CORPORATE LAW · BY DR ADRIAN ADAMS

CHAPTER 3 · Week 3 Forum → Tutorial 3 in Week 4 · BEGINNER-FIRST STUDY GUIDE

Registration, constitutions, replaceable rules and company liability

Identify the source of each rule and the legal relationship it governs: creation, internal management, outsiders, or attribution of wrongdoing.

Start with this: how the law works

The company is now registered. The next practical question is: who is allowed to make decisions for it, and where do we find the rule? Australian law supplies several layers. The Corporations Act contains mandatory rules. Many internal procedures are supplied by replaceable rules that apply subject to the Act and the company's constitution. A constitution can change some internal arrangements, but cannot generally undo mandatory statutory requirements. Do not confuse the company's powers with the directors’ authority to exercise them.

Registration is the legal starting line. Under ss 117–119, a person applies for registration, ASIC performs its statutory role, and the company comes into existence on registration. Section 124 gives the company legal capacity and powers; s 125 addresses restrictions in a constitution or the company’s objects. A company generally does not escape a contract with an outsider merely by claiming the directors exceeded an internal object restriction. You must still ask whether the particular person who signed had authority, an issue developed in Chapter 6.

The constitution and replaceable rules provide the internal machinery. Sections 134–136 describe the relationship between internal management rules and a company’s constitution, while s 140 gives relevant rules a statutory-contract effect among specified persons in their relevant capacities. This does not mean every promise in a constitution is enforceable by any person mentioned in it. The lawyer asks who seeks enforcement and in what legal capacity. A member asserting a membership right is different from someone invoking an external contract or asserting rights solely as an employee.

Suppose shareholders change the constitution to make directors easier to remove. A correct answer should ask about the special-resolution requirements and any additional safeguards or constraints, rather than assuming the majority can do anything. The doctrine illustrated by Gambotto v WCP Ltd (1995) 182 CLR 432 is particularly significant when a constitutional alteration affects minority property rights through compulsory share acquisition. Identify the kind of alteration before applying the relevant constraint.

Companies also act through human beings. In civil disputes, identify the primary legal rule first: agency, employment, statutory attribution or direct acts of an authorised corporate organ may provide different routes to responsibility. For criminal offences, identify the specific statutory offence and the relevant attribution regime; an individual employee's act does not always automatically become a company offence. An examination answer earns precision by stating the applicable rule rather than using 'the company knew' as an unsupported shortcut.

Your step-by-step exam pathway

Use these steps to organise the facts before writing an IRAC answer. Do not jump to a case until you know why it applies.

  1. STEP 1Confirm corporate registration and identity
  2. STEP 2Locate the constitution and any applicable replaceable rule
  3. STEP 3Identify the power, right or obligation being asserted
  4. STEP 4Distinguish an internal dispute from an outsider transaction
  5. STEP 5Use the correct source of civil or criminal liability

Statute and authority map

Each source answers a different question. Read the actual provision and check the exact subsection and legal context before formal reliance.

Why the cases matter: Gambotto v WCP Ltd (1995) 182 CLR 432 helps analyse certain constitutional changes affecting minority shares. Do not apply it indiscriminately to every ordinary amendment.

Read the current Act at the official Federal Register of Legislation.

Full worked client problem

Facts: A company's constitution gives members voting rights. A person named in its constitution as the preferred accountant, but who is not a member, demands continued employment purely on the basis of the constitution.

High-standard IRAC worked answer: explanation and application

The issue is whether s 140 makes that employment entitlement enforceable. First identify the claimant and capacity: the claimant is relying on being the named accountant, not on a membership right. Section 140 creates a statutory contract in the specified relationships and capacities, not an automatic external employment contract for every person named. The accountant should look for a separate enforceable service agreement. The conclusion depends on those documents; membership status and the precise contractual basis must be proved rather than assumed.

Study problem authored for this guide, not represented as an original university tutorial question.

Essential reading explained: learn it, reason with it, apply it

Prescribed-reading connection

Chapple et al, Company Law (3rd ed, 2023), ch 3, §§ 3.1–3.6 (company constitution, replaceable rules, objects and alteration).

Direct required reading for Week 3 Forum and Tutorial 3 (Week 4); supported by the lecturer’s PowerPoint notes on corporate liability and attribution.

The reading is a course/licensed text; it is cited, not republished. Textbook publisher and table of contents. For the current statutory wording, use the Federal Register of Legislation.

Lecturer-style teaching: what it means and why it matters

A company needs rules just as a sporting club does. But its rules have different legal sources. s 134 allows the company to use statutory replaceable rules, its own constitution, or both. s 135 identifies which replaceable rules apply and when. A provision cannot override a mandatory statutory rule merely because shareholders prefer their own wording. s 141 provides the table of replaceable rules. A notable exception is the single-director/single-shareholder proprietary company: check the special statutory regime rather than applying every replaceable rule mechanically.

A constitution is the company’s bespoke internal rulebook. Under s 136, adoption or alteration generally engages a special resolution (subject to applicable statutory and constitutional conditions). In an exam, do not stop at “75 per cent voted yes”: examine meeting notice, voting entitlement, any additional restrictions and whether the alteration has an improper or oppressive effect.

The statutory contract under s 140(1) is powerful but specific. It binds the company and each member, the company and each director and secretary, and members inter se to the extent the rules apply to their capacities. A member asserting a right conferred on them as a member is differently placed from someone claiming only as an employee, lawyer or supplier. This is why the Hickman and Eley examples matter in the prescribed textbook.

