New: essential-reading teaching for Chapter 3. The prescribed textbook topics are explained in original plain English, with a statutory issue map, an applied problem, FAQs and reasoned MCQs.
Open the source-integrated guideNew: beginner-first companion for Chapter 3. A plain-English lecturer-style explanation, statutory map, worked IRAC example, FAQs and MCQs with explanations.
Start the easy-to-read guideORIGINAL PUBLISHED INTERIOR · 26 OCTOBER 2026
Chapter 3 — Registration, Constitution and Liability
Preservation note. The material below is a readable text extraction from the existing original book, kept in the same page order without editorial rewriting. Its complete, original approved page layout and link annotations are preserved in the PDFs. Open the complete reading edition.
Original book page 93
Registration, Corporate
Constitutions, Replaceable
Rules, Civil Liability and
Corporate Criminal
Responsibility
Week 3 Forum / Lecture
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Corporate attribution
Chapter purpose. Chapter 2 established that registration creates a
legal person separate from its members and directors. Chapter 3 asks
what that company looks like internally and how an artificial person
can be made legally responsible externally. We move from the
mechanics of registration to constitutions and replaceable rules, the
statutory contract under s 140, limits on constitutional alteration,
corporate capacity, civil attribution and corporate criminal
responsibility. The organising question is always the same: whose act,
knowledge or decision does the law treat as the act, knowledge or
decision of the company?
Teaching flow: register the company -> identify the internal rulebook
-> determine which rule is replaceable or mandatory -> ask who can
enforce the rule -> distinguish internal irregularity from external validity
-> identify the human actor -> decide whether liability is vicarious,
strict or attributed directly -> identify the mental element -> apply the
correct attribution rule.
CORPORATE LAW
92 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 94
3.1 Registration is the legal birth of
the company
Australian companies are created by registration. This point sounds
administrative, but it is doctrinally fundamental because registration is
the event that brings the separate legal person into existence. Under
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 117-119, an application is lodged with
ASIC, ASIC registers the company if the statutory requirements are
satisfied, and the company comes into existence as a body corporate
at the beginning of the day on which it is registered.
Students should connect this directly to Chapter 2. Before registration
there is no company capable of owning property or being a party to a
contract in its own right. After registration there is. That temporal line
matters later when we examine pre-registration contracts in Chapter
6.
Issue-spotting trigger. Whenever a problem involves something
done "for the company" before incorporation, identify the registration
date first. If the purported company did not yet exist, ordinary agency
language can be misleading because there was no principal capable
of authorising the act at that time.
The Week 3 lecture also emphasises what students do not need to
memorise: form numbers and the exact dollar amount of ASIC fees.
Fees change. The examinable idea is the statutory process and legal
consequence of registration.
CORPORATE LAW
93 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 95
3.2 Registration choices: type, name,
office, members and share structure
A registration application forces the founders to make several legal
choices. They must decide what type of company is being formed,
settle the proposed name or use the Australian Company Number in
the permitted way, identify the registered office, obtain the necessary
consents from proposed officeholders and members, and specify the
share structure where the company has share capital.
The name rules sit in Part 2B.6 of the Act. For exam purposes, the
important skill is not memorising a list of restricted words. It is
recognising that the company name is part of the statutory identity of
the new legal person and that ASIC controls registration of names
through the Act.
3.3 Registration does not end
compliance
Incorporation creates the company, but the company remains subject
to ongoing statutory obligations. The lecture highlights annual
statements, correction of company details, annual review processes
and annual solvency resolutions. The precise mechanics depend on
the kind of company and the current statutory scheme. The broader
corporate-law lesson is that limited liability and separate personality
come with continuing public regulation.
Question
Legal source
Why it matters
CORPORATE LAW
94 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 96
How is the company
created?
Corporations
Act ss 117-119
Registration is the point at
which the body corporate
comes into existence.
What governs
internal
management?
ss 134-141
Replaceable rules,
constitution, or a combination
of both.
What legal powers
does the company
have?
ss 124-125
The company has broad legal
capacity; an internal objects
clause does not generally
invalidate an external act.
How can a
constitution be
adopted or
changed?
s 136 and
related
provisions
Usually by the statutory
mechanisms, including special
resolution after registration.
What is the legal
effect of the
constitution/RRs?
s 140
They operate as a statutory
contract between specified
corporate participants.
3.4 The internal corporate rulebook:
s 134
Section 134 is the gateway provision. A company's internal
management may be governed by replaceable rules in the
Corporations Act, by a constitution, or by a combination of both. That
gives founders flexibility. A small proprietary company may be content
to rely heavily on statutory defaults. A larger or specialised enterprise
may require a detailed constitution tailored to voting, board structure,
share rights or other internal arrangements.
CORPORATE LAW
95 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 97
The key point is that "constitution" and "replaceable rules" are not rival
legal systems. They are components of the same internal governance
architecture. Section 135(2) allows a constitution to displace or modify
a replaceable rule that would otherwise apply.
Professional application. When advising a company, never assume
the Act alone answers an internal-management question. Ask for the
constitution, identify whether the relevant statutory provision is
mandatory or replaceable, and then determine whether the
constitution has displaced or modified the default rule.
3.5 Replaceable rules: defaults, not
optional law in the loose sense
The replaceable rules are statutory default rules. Their function is to
reduce the transaction costs of incorporation: a company need not
draft every governance rule from scratch. Section 141 provides the
table identifying the replaceable rules. But the student must read the
provision carefully because some rules are replaceable for proprietary
companies yet mandatory for public companies.
A recurring exam trap is to see the words "replaceable rule" and
conclude that every company can contract out of it. That is wrong. The
heading and the company type matter. Section 135 must be read
before assuming that a constitutional clause is effective.
Example. A clause saying directors alone may remove another
director can operate differently depending on whether the company is
proprietary or public. The Week 3 lecture uses ss 203C-203E to show
CORPORATE LAW
96 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 98
why public-company rules can be mandatory even where the
proprietary-company position is replaceable.
3.6 One-person proprietary
companies
A special statutory arrangement applies while the same person is both
sole director and sole shareholder of a proprietary company. Section
135(1) excludes the ordinary replaceable-rule regime in that situation,
while specific provisions such as ss 198E, 201F and 202C deal with
governance of that form. The point is not to become lost in
exceptions. The point is to recognise that internal-management law
adapts to corporate structure.
3.7 Corporate capacity: s 124
Section 124 gives a company the legal capacity and powers of an
individual, together with specifically corporate powers such as issuing
and cancelling shares and issuing debentures. This provision is a
statutory expression of a powerful idea: the company is not merely a
bundle of contracts between investors. It is a legal person capable of
acting in the legal world.
That broad capacity also explains why modern Australian law no
longer makes outsiders bear the old ultra vires risk in the way
nineteenth-century company law did.
