Original Tutorial 7 (Week 9)
The original, unaltered problem questions and lecturer prompts. Teaching answers are in Chapter 8.
CORPORATE LAW 263 Tutorial 7 (Week 9) - Good Faith and Proper Purpose
Question 1
Testa Ltd ('Testa') is a large Australian conglomerate that operates in several high-technology industries. The company is dominated by its charismatic founder and managing director, Evan Rusk. Several years ago, Testa and Turnbull Pty Ltd ('Turnbull') established a joint venture company, SolarCar Ltd ('SolarCar'), to design and manufacture solar-powered vehicles. Testa holds 60% of SolarCar's shares and Turnbull holds the remaining 40%. SolarCar has a board of three directors. Alexandra and James were nominated for appointment by Testa, while Carson was nominated by Turnbull. SolarCar's constitution is silent on the role of nominee directors. SolarCar purchases one of its most important components, solar battery cells, from Testa under a long-term supply agreement. No other manufacturer currently produces battery cells that are suitable for use in SolarCar's vehicles. When the joint venture was established, Testa relied heavily on Turnbull's expertise in automotive design. Over time, however, Testa developed its own in-house design capability and became dissatisfied with having to share SolarCar's profits with Turnbull. The intellectual property rights relating to SolarCar's vehicle designs and manufacturing processes are owned by SolarCar itself. Testa subsequently incorporates a wholly owned subsidiary, SunMobile Ltd ('SunMobile'). SunMobile begins manufacturing vehicles that are identical to those produced by SolarCar. At around the same time, Testa stops supplying battery cells to SolarCar despite the existence of the long-term supply agreement. Carson proposes that SolarCar commence proceedings: (1) against SunMobile for infringement of SolarCar's patents; and (2) against Testa for breach of the battery supply agreement. Alexandra and James vote against both proposals after being directed by Evan Rusk not to allow SolarCar to take action against either Testa or SunMobile. Alexandra and James state that they were appointed to represent Testa's interests, are expected to follow Testa's instructions, and have no practical choice but to do what Evan says. Discuss the legal issues arising from these facts and advise what remedies, if any, may be available to Turnbull.
Points to Consider As You Work Through This Question
1. To whom do directors owe their duties? Can a director appointed by a particular shareholder treat that shareholder’s interests as paramount? What is the significance of the company’s constitution being silent on nominee directors?
2. What does acting in the best interests of the company require? Whose interests should Alexandra and James consider when deciding whether SolarCar should commence legal proceedings?
3. Must directors exercise their own judgment? Can directors simply follow instructions given by the person or entity that nominated them?
4. What significance attaches to the fact that SolarCar is part of a corporate group? Can directors prioritise the interests of a parent company over those of a subsidiary?
5. What consequences might follow if directors refuse to allow the company to pursue potentially valuable claims?
6. Revision: Does Evan’s role create additional issues? Could a person who gives directions or instructions to directors incur legal responsibility even if not formally appointed?
7. If a breach of duty has occurred, who may seek a remedy and what remedies might be available?
Consider both relevant case law and relevant sections of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) as you work through this question.
Question 2
Hogwarts Ltd ('Hogwarts') is a publicly listed company. Recent reports suggest that Beauxbatons Ltd ('Beauxbatons') is considering making a takeover bid for Hogwarts. Concerned by this possibility, the Hogwarts board resolves to undertake a $250 million rights issue. Under the proposal, each existing shareholder will be entitled to subscribe for new shares in proportion to their current shareholding. No shares will be offered to non-shareholders. Hogwarts does not presently require additional capital. The company is financially strong and has substantial cash reserves. Internal board papers indicate that several directors support the rights issue because it will make any takeover attempt significantly more expensive and difficult to complete.
Advise Beauxbatons whether there are any legal grounds on which the rights issue could be challenged.
Points to Consider as You Work Through This Question
1. What is the relevant director power being exercised? What is the legal purpose of a power to issue shares?
2. How do courts determine whether a power has been exercised for a proper purpose? Is it enough that directors honestly believe they are acting in the company’s best interests?
3. What evidence might assist a court in determining the directors’ purpose?
4. Is there a distinction between acting in good faith and acting for a proper purpose?
5. What significance should be attached to the fact that Hogwarts does not presently require additional capital?
6. How might the proposed rights issue affect a potential takeover bid? Is influencing the outcome of a takeover necessarily an improper purpose?
7. If the directors had more than one purpose, how should a court determine whether the share issue is valid?
8. Assuming a breach is established, what remedies might be available and who would have standing to seek them?
As with Question 1, consider relevant portions of both the case law and the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).