Company capacity and internal authority are separate questions. Under s 125, a corporate act is not invalid only because a company’s constitution restricts its activity. But a director may still breach an internal obligation, and a third party’s ability to enforce the transaction may raise separate agency and statutory-assumption questions. That is a Chapter 6 problem, not an automatic consequence of s 125.

To prepare Tutorial 3’s corporate-misconduct question, create a second branch: how is a natural person’s action or state of mind attributed to a company? The answer depends on the particular liability rule. Do not use a universal “directing mind” shortcut. Your lecturer’s Week 3 last-slide notes and the assigned articles by Walpole and Corrigan and Elise Bant provide the conceptual discussion. The articles are analytical readings, not substitutes for the governing criminal statute or controlling judicial authority.

Visual issue-spotting pathway

  1. 1Find the Act rule
  2. 2Check if replaceable
  3. 3Read the constitution
  4. 4Check the claimant’s capacity
  5. 5Apply the relevant remedy

This sequence is an issue-spotting tool; the case facts and applicable law still control the answer.

Illustrated tutorial application — the issue and rule in context

Issue. The majority changes a constitution to eliminate a minority shareholder’s procedural protection. Can the change be enforced? Rule. Start with s 136 (valid adoption/alteration), then s 140 (the relevant contractual right), and consider whether the change is constrained by general-law fairness principles or statutory remedies, depending on the exact facts. Application. Was a special resolution properly passed? Is the claimed protection a membership right? What does the clause actually say? Does the change affect share rights or involve an expropriation requiring the Gambotto analysis? Conclusion. A successful vote is an important fact, not a complete legal conclusion.

Compare this method with the original tutorial question and full model answer. Do not substitute this illustrative problem for the university question.

What a High Distinction-standard explanation must demonstrate

Identify every material issue and sub-issue; state the exact legislative source and the legal effect of its subsection; distinguish binding rules from commentary; explain the controlling case rather than name-dropping; apply facts for both parties; address limits, remedies and standing; then give a qualified, evidence-based conclusion. The course-participation High Distinction benchmark previously provided is 85%+: thorough preparation, sophisticated legal analysis, synthesis and evaluation, original thinking, practical and wider connections, constructive participation and professionalism. Explain how each issue meets those criteria in a tutorial response. This is not a substitute for an examination-specific marking rubric, nor a guarantee of any mark.

Essential-reading FAQs — questions with explanations

Is every rule in the Corporations Act a replaceable rule?

No. Only provisions designated as replaceable rules operate that way. Read ss 135 and 141 and check the heading of the relevant provision.

Can anyone named in a constitution sue to enforce it?

No. The statutory contract under s 140 is limited by its parties and the capacity in which a right is claimed. Separate ordinary contractual rights may also exist.

Does the company become automatically criminally liable when one employee commits an offence?

No. Identify the offence, its required fault elements and the statute or doctrine used to attribute conduct and fault. The Week 3 assigned attribution articles deepen that analysis.

Essential-reading MCQs — with answer reasoning

Question 1: Which section gives a constitution and applicable replaceable rules statutory-contract effect?

  1. s 119
  2. s 140
  3. s 181
  4. s 588G
Show answer and reasoning

Answer B. s 140(1) defines the statutory relationships; the capacity of the claimant still matters.

Question 2: An internal objects clause prohibits a transaction. What should you analyse?

  1. Assume the transaction is automatically void
  2. Apply s 125, then internal duties and authority
  3. Ignore the constitution completely
  4. Treat every director as a shareholder
Show answer and reasoning

Answer B. s 125 addresses validity. Internal compliance and outsider authority are separate issues.

Scope and publication note

Essential Week 3 supporting readings also include Walpole and Corrigan (2021), Bant (2025) and the lecturer’s final-slide notes; treat any broader theories of corporate intention as commentary unless the governing law adopts them.

Frequently asked questions — and actual answers

What creates a company?

Registration under the Corporations Act; generally, s 119 fixes the moment of its legal existence.

Can a constitution override every law?

No. Statutory rules of mandatory operation cannot simply be displaced by a constitution.

What is a replaceable rule?

A statutory internal-management default that may apply unless validly displaced; check the Act and company type.

Does s 140 create any contract a third party wants?

No. It creates specified statutory-contract relationships, so identify the claimant’s legal capacity.

MCQs: reason your way to the answer

Select an answer before revealing the explanation. Memorising an option is less useful than being able to explain why each legal distinction matters.

MCQ 1: Which provision is central to the statutory-contract effect?

Reveal the correct answer and explanation

Answer: B. Section 140 addresses the constitution and replaceable rules as a statutory contract.

MCQ 2: What is the correct first question about an internal meeting rule?

  • A. Can ASIC waive all rules?
  • B. What is the company’s governing source: Act, replaceable rule or constitution?
  • C. Did the CEO like the outcome?
  • D. Did any member object online?
Reveal the correct answer and explanation

Answer: B. The source of the rule determines its application and whether it can be altered.

MCQ 3: What usually makes a company exist as a body corporate?

  • A. Its first transaction
  • B. Its first employee
  • C. Registration under s 119
  • D. A shareholder’s bank account
Reveal the correct answer and explanation

Answer: C. The registered company comes into existence under s 119.

Now return to the full book and original tutorial

The complete chapter contains the fuller narrative, authority discussions and the existing tutorial material. This accessible guide is a supplement, not a replacement or a claim that every case pinpoint has been verified.

Read Chapter 3 in full · Tutorial library · Original approved PDF book