documents
Where disclosure is required, the central document is often a prospectus. Section 710 uses an investor-focused standard: disclose information investors and professional advisers would reasonably require to make an informed assessment of the specified matters, within the statutory framework. Section 711 imposes additional content requirements. A useful prospectus tells the reader what the company does, how it will use funds, what the financial and commercial risks are, who controls it and what major agreements or litigation could materially affect the investment.
The lecturer contrasts a full prospectus with a short-form prospectus (s 712), which may incorporate information from documents lodged with ASIC by reference; a profile statement (ss 709 and 714), subject to approval and procedural conditions; and an offer information statement (ss 709 and 715), available within applicable statutory thresholds and conditions. The older lecture mentions a dollar threshold, but this edition deliberately directs the reader to verify the current provision and all conditions at the time of an actual offer. A document's familiar name is not a substitute for meeting its statutory rules.
Fundraising rules extend beyond the document itself. Section 734 regulates certain advertising and publicity for offers that require disclosure; s 727 prohibits specified conduct involving securities without required disclosure; and the Act includes rules on unsolicited offers. The lecture also distinguishes primary-market disclosure from listed companies' continuous disclosure obligations. They are related investor-protection systems but should not be conflated in an IRAC answer.
7.10 Case study: advising a client who wants $1.5 million
A new food-technology company says: “We want $1.5 million quickly. Could we put a post on social media inviting anyone to buy shares?” A weak legal answer is “Yes, because $1.5 million is less than $2 million.” A stronger answer explains why that is insufficient. First, find out whether the company is proprietary or public. Second, establish exactly what security is being offered and to whom. Third, test whether any qualifying exemption applies. A public social-media invitation may not satisfy the personal-offer requirement in s 708 merely because the target raise is below a monetary ceiling. Fourth, decide whether a disclosure document is needed and what offer advertising constraints apply. Finally, examine the director decision to issue shares: is the company genuinely raising capital, or is there another control-related objective? That last question connects directly to Chapter 8.
7.11 Applied practice problem A — equity versus debt
OceanTech Ltd requires $900,000 for manufacturing. Its founders currently hold all 900 ordinary shares. It can either issue 300 new ordinary shares to an investor for $900,000 or borrow $900,000 for two years at 9% simple annual interest. Explain the ownership and cash-flow consequences and the key legal questions for directors.
Model answer — Issue
The issues are dilution, differences between member and creditor rights, lawful use of the share-issue power, obligations under the loan and directors' governance duties.
Rule
A company has power to issue shares and borrow under ss 124 and 254A, subject to the Act and constitutional limits. Shareholders are members with rights determined by the class and constitution; lenders hold contractual claims. The directors must act in good faith in the corporation's best interests and use powers for proper purposes under s 181.
Application and calculations
Before issue the founders hold 900 of 900 shares = 100%. After issue there are 900 + 300 = 1,200 shares. Founders retain 900 ÷ 1,200 = 75% and the new investor holds 300 ÷ 1,200 = 25%. The company receives $900,000 without an ordinary loan repayment obligation, but the founders' proportional voting/economic interest is reduced, assuming equal ordinary share rights.
For the loan, two years' simple interest = $900,000 × 0.09 × 2 = $162,000. Total principal plus interest at the end, on the stated simplified assumption, is $1,062,000. Founders' share percentage remains unchanged, but the company faces repayment risk and may provide security or financial covenants. Real loans may compound, require instalments or charge fees, so the actual contract is essential.
Counterarguments and conclusion
The founder may prefer no dilution, but debt is not automatically safer merely because ownership is preserved. Conversely, equity need not be preferable if the directors issue shares on unfair terms or for an ulterior control purpose. The board should compare cash flows, investor conditions, constitutional rights, solvency and statutory compliance before recommending a structure.
7.12 Applied practice problem B — a small-scale offer
BlueCo Pty Ltd has placed a public online advertisement soliciting share investments. Twenty-one unrelated people propose to invest $80,000 each in the same 12 months. BlueCo argues that s 708 automatically exempts the offers because the money sought is “only startup capital”. Advise.