CORPORATE LAW
97 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 99
3.8 Objects clauses and s 125:
internal limit, external validity
A constitution may contain restrictions on the exercise of corporate
powers and may state corporate objects. Section 125 is deliberately
careful about the consequence. An act is not invalid merely because it
contravenes a constitutional restriction or falls outside stated objects.
This separates two questions that students often collapse. First, did
the company act contrary to an internal rule? Second, is the
transaction externally invalid? Modern law can answer yes to the first
and no to the second.
The historical comparator is Ashbury Railway Carriage & Iron
Co v Riche (1875) LR 7 HL 653. Under the old ultra vires
doctrine, transactions beyond corporate objects could be void. The
Corporations Act rejects that harsh external consequence. The risk of
internal non-compliance is now generally dealt with through internal
governance and liability rules rather than automatic invalidity of the
transaction.
Exam sequence. If facts say the company acted outside its objects,
do not conclude "the contract is void". Start with ss 124-125. Then ask
whether the conduct creates an internal breach, a directors' duty issue
or some other consequence.
CORPORATE LAW
98 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 100
3.9 Section 140: the statutory
contract
Section 140 gives the constitution and applicable replaceable rules
contractual effect in three relationships: between company and
member; company and each director/company secretary; and
member and member. This is not an ordinary negotiated contract. It is
a statutory contract created by legislation.
Its purpose is enforcement of the corporate rulebook. But its scope is
defined by the statutory relationships. It does not create a general
contract between the company and every outsider who happens to be
mentioned in the constitution.
Relationship
s 140(1)
Core point
Company ↔
member
(a)
Constitutional/member rights can
be enforced in the member's
corporate capacity.
Company ↔
director/secretary
(b)
Officeholders are parties to the
statutory contract to the extent the
rules apply to them.
Member ↔
member
(c)
Members may enforce applicable
constitutional obligations against
one another.
Company ↔
outsider
No general s
140 contract
Being named in the constitution
does not itself create an ordinary
external contract.
CORPORATE LAW
99 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 101
3.10 Who can enforce the statutory
contract?
The lecture uses older authorities to illustrate the statutory-contract
logic. Hickman v Kent or Romney Marsh Sheep-
Breeders' Association [1915] 1 Ch 881 illustrates
enforcement in the company-member relationship. Re Caratti
Holding Co Pty Ltd [1975] 1 ACLR 87 illustrates the member-
member dimension. Forbes v NSW Trotting Club Ltd [1977]
2 NSWLR 515 reinforces that an outsider cannot simply invoke the
constitution as though it were a contract with them.
The deeper exam point is capacity. A person may wear several hats:
shareholder, director, employee, creditor. A constitutional right
enforceable in the person's capacity as member does not necessarily
become enforceable as an employment right. Older cases such as Ely
v Positive Government Security Life Assurance Co demonstrate that
distinction.
3.11 The statutory contract is
unusual
The s 140 contract differs from an ordinary contract in several ways. It
does not depend upon ordinary consideration or signature. Its terms
can be altered through the statutory constitutional-amendment
mechanism even without unanimous consent. Remedies are shaped
by corporate law and the nature of the right being enforced.
CORPORATE LAW
100 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 102
Students should therefore avoid mechanically importing every
ordinary contract doctrine. Section 140 is best understood as
legislation giving contractual force to the internal governance rules for
defined corporate relationships.
3.12 Altering the constitution: s 136
and special resolutions
A constitution may be adopted on registration in the manner specified
by s 136, or after registration through the statutory process. A central
concept is the special resolution, generally requiring at least 75% of
the votes cast by members entitled to vote on the resolution.
The lecturer expressly identifies this as assessable. Students should
know both the threshold and the institutional point: the members in
general meeting exercise this constitutional-amendment power. This
matters because corporate law divides powers between the board and
the members rather than treating "the company" as one
undifferentiated group of people.
3.13 Limits on constitutional
alteration
Corporate democracy is not unlimited. Section 140(2) protects a
member from certain post-membership alterations unless the member
agrees in writing, including changes requiring additional shares,
increasing liability to contribute or pay money, and certain increased
transfer restrictions.
CORPORATE LAW
101 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 103
The general law also limits expropriation of shares. Gambotto v
WCP Ltd (1995) 182 CLR 432 is the leading Australian authority.
For students, the important function of Gambotto is not simply to
remember the phrase "proper purpose". It demonstrates that majority
voting power over the constitution is constrained where the
amendment is used to compulsorily expropriate minority shares;
legality depends upon the recognised purpose and fairness
requirements articulated by the High Court.
3.14 The external problem: an
artificial person can still commit a
civil wrong
Once the company is recognised as a separate legal person, another
question follows: how can an entity with no physical body commit a
tort? Corporate law answers this through several attribution
mechanisms. The first is familiar from Torts: vicarious liability. A
company can be responsible for torts committed by employees within
the scope of employment even though the employee's act is not
treated as the company's own personal act.
This is secondary liability. The employee commits the tort; the law
makes the employer answer for it because of the employment
relationship.
CORPORATE LAW
102 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 104
3.15 Primary liability and organic
theory
Different problems require the law to treat a human act, knowledge or
state of mind as the company's own. This is the identification or
organic theory. The classic authority is Lennard's Carrying Co
Ltd v Asiatic Petroleum Co Ltd [1915] AC 705.
In Lennard's, the relevant managing individual had responsibility for
the vessel and its seaworthiness. The House of Lords treated his fault
and knowledge as the company's because, for the relevant function,
he was the directing mind and will of the corporate owner. This is not
ordinary vicarious liability. The law identifies the human decision-
maker with the company itself for the purpose of the relevant rule.
HL Bolton (Engineering) Co Ltd v TJ Graham & Sons
Ltd [1957] 1 QB 159 famously used the body analogy: some
corporate participants are the "hands", while senior decision-makers
may constitute the corporate "brain". The metaphor is memorable, but
the legal question must remain functional: who had authority to make
the relevant decision?
3.16 Tesco: not every manager is the
company
Tesco Supermarkets Ltd v Nattrass [1972] AC 153
exposes the limits of traditional identification doctrine. A supermarket
promotion was implemented incorrectly at store level. The store
CORPORATE LAW
103 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 105
manager had failed to follow Tesco's procedures, but the House of
Lords did not treat the store manager as the company's directing mind
and will for the relevant purpose.
The exam lesson is not that managers never count. It is that authority
matters. A person may be senior in a local operational sense yet
remain subject to instructions from higher corporate organs. The
traditional test focuses upon whether the person is entrusted with the
relevant corporate management power such that, within the scope of
that delegation, the person acts as the company rather than merely
for the company.
Why this became controversial. In a modern dispersed corporation,
important decisions may be delegated to teams or mid-level
specialists. A test focused too narrowly on the board or very senior
officers can make corporate fault difficult to establish even where the
organisation's own systems produce misconduct.
3.17 Meridian: attribution depends
on the purpose of the substantive
rule
Meridian Global Funds Management Asia Ltd v
Securities Commission [1995] 2 AC 500 provides a more
functional approach. The question is not always "who is the
company's single directing mind?" Instead, interpret the substantive
rule and ask whose act, knowledge or state of mind the rule intends to
count as the company's for that purpose.
CORPORATE LAW
104 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 106
In Meridian, investment personnel had authority to acquire securities.
The relevant disclosure obligation would have been undermined if the
company could avoid attribution simply because those personnel were
not the board. Their knowledge could therefore be attributed to the
company for the statutory disclosure rule.
Attribution method: identify the substantive legal rule -> ask what act
or mental state it requires -> identify who had authority to perform the
relevant corporate function -> determine whether that person's act/
knowledge should count as the company's for the purpose of that rule.
3.18 Corporate criminal liability
Companies can be criminally liable. The conceptual difficulty is mens
rea. A corporation has no biological mind, yet many offences require
intention, knowledge or recklessness. Different offences solve this in
different ways: strict liability may remove the need for mens rea;
legislation may impose vicarious criminal responsibility; and attribution
rules may identify human states of mind with the company.
The lecture distinguishes three broad categories: vicarious criminal
liability, strict or non-delegable statutory liability, and attributed primary
criminal liability. Students must identify which model the particular
offence uses rather than assuming one general theory applies to
every corporate crime.
CORPORATE LAW
105 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 107
3.19 Corporate culture and systems
Part 2.5 of the Criminal Code (Cth) contains statutory rules for
corporate criminal responsibility, including circumstances in which
corporate culture can establish the fault element. The lecture focuses
on the idea that a corporation's systems, policies and practices may
reveal organisational intention in ways that cannot be reduced to the
mind of one executive.
This point connects to systemic misconduct in banks, casinos,
education providers and other large organisations. Where decisions
are distributed across systems and teams, the question "who is the
guilty individual?" may fail to capture the organisational character of
the conduct.
3.20 Productivity Partners v ACCC:
systems as evidence of corporate
intention
The Week 3 lecture uses Productivity Partners Pty Ltd v
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission
[2024] HCA 27 as a modern illustration. Captain Cook College
used external recruiters in a government-funded vocational-education
model. Safeguards designed to identify unwitting or unsuitable
students were removed. The removal reduced attrition and
dramatically increased revenue.
The High Court's reasoning is important for corporate-law students
because the company's systems and the deliberate dismantling of
controls were capable of revealing corporate intention. The case
CORPORATE LAW
106 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 108
demonstrates a contemporary move away from asking only whether
one senior human being personally possessed a particular mental
state. Organisational design itself can be evidentiary.
Professional lesson. Governance systems are not merely
compliance paperwork. A board that receives evidence that a process
is producing unlawful outcomes and chooses not to repair it may
create powerful evidence about corporate intention, director
responsibility and organisational culture.
3.21 How the doctrines fit together
Problem
Question to ask
Doctrine
Internal
management dispute
What rule governs,
and is it mandatory or
replaceable?
ss 134-141 +
constitution
Company acts
outside objects
Is the external act
invalid, or is the issue
internal?
ss 124-125; abolition of
ultra vires
consequence
Member wants to
enforce constitution
Is the right held in a
capacity covered by s
140?
Statutory contract
Employee commits
tort
Was it within scope
of employment?
Vicarious liability
Human state of mind
must become
corporate state of
mind
Who exercised the
relevant corporate
function?
Identification/
attribution: Lennard's,
Tesco, Meridian
Corporate culture/
systems; Criminal
CORPORATE LAW
107 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 109
Systemic corporate
misconduct
What do systems,
policies and feedback
responses reveal?
Code Pt 2.5;
Productivity Partners
3.22 Exam attack sequence
Step 1: Identify whether the problem is internal governance, external
transaction validity, civil wrongdoing or criminal responsibility.
Step 2: Locate the exact statute and determine whether the rule is
mandatory, replaceable or constitutional.
Step 3: Identify the human actor and their corporate role/capacity.
Step 4: If fault or knowledge is required, state the attribution rule
before applying facts.
Step 5: Separate vicarious liability from primary attribution.
Step 6: Apply the authority that answers the same functional question
- Tesco for the limit of directing-mind theory, Meridian for purpose-
based attribution, and modern systems reasoning where
organisational design itself matters.
Step 7: State the legal consequence precisely: enforceability,
injunction, internal breach, compensation, penalty or criminal
responsibility.
3.23 Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Does every company need a written constitution?
No. Section 134 permits internal management through replaceable
rules, a constitution or a combination, subject to special statutory
situations.
CORPORATE LAW
108 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 110
Q: If a company breaches an objects clause, is the transaction
automatically void?
No. Section 125 provides that an act is not invalid merely because it is
contrary to an express restriction or beyond stated objects.
Q: Is a breach of a replaceable rule automatically a contravention
of the Corporations Act?
No. Section 135(3) expressly provides that failure to comply with a
replaceable rule is not, of itself, a contravention of the Act. The rules
have contractual effect through s 140.
Q: Can an employee enforce a promised employment benefit
merely because it appears in the constitution?
Not simply on that basis. The s 140 contract operates only within the
statutory relationships and capacity in which the right is held.
Q: Is corporate liability always vicarious?
No. Vicarious liability makes the company responsible for another
person's wrong. Identification/attribution can instead treat the act or
mind of the relevant human as the company's own.
Q: Why is Meridian so important?
Because it directs attention to the purpose of the substantive legal
rule and asks whose act or knowledge should count as the company's
for that rule, rather than insisting on one universal "directing mind".
3.24 Multiple-Choice Revision
The legal event that creates the company as a body corporate is:
A. signing the constitution
B. registration under the Corporations Act
C. the first board meeting
D. issuing the first invoice
1.
CORPORATE LAW
109 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 111
Answer: B. Sections 117-119 govern registration and the
company's coming into existence.
Section 134 permits internal management to be governed by:
A. only a constitution
B. only replaceable rules
C. replaceable rules, a constitution, or a combination
D. only shareholder agreements
Answer: C.
A company acts outside an objects clause. The best starting
proposition is:
A. the act is automatically void
B. the directors are automatically imprisoned
C. s 125 means the act is not invalid merely for that reason
D. the company ceases to exist
Answer: C.
The statutory contract is principally found in:
A. s 119
B. s 124
C. s 140
D. s 588G
Answer: C.
Which authority most directly illustrates the traditional "directing
mind and will" approach in a supermarket context?
A. Salomon
B. Tesco Supermarkets v Nattrass
C. Gambotto
D. Gilford Motor
2.