Model answer — Issue and rule
The issues are the company's status as proprietary, the restrictions in s 113, the disclosure starting point in ss 706–707, and whether s 708's small-scale exemption is available. The exemption is conditioned on qualifying personal offers and relevant numerical ceilings; it is not an exemption for all startup ventures.
Application
The proposed investor count is 21, above the basic 20-investor ceiling if all issues fall within its counting rules. Total proposed subscriptions = 21 × $80,000 = $1,680,000, below $2 million. The numerical ceiling is conjunctive: satisfying the monetary ceiling alone is insufficient. Furthermore, a public online advertisement is unlike a qualifying offer made personally to an identified recipient, so the personal-offer condition requires particular scrutiny. BlueCo's proprietary status also raises s 113(3).
Conclusion
BlueCo should not proceed on its claimed automatic exemption. The facts strongly suggest the small-scale pathway is unavailable; an adviser must check all statutory exclusions and alternatives before settling the fundraising method and advertising. Directors should seek specialist fundraising advice and prepare a compliant transaction process.
7.13 Applied practice problem C — a preference share promise
Peak Holdings proposes 1,000 preference shares at $100 each with a 7% annual preferred dividend and preferential repayment on winding up. The directors say they need no special shareholder approval and the preferred dividend must be paid every year even if the company cannot lawfully make a distribution. Analyse.
Model answer
Section 254A(2) requires the specified preference-share rights to be set out in the company's constitution (if any) or otherwise approved by special resolution. The legal analysis begins with those issue terms and the company documents. The proposed paid-up capital is 1,000 × $100 = $100,000; an annual 7% measure would be $100,000 × 0.07 = $7,000. But those calculations do not independently establish that $7,000 can or must be paid in each year. Actual dividend entitlements depend on issue terms and statutory requirements. Priority on winding up likewise depends on the class terms and the hierarchy of claims; preference shareholders generally remain members rather than ordinary creditors. The directors' assurances are therefore legally unsafe without examining the documents and payment conditions.
7.14 Applied practice problem D — the share issue as an abuse of power
A board issues shares worth $2 million to a friendly investor immediately after learning that a potential acquirer has assembled a large shareholding. The company has substantial cash reserves, no announced project and no immediate need for finance. Directors say the new investor will protect the business's “culture”. Is the finance transaction automatically valid?
Model answer
No. A company can possess the legal power to issue shares while directors still exercise that power for an improper purpose. The question is not simply whether capital entered the company. Under s 181(1)(b), and the fiduciary proper-purpose doctrine explained in Howard Smith Ltd v Ampol Petroleum Ltd [1974] AC 821 and Whitehouse v Carlton Hotel Pty Ltd (1987) 162 CLR 285, identify the power, its authorised objects and the actual motivating purpose. The company's lack of capital need, timing, selection of a friendly investor and anticipated voting impact are evidence of a potentially impermissible control objective. The directors may respond that the business faced a genuine threat, but honest belief does not itself answer the proper-purpose inquiry. Further evidence, including board minutes and commercial forecasts, is required before a final conclusion. Chapter 8 supplies the structured analysis and potential remedies.
7.15 FAQs — the questions students actually ask
Does owning 20% of shares mean owning 20% of the company's property?
No. A shareholder owns the shares, a distinct form of property. The company owns its assets as a separate legal person. Membership rights, not direct co-ownership of assets, follow from the shares.
Does a new share issue automatically breach directors' duties because it dilutes existing members?
No. Dilution is common in lawful fundraising. The key is whether the issue complies with the Act, constitution, share rights and directors' duties, especially proper purpose.
Are preference shareholders creditors?
Usually they remain members despite preferential terms. Their exact rights must be read from the share terms and statute; convertible and hybrid instruments need individual classification.
Can a company issue partly-paid shares?
Yes. Section 254A recognises them; payment calls and member liability require analysis of ss 254M–254N and the terms of issue.
Can a company borrow even if its constitution is silent?