3.
4.
5.
CORPORATE LAW
110 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 112
Answer: B.
Meridian is important because it emphasises:
A. every employee is the company
B. the company's constitution is irrelevant
C. attribution should be tailored to the purpose of the substantive
rule
D. companies cannot commit crimes
Answer: C.
Productivity Partners [2024] HCA 27 is useful in this chapter
because it illustrates:
A. partnership formation
B. corporate systems as evidence relevant to organisational
intention
C. limited liability of shareholders only
D. winding up
Answer: B.
3.25 Short-Answer Practice
Question 1 - Explain the difference between corporate capacity
and an internal constitutional restriction.
Corporate capacity concerns what the company is legally
capable of doing. Section 124 gives broad legal capacity and
corporate powers. A constitution can restrict the exercise of
those powers or state objects under s 125, but the external act is
6.
7.
CORPORATE LAW
111 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 113
not invalid merely because the company acted contrary to that
restriction. The breach may instead create internal governance
consequences.
Question 2 - Why does s 140 require attention to capacity?
Because a person may be a member, director, employee and
creditor at the same time. Section 140 creates specific statutory
contractual relationships. A right written in the constitution is not
automatically enforceable in every capacity the person happens
to have. The analysis must identify whether the asserted right is
a member right, director/secretary right or member-member
obligation covered by the section.
Question 3 - Distinguish vicarious liability from attribution.
With vicarious liability, the wrong remains the employee's wrong
but the company is legally responsible because of the
employment relationship. With attribution or identification, the
law treats the relevant human's act, knowledge or mental state
as the company's own for the purpose of the substantive rule.
CORPORATE LAW
112 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 114
3.26 Constructed IRAC Problem -
Marlin Robotics Pty Ltd
Problem. Marlin Robotics Pty Ltd has a constitution stating that the
company must only manufacture industrial robotics. The board
nevertheless approves a profitable acquisition of a medical-software
business. A member argues the acquisition is void. Separately, a
senior compliance manager with delegated responsibility for
regulatory reporting learns that Marlin has crossed a statutory
ownership threshold in another listed company but deliberately does
not report it. The managing director and board are unaware. Advise
Marlin on the validity of the acquisition and whether the compliance
manager's knowledge can potentially be attributed to the company for
the reporting obligation.
Issue
The problem raises two distinct issues. First, whether Marlin's
acquisition is invalid because it falls outside a constitutional
objects restriction. Second, whether the knowledge and
omission of a delegated compliance decision-maker can count
as the company's knowledge for a statutory reporting
obligation even though the board was unaware.
Rule / Law
Section 124 gives a company broad legal capacity and
powers. Section 125 permits a constitution to restrict powers or
state objects but expressly provides that an exercise of power
or act is not invalid merely because it is contrary to the
CORPORATE LAW
113 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 115
restriction or beyond the objects. The old ultra vires
consequence illustrated historically by Ashbury Railway has
therefore been displaced in modern Australian company law.
For attribution, Lennard's and Tesco represent the traditional
identification model, under which a person exercising
sufficiently high corporate authority may constitute the
company's directing mind and will for the relevant function.
Meridian demonstrates that the attribution question is
ultimately tailored to the substantive legal rule: the court asks
whose act, knowledge or state of mind the rule intends to
count as that of the company.
Application - acquisition
The member should not succeed merely by arguing that the
acquisition is outside the stated object. Marlin has legal
capacity under s 124. Section 125 prevents the acquisition
from being invalid merely because it is contrary to an objects
clause. The constitutional breach may create internal
consequences, including questions concerning directors'
authority or duties, but external invalidity does not follow
automatically.
Application - regulatory knowledge
The compliance manager is not necessarily the company's
universal directing mind. Tesco warns against assuming that
any manager is the company. But the facts state that this
manager has delegated responsibility for the precise regulatory
reporting function. Meridian therefore provides the more useful
framework. If the statutory reporting rule is designed to require
the corporation to disclose once the person authorised to
manage the relevant investment/reporting function knows the
CORPORATE LAW
114 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 116
threshold has been crossed, there is a strong argument that
the manager's knowledge should be attributed to Marlin for that
purpose.
Counterargument. Marlin may argue that the manager was
subordinate, acted contrary to policy and withheld information
from senior management. Tesco shows that a subordinate's
default is not automatically the company's own state of mind.
The answer therefore depends on the construction and
purpose of the particular reporting rule and the scope of
delegated authority.
Conclusion
The acquisition is not invalid merely because it is beyond the
constitutional object. The internal breach must be analysed
separately. On attribution, the compliance manager's
delegated authority over the exact reporting function makes
Meridian highly relevant and creates a strong basis for treating
the manager's knowledge as Marlin's for that statutory
obligation, subject to the precise wording and purpose of the
reporting provision.
CORPORATE LAW
115 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 117
CORPORATE LAW
CHAPTER 3 — COURSE READINGS AND
TEACHING INTEGRATION
A single statutory map connects registration and constitutional
authority
Part 2A.2 of the Corporations Act includes ss 117–119: application, registration
and the company’s existence. Part 2B.4 includes ss 134–141 concerning internal
governance by constitution and replaceable rules. The lawyer’s sequence is to
ask whether the entity exists, which governance rules bind its members and
officeholders, and whether a disputed resolution complies with the Act and its
constitution. These are related inquiries, not interchangeable sections.
Section 117 is a registration application, not proof of existence
Section 117 identifies requirements for applying to register a company. Section
118 concerns the registration steps taken by ASIC. Section 119 fixes the day on
which the company comes into existence. The distinction matters when
considering whether a pre-registration transaction was made by a person who did
not yet have a corporate principal. Do not cite s 117 when the issue is simply the
legal date of the company’s birth; cite s 119.
Section 134 provides the internal rule sources; ss 135 and 141 identify
defaults
Section 134 allows a company’s internal management to be governed by
replaceable rules, a constitution or both. Section 135 explains their operation and
limits; s 141 provides a table identifying the replaceable provisions, and that table
must not be treated as a complete standalone code of director powers. Section
136 is the starting point for adopting and modifying a constitution. Section 140
gives statutory-contract effect among specified corporate participants in their
defined capacities. A complaint about governance thus requires identification of
the actual clause or replaceable rule, a competent applicant and a valid
procedure.
Ultra vires in historical comparison
The historic objects-clause approach, illustrated by Ashbury Railway Carriage
and Iron Co Ltd v Riche (1875) LR 7 HL 653, could render activities beyond
stated objects ultra vires. Today s 124 gives broad corporate capacity and s 125
116 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 118
CORPORATE LAW
addresses constitutional limits and their effect on validity. Changing Lemon Aid’s
business from lemonade to T-shirts is therefore not automatically void because of
an historical narrow objects clause. Internal governance consequences must be
analysed separately from the validity of transactions with outsiders.
Attribution of conduct and criminal fault: the rule supplies the relevant
question
In Tesco Supermarkets Ltd v Nattrass [1972] AC 153, the manager of a particular
shop did not constitute the company’s directing mind merely because he
managed that shop; the statute provided a defence in that particular English
regulatory setting. Meridian Global Funds Management Asia Ltd v Securities
Commission [1995] 2 AC 500 shows that the purpose of the substantive rule
affects attribution. Neither case means any careless employee’s state of mind is
automatically corporate mens rea. Identify the offence elements and applicable
Australian attribution rules before deciding whose conduct or knowledge is legally
attributed.
Criminal Code Part 2.5 and system-based proof must not be confused
Part 2.5 of the Commonwealth Criminal Code contains general provisions for
corporate criminal responsibility for offences to which it applies. Section 12.2
deals with physical elements attributed through conduct in the scope of
employment, authority or agency; s 12.3 concerns fault elements, including
routes relating to corporate culture and authorisation or permission. Do not use s
12.3 as an all-purpose rule for every state offence or statutory contravention. The
exact regime and any contrary offence-specific provision must be checked first.
Systems intentionality: the lecture’s important final-slide explanation
The final Week 3 lecture notes ask students to examine a company’s real
systems, repeated conduct, incentives, safeguards and feedback loops. In
Productivity Partners Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer
Commission [2024] HCA 27, the college’s dismantling of enrolment safeguards,
despite awareness of recruitment risks, supported findings concerning its
intention in that statutory unconscionability context. Elise Bant, “Rethinking
Corporate Groups: Insights from Systems Intentionality” (2025) 47 Sydney Law
Review, especially pp 1–3, examines how coordinated company systems may
evidence states of mind and how such reasoning might illuminate
parent-company responsibility. This is a developing interpretive approach: it does
not abolish separate corporate personality or create automatic group liability.
117 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 119
CORPORATE LAW
What the journal readings contribute to the tutorial
Samuel Walpole and Matt Corrigan, “Fighting the System: New Approaches to
Addressing Systematic Corporate Misconduct” (2021) 43 Sydney Law Review
489, assigned Parts II.B–C and IV, contributes the policy question whether legal
rules can respond to diffuse organisational misconduct. Penny Crofts, “Three
Recent Royal Commissions: The Failure to Prevent Harms and Attributions of
Organisational Liability” (2020) 42 Sydney Law Review 395, assigned in the
original tutorial and marked as supplementary in the updated reading directions,
provides an additional framing of institutional failures. The user supplied the
complete Bant PDF and the lecture’s final-slide notes; full copies of the
Walpole–Corrigan and Crofts articles have not been located in the supplied
sources, so their detailed arguments must not be purported to have been
reproduced or verified from full text.
The precise week 3 course reading map
The prescribed textbook locations are Chapter 1 pp 38–40, all of Chapter 3, and
Chapter 5 pp 135–139 (section 5.7 on tort and crime). The exact legislative
cluster is ss 117–119 and 134–141. The lecturer additionally points to *Tesco*
(slide 38 and optional case extract), the final slide 39 notes, and Australian Law
Reform Commission reform materials on corporate criminal liability. This map
keeps required and optional readings distinct and makes clear which full texts
have been supplied versus merely referenced.
The official Tutorial 3 question sheet and complete model answers remain printed
in full in the main chapter, immediately before the start of Chapter 4.
118 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 120
CORPORATE LAW
Understanding the constitution reading:
from internal rules to corporate
responsibility
The newly uploaded Chapter 3 Company Law PDF contains its learning-objectives
page (textbook p 75), not the full prose of that chapter. The six objectives nevertheless
supply a valuable structure: why a company needs governance rules; how replaceable
rules operate; the function of a constitution and an objects clause; who is bound; and
how rules are changed. This section connects those questions with the actual statutory
provisions and the user's Week 3 slides, forum and tutorial. It does not pretend the
missing textbook pages have been read.
Why an internal rule book matters even when a company has
legal capacity
Registration makes a company a distinct legal person and s 124 gives it broad
capacity, but a company cannot literally sit in a meeting or sign a document. Human
beings must make decisions in recognised capacities. This produces two separate
questions. First, can the company lawfully enter this kind of transaction? Second,
which person or company organ is authorised to decide and act for it? Sections
134–141 of the Corporations Act 2001 provide the main internal governance
framework for the second question, read with mandatory statutory provisions, common
law and any applicable constitution.
Under s 134, a company's internal management may be governed by replaceable
rules, a constitution or both. This is an introductory gateway, not itself an answer to
who has a particular power. Section 135(1) identifies which rules operate as
replaceable rules for relevant companies; critically, it makes special provision for
proprietary companies with the same sole director and sole shareholder. Section
135(2) allows applicable replaceable rules to be displaced or modified by the
constitution. Section 135(3) says a breach of a replaceable rule, simply as such, is not
automatically a contravention attracting the Act's offence or civil-penalty
consequences; the rules have statutory-contractual effect through s 140. Explain this
qualification in a tutorial rather than saying that any breached company procedure is
automatically a civil penalty offence.
119 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 121
CORPORATE LAW
Creating and changing the constitution
Section 136(1)(a) addresses adoption on registration with the required pre-registration
agreement of the proposed members, while s 136(1)(b) permits later adoption by
special resolution or by an applicable court order. Section 136(2) governs modification
or repeal by special resolution unless the legislation provides otherwise. The
special-resolution requirements must be applied precisely; students should not equate
a mere ordinary majority with the statutory voting threshold. Section 137 addresses
when relevant adoption or modification takes effect, and s 139 concerns provision of a
constitution to a member on request. The board and company secretary therefore
need a reliable current version of the constitution, its resolution history and appropriate
lodgement or notification records, rather than relying on an undated PDF circulated
years ago.
Section 140(1)(a)–(c) makes the constitution and applicable replaceable rules operate
as a statutory contract in specified relationships: company and member, company and
director or company secretary, and member and member, so far as the provisions
apply to them. Do not extend this automatically to everyone affected by a company. A
supplier is not ordinarily made a party to the statutory contract merely because the
supplier has read the constitution. Nor is every procedural promise enforceable as an
individual's ordinary employment right without first identifying the capacity in which it is
relied upon. Section 140(2) protects members against some retrospective changes
imposing additional share commitments, contribution obligations or share-transfer
restrictions without the relevant agreement, subject to the statutory detail. The
tutorial's question about who can enforce a rule should identify both the actual
claimant and the particular contractual relationship the statute creates.
The s 141 table is a research map: it directs a student to the appropriate replaceable
rule rather than resolving a factual dispute by itself. Students should find the exact
entry about management, meetings, director appointment or other governance issues,
and then determine whether that rule applies to the particular company or has been
validly replaced. A well-written model answer says why a public-company mandatory
rule or a special sole-director provision may prevent uncritical use of a replaceable
rule. The constitution is not free to override all mandatory provisions of the Act.