The Corporations Act generally confers broad corporate powers under s 124, including borrowing; management authority, any constitutional restrictions and the legality of the financing terms must still be checked.
Are all offers under $2 million exempt from prospectus requirements?
No. The small-scale exception depends on qualifying personal offers and both numerical ceilings, subject to the provision's full rules and exclusions.
Is a prospectus the same as a business plan?
No. A prospectus is a legally regulated disclosure document with statutory content obligations. A marketing plan alone does not fulfil those obligations.
7.16 Multiple-choice practice — reasoning after each answer
MCQ 1 — An investor with 100 of 400 equal ordinary shares owns: A. 10%; B. 20%; C. 25%; D. 40%.
Answer C. 100 ÷ 400 × 100 = 25%. The percentage describes the class holding on these assumptions, not ownership of 25% of the company's physical assets.
MCQ 2 — The usual legal position of a debentureholder is: A. director; B. creditor; C. ordinary shareholder; D. regulator.
Answer B. A debenture is a debt security. The holder is a creditor, although instruments may have conversion terms.
MCQ 3 — Preference shares are subject to which statutory rule about specified attached rights? A. s 254A(2); B. s 249D; C. s 588G; D. s 1324.
Answer A. Section 254A(2) requires the listed preference rights to be specified in the constitution (if any) or approved by special resolution.
MCQ 4 — Which is a central purpose of Chapter 6D disclosure rules? A. guarantee profits; B. give investors material information; C. eliminate all business risk; D. appoint every director.
Answer B. Disclosure improves informed assessment, but no legislation can guarantee investment success.
MCQ 5 — A company borrows $100,000 at 5% simple interest for two years. Total simple interest? A. $5,000; B. $10,000; C. $20,000; D. $110,000.
Answer B. $100,000 × 0.05 × 2 = $10,000. $110,000 is the principal plus interest, not interest alone.
MCQ 6 — A public post inviting everyone to buy shares automatically qualifies for a personal-offer exemption. True or false?
False. The personal-offer conditions in s 708 must actually be satisfied. An invitation to the public is not transformed into a personal offer by low response numbers.
MCQ 7 — Which question belongs at the beginning of a fundraising-law problem? A. What is the logo? B. Is there an offer requiring disclosure and any exception? C. Who likes the director? D. Will the shares rise in price?
Answer B. Characterise the offer under ss 706–708 and the company type before selecting disclosure documentation.
MCQ 8 — A company issues shares to defeat a takeover. Can a genuine receipt of cash end the proper-purpose inquiry?
No. The real motivating purpose matters. The share issue power cannot be used for a collateral control objective merely because the company also receives subscription funds.
7.17 Short-answer revision — model explanations
Model: Dilution occurs when a company issues additional shares and an existing member's percentage ownership or voting interest falls because the total number of shares increases. Their original number of shares may stay the same. The legal relevance is that share issues can alter control, requiring both compliance with the Act and a proper-purpose analysis.
Model: Interest ordinarily arises from a debt obligation owed to a creditor; a dividend is a distribution to members governed by corporate law and issue terms. Thus a loss-making company may owe agreed loan interest even though it cannot lawfully make or has not validly declared dividends.
Model: Obtain the constitution, the terms of the issue and any approval resolution. Those documents identify the actual class rights and whether the requirements of s 254A(2) were followed.
7.18 Recap and source note
Corporate finance becomes straightforward once you ask three questions: What is the instrument? What rights and duties does it create? What statutory pathway makes the transaction lawful? In advice, add a fourth: Why did the directors choose this instrument? The fourth question leads to Chapter 8 and proper purpose.
Course basis: Corporate Law Updated Lecture Seven — Equity, Debt and Fundraising (25-slide deck), and the funding-week reading instructions previously provided. The lecturer marks variation of class rights, capital reductions and financial assistance as non-examinable at this stage. There was no independently authenticated original Week 8 tutorial question sheet for this finance lecture among the files recovered; the four Chapter 7 problems above are therefore clearly marked author-created practice, not passed off as original university tutorial questions. Verify the statutory text against the latest official Corporations Act before using this material in a live transaction.