120 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 122
CORPORATE LAW
Objects clauses and modern company capacity
Historically, a company's stated objects could be important to whether a transaction
was beyond its permitted corporate purposes. Today's s 125 requires more care. A
constitutional restriction on powers or an objects provision does not automatically
invalidate a company act merely because the act conflicts with that internal clause.
The legal effect of the transaction must be distinguished from whether directors or
others breached internal governance obligations. In the Lemon Aid tutorial, if a
company set up to sell lemonade later sells T-shirts, the correct question is not simply
‘was T-shirt trading in the original objects?’. Check the current constitutional wording, s
125 and who validly approved the change of business. A separate claim against the
decision-makers may arise without the transaction itself being void.
From corporate capacity to attributing wrongdoing
The Week 3 lecture then shifts from rules governing corporate conduct to who bears
responsibility when harm occurs. A company cannot have a human brain, but it is
capable of civil wrongs and, where the particular legal rules permit, criminal fault. The
method is to identify the elements of the specific offence or cause of action first,
then find the legally applicable attribution rule. The classic English identification
approach illustrated by Tesco Supermarkets Ltd v Nattrass [1972] AC 153 was
comparatively restrictive in its focus on an individual's directing mind for a particular
kind of liability. It should be taught historically and in context, not presented as the only
modern answer to every Australian statutory offence.
For relevant Commonwealth criminal offences, Part 2.5 of the Criminal Code Act
1995 (Cth) contains statutory rules addressing corporate criminal responsibility,
including physical elements and fault elements. Section 12.3, for example, addresses
fault elements other than negligence and the ways authorisation or permission through
corporate culture or appropriate actors can become relevant. Which provisions apply
depends on the particular offence and governing legislation. A State-law prosecution
or a tailored statutory attribution regime may require a different approach. It is a legal
mistake to cite a general attribution theory without explaining its applicability to the
offence the prosecutor must actually prove.
121 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 123
CORPORATE LAW
Scholarly developments: attribution and corporate systems
The Week 3 reading list directs students to Samuel Walpole and Matt Corrigan,
‘Fighting the System: New Approaches to Addressing Systematic Corporate
Misconduct’ (2021) 43 Sydney Law Review 489. Its significance to legal education is
conceptual: it prompts students to ask whether repeated organisational misconduct
can be understood only by finding an individually culpable executive, or whether the
corporation's processes, incentives, recording systems and decision routines may be
relevant to an available statutory pathway to corporate responsibility. This is a
research lens; it is not permission to invent liability where no statutory or common-law
cause of action exists.
The user also supplied Elise Bant, ‘Rethinking Corporate Groups: Insights from
Systems Intentionality’ (2025) 47 Sydney Law Review. Bant examines how a
company, including a corporate parent, may express knowledge or intention through
coordinated systems of conduct rather than merely through one individual's mental
state. Her discussion engages with Productivity Partners Pty Ltd v Australian
Competition and Consumer Commission [2024] HCA 27 and reasoning directed to
systemic unconscionable conduct. The careful practical question is whether a parent's
own procedures, governance choices or group-wide policies can form part of its own
contravening conduct or knowledge. That is not the same as declaring the subsidiary
and parent a single legal person, and Bant's scholarly proposal should not be
misrepresented as a universal statutory rule already enacted for all corporate
offences.
The prescribed optional Penny Crofts reading on organisational attribution provides a
further critical perspective on why formal individualist models can fail to account
adequately for organisational harm. Students should identify whether a quotation is a
legislative rule, a court holding, an academic criticism or proposed reform. The first two
may provide operative law; the latter two deepen understanding, illuminate policy and
potentially support arguments where legal doctrine leaves room, but do not substitute
for the elements of the relevant offence.
122 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 124
CORPORATE LAW
Tutorial method: keep the two problem families distinct
For Lemon Aid, the questions concern registration, internal governance, contractual
enforcement and objects. Apply ss 117–119 to the act of creating the company; ss
134–141 to the rule framework; s 140 to the relevant parties' enforcement rights; and s
125 to the effect of an objects restriction. For the corporate-criminal-liability
question, start anew: identify the exact offence, the applicable attribution regime, the
fault or physical elements, which persons or systems supplied evidence, and possible
defences. Bring Tesco, the modern statutory approach, Walpole–Corrigan and Bant
into the discussion for the distinct analytical jobs each can actually perform. The model
answer should finish by saying what documents—board minutes, internal policies,
training records, approvals, complaints, incident histories or audits—the lawyer would
seek before advising on a corporation's liability.
The broader connection to Chapter 4 is profound: a governance rule allocates
responsibility to a board, but real organisations act through processes. The board must
understand who can act and how lawful supervision and reporting systems function.
This is why a student who has carefully understood constitutional rules and attribution
is much better prepared to study directors' responsibilities.
Source alignment: Chapple et al, Company Law (3rd ed, 2023), Chapter 3 learning-objectives
page 75 (only supplied textbook page); Bond Week 3 lecture, final-slide notes, Tutorial 3 and
transcript; the separately supplied Bant article. The full body text of the textbook's Chapter 3 was
not included in the supplied extract.
Primary legislative research: Corporations Act 2001, Federal Register of Legislation. For statutory
detail, use the provisions identified above and check the version operative on the material date.
123 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 125
Connecting registration, governance and corporate
responsibility
Registration • constitutions • replaceable rules • civil and criminal attribution • corporate
systems
1. Four questions that make Chapter 3
understandable
Imagine that classmates agree to operate Lemon Aid Pty Ltd. At first glance, the plan
looks simple: agree on a name, choose directors and sell lemonade. A future lawyer must
see four legally distinct questions. First, has a separate legal person actually come into
existence? This is the registration question. Secondly, which rules govern the
relationship between the company, members and directors? This is the internal-
governance question. Thirdly, does the company have capacity to make the proposed
transaction, even if the company has broken its own internal rules? This is the
corporate-capacity question. Finally, if a person causes harm while operating the
business, on what basis can the act or mental state be treated as the company's?
This is the external-liability and attribution question.
The lecturer's recurring triangle makes this distinction visual: the company is the legal entity;
the directors exercise management functions; members hold shares and relevant voting
rights. Those components are connected, but they are not interchangeable. This explains
why a company can remain bound to a third party even though its directors have disobeyed
a constitutional restriction. It also explains why an employee's wrongful conduct can
sometimes create liability for the company even though the company has no natural body or
mind of its own.
2. Registration: ss 117, 118 and 119 are a sequence,
not synonyms
The relevant legislation is Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), Chapter 2A, Part 2A.2. Under s
117(1), a person seeking to register a company must lodge the application with ASIC. The
remaining provisions of s 117 deal with the information and consents involved in that
application. When advising clients, check the intended company type, proposed members
and share structure, registered office and director consents. The lecture rightly says that
CORPORATE LAW
124 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 126
students should know the general process, but not memorise filing prices or form numbers,
which change over time.
Section 118 concerns ASIC's registration step: ASIC gives the company an Australian
Company Number (ACN), registers it and issues a certificate. Section 119 is the decisive
legal event: a company comes into existence at the beginning of the day on which it is
registered, takes the registered name and becomes capable of performing all the functions
of a body corporate. The sequence matters: making a plan or lodging an application is not
the same thing as having a registered corporation. In a problem question, identify the
precise day of registration and whether any transaction occurred before it. Contracts
entered into before registration may require separate analysis under ss 131–133.
Practical advice. A client who signs a supply agreement on Monday but registers the
company on Thursday should not simply assume that the company was a contracting party
on Monday. First identify the counterparty and the governing pre-registration-contract rules.
The question is not resolved by calling the business "Lemon Aid Pty Ltd" in the negotiations.
3. What governs the company's internal
relationships? Start with s 134
Section 134 is the gateway. It explains that internal management may be regulated through
replaceable rules, a constitution, or a combination. The distinction is fundamental. A
replaceable rule is a statutory default. A constitutional provision may displace or modify the
default, but not a mandatory provision of the Act. Therefore, finding an apparently relevant
rule in the Act is only the beginning. Ask whether the provision is a replaceable rule,
whether a constitution exists, whether that constitution changes it, and whether another
mandatory rule overrides the proposed arrangement.
Section 135(1) identifies when the replaceable rules apply and makes distinctions between
company types; s 135(2) permits a constitution to displace or modify an applicable
replaceable rule. Section 135(3) is especially examinable: failure to comply with a
replaceable rule does not, of itself, amount to a statutory contravention attracting the Act's
ordinary civil or criminal consequences. This does not make the rules pointless. Through s
140, the constitution and applicable replaceable rules operate as a statutory contract.
Students must distinguish an internal contractual claim from a statutory civil-penalty offence.
Section 141 contains the table locating the replaceable rules. The lecturer warns that the
leftmost item numbers are merely table numbers: identify the actual Act provision in the
right-hand column. For example, the management rule is found at s 198A; appointment by
members at s 201G; appointment by directors at s 201H; and proprietary-company director
CORPORATE LAW
125 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 127
removal at s 203C. Each may be displaced if genuinely replaceable; public-company
director removal under s 203D is not replaced by an inconsistent constitutional rule.
These connections also bridge directly to Chapter 4.
The narrow rule for a one-director, one-shareholder proprietary company deserves separate
attention: s 135(1) has a specific exception for applicable replaceable rules in those
circumstances, while ss 198E, 201F and 202C provide special rules. Never assume that a
rule designed for an ordinary multi-person board applies unchanged to a single-person
company.
4. A company's constitution: creation, alteration and
limitations
Section 136(1)(a) addresses adopting a constitution on registration, with the requisite
agreement of the proposed members. Section 136(1)(b) allows a company to adopt a
constitution after registration by special resolution. Section 136(2) provides the usual
method to modify or repeal the constitution: a special resolution. The concept of a special
resolution must be tied to s 9, including the requirements for notice and at least 75 per cent
of votes cast by members entitled to vote. A 75 per cent threshold is not a requirement
that 75 per cent of all issued shares support a proposal irrespective of voting.
The company constitution can allocate internal procedural powers, but must coexist with
mandatory law. Section 136(3) addresses additional constitutional requirements for
constitutional alteration in the circumstances it specifies. Section 140(2)(a)–(c) limits the
binding effect of later alterations on an existing member unless the member agrees in
writing where the alteration requires additional shares, increases relevant contribution or
payment liabilities, or restricts transfer rights (subject to stated exceptions). A lawyer must
read each paragraph and any exception before asserting that a majority can bind all
members to an increased obligation.
In Gambotto v WCP Ltd (1995) 182 CLR 432, the High Court addressed constitutional
amendments enabling compulsory acquisition of minority shares. The principle is not that all
constitutional alterations affecting investors are invalid. The analysis asks whether
expropriation is for a permissible purpose and whether it is fair in all the circumstances.
Apply Gambotto when a change forces a member to surrender an ownership interest, not
mechanically whenever a company amends a constitution.
Teaching example. If Lemon Aid's members want the class representatives to approve
future share transfers, ask first whether that provision can validly be adopted or amended.
Then ask who is entitled to enforce it as a membership-related right. Only after those
CORPORATE LAW
126 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 128
questions should you examine whether the clause conflicts with the Act or other applicable
legal principles.
5. The statutory contract: s 140 contains three
relationships
Section 140(1)(a) creates the statutory contractual relationship between the company and
each member. Section 140(1)(b) concerns the company and each director and
company secretary. Section 140(1)(c) concerns members as between themselves.
These are separate statutory relationships, not interchangeable descriptions of one
contract. In any tutorial problem, write the relevant paragraph out and explain why that
plaintiff is a party entitled to enforce the particular right.
The leading authorities concerning rights conferred by constitutions, including Hickman v
Kent or Romney Marsh Sheep-Breeders' Association [1915] 1 Ch 881, Eley v Positive
Government Security Life Assurance Co Ltd (1876) 1 Ex D 88 and Bailey v NSW
Medical Defence Union Ltd (1995) 184 CLR 399, distinguish member rights from merely
personal or outsider rights. A clause mentioning a person does not necessarily confer an
enforceable right on that person in every capacity. Class representatives who are not
members or officers cannot assert statutory-contract standing merely because they are
named in the constitution. Consider their actual legal relationship and whether a separate
enforceable bargain exists.
The practical sequence is identify the clause → identify the intended right → identify
the claimant's capacity → identify the relevant s 140 relationship → consider any
statutory or equitable qualification → state the available relief. Relief for breach may
include a declaration or injunction in suitable circumstances; a private-party contractual
remedy cannot be assumed without establishing standing, breach and the court's power.
6. Corporate capacity is not the same as internal
permission: ss 124–125
Section 124(1) broadly confers on a registered company the legal capacity and powers of
an individual, together with specified body-corporate powers such as issuing shares. The
old doctrine of ultra vires allowed objects clauses to invalidate transactions outside the
company's objects. Ashbury Railway Carriage & Iron Co Ltd v Riche (1875) LR 7 HL 653
illustrates the historical doctrine; it does not state the current Australian statutory result.
CORPORATE LAW
127 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 129
Section 125(1) states that exercise of a power is not invalid merely because it breaches an
express constitutional restriction or prohibition. Section 125(2) similarly provides that an act
is not invalid merely because it goes beyond stated objects. A limited corporate purpose is
therefore not necessarily an external obstacle to a valid contract. It may instead create an
internal governance problem concerning whether directors acted within their authority and
duties. This reflects the lecturer's policy question: which is more efficient and fair, forcing
outsiders to police internal objects clauses or protecting transactions while enforcing
internal discipline?
Tutorial example. Lemon Aid's constitution refers to selling lemonade. Its directors
subsequently order t-shirts. Start with ss 124 and 125(2), not with an automatic assertion
that the t-shirt purchase is void. Then consider internal allocation of decision-making power,
relevant director duties and any other independently applicable statutory or contractual
constraints. Do not substitute a constitution's internal restriction for a lack of corporate
capacity.
7. Civil wrongdoing: primary attribution and vicarious
liability are different routes
A corporation is a separate legal person, but its activities occur through human beings and
organisational systems. A claimant must identify the duty or wrong before selecting a
method of attribution. Vicarious liability is secondary responsibility for qualifying conduct of
another person: the relationship and connection between the wrongdoing and employment
or another recognised basis are critical. Primary or direct liability, by contrast, treats
conduct or knowledge attributable under the applicable rule as the company's own. The
mere fact that an employee works for the company does not prove every form of direct
corporate fault.
The traditional organic theory, taught through Lennard's Carrying Co Ltd v Asiatic
Petroleum Co Ltd [1915] AC 705 and HL Bolton (Engineering) Co Ltd v TJ Graham &
Sons Ltd [1957] 1 QB 159, asks whether a particular human decision-maker operated as
the company's directing mind and will for the relevant activity. In Lennard's, the ship-
owner company's ability to invoke the statutory exemption depended on actual fault or
privity. The executive's management role in relation to the ship made his relevant
knowledge attributable to the corporation. The lesson is not that the managing director is
automatically the company's mind for every conceivable issue; ask who had entrusted
responsibility for the function at issue.
Tesco Supermarkets Ltd v Nattrass [1972] AC 153 is the lecturer's critical counter-
example. A store manager failed to follow promotional pricing procedures, leaving
CORPORATE LAW
128 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 130
customers exposed to misleading pricing. The House of Lords considered a defence under
the particular UK Trade Descriptions Act scheme and distinguished a manager carrying out
instructions from a person acting as the corporation's controlling mind. The store manager
was not, on those facts and in that statutory setting, the company's directing mind. This
does not give every company blanket immunity for failures by local managers. The result
depends on the wording, purpose and structure of the relevant substantive law, and on
which form of liability is being claimed.
Meridian Global Funds Management Asia Ltd v Securities Commission [1995] 2 AC
500 provides the necessary modern qualification. Attribution rules must be selected in light
of the purpose of the rule to be applied. A disclosure obligation could be defeated if
knowledge held by the relevant employees could never count as knowledge of the
corporation. Thus, do not teach Tesco as an eternal, universal rule that only board
members' minds may be attributed. Ask what the particular legislature or rule is trying to
make the corporation do and whose knowledge is relevant to that function.
8. Corporate criminal responsibility: identify the
offence before the attribution test
The lecturer's slides distinguish criminal offences that do not require proof of fault from
offences involving intention, knowledge or recklessness. That distinction controls your
answer. Do not assume that every corporate offence requires an identifiable individual with
a guilty mind. Conversely, do not assume that a company commits an offence solely
because wrongdoing occurred somewhere within its workforce. Start with the statute
creating the offence: identify its physical elements, fault elements and any defence,
including any objective or strict-liability formulation.
For offences governed by the Commonwealth Criminal Code, corporate responsibility is
addressed in Part 2.5, Division 12 of the Schedule to the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth).
Section 12.1 establishes the application of that Part; s 12.2 addresses attribution of
physical elements performed by employees, agents or officers acting within actual or
apparent employment or authority. Section 12.3(1) governs specified fault elements—
intention, knowledge or recklessness—by requiring corporate authorisation or permission in
the terms of that provision. It is not enough to recite 'corporate culture' without identifying
the particular offence and how the fault element is said to have been established.
The alternative methods in s 12.3(2)(a)–(d) matter individually. Paragraph (a) concerns
action or authorisation by the board; (b) a high managerial agent, subject to the due-
diligence defence in s 12.3(3); (c) a corporate culture that directed, encouraged, tolerated
or led to non-compliance; and (d) a failure to create and maintain a culture requiring
CORPORATE LAW
129 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 131
compliance. Section 12.3(4) identifies relevant considerations for the culture pathways, and
s 12.3(6) defines 'corporate culture' and 'high managerial agent'. The lecturer's notation 's
12.3(c), (d)' is shorthand; for accurate statutory referencing use s 12.3(2)(c)–(d). The
Code's specific application requirements must be satisfied; it is not a universal template for
every State crime or regulatory offence.
The slide discussion of a childcare-service prosecution is an example of why a court may
focus on the breach of a direct statutory obligation rather than attempt to prove a senior
manager's guilty mind. Before using it in an answer, identify the enactment and whether the
offence is strict liability, absolute liability or subject to a specific defence. Each is legally
different. Do not infer that a company's only possible consequences are fines, or that
criminal liability automatically follows from civil compensation.
9. Why organisational systems now matter
Traditional 'find the guilty individual' approaches can struggle with dispersed decision-
making. A large company may generate harm through a combination of recruitment
incentives, computer processes, customer scripts, targets, audits, complaints handling and
management responses. There may be no single employee who designed the entire
sequence. The lecturer's final slide therefore asks students to analyse systems of
conduct, policies, practices and feedback loops. This is not rhetoric: the organisation's
operational architecture may be evidence of what it actually intended or tolerated.
In Productivity Partners Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission
[2024] HCA 27, concerning Captain Cook College, the High Court examined the operation
of a VET enrolment system and the dismantling of safeguards that had prevented
unsuitable students from being enrolled. The case arose under s 21 of the Australian
Consumer Law concerning unconscionable conduct, not a prosecution under Criminal
Code s 12.3. The evidence about corporate practices and their foreseeable effect supported
the legal analysis under the ACL. A particularly important idea is responsiveness: an
organisation may learn that its practices cause harm and then either correct the system or
decide to retain it because it is profitable. The latter can be probative of its attitude and
purpose. Yet bad outcomes alone do not prove a specific mental element; an uncorrected
mistake must be evaluated in context.
The assigned article by Elise Bant, 'Rethinking Corporate Groups: Insights from Systems
Intentionality' (2025) 47 Sydney Law Review, explains how corporate groups may operate
through coordinated systems and why the parent's own system design can be relevant to
direct responsibility. An article is scholarship, not a newly enacted rule. Do not present its
proposals as automatic piercing of the corporate veil. If advising a claimant, identify an
CORPORATE LAW
130 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 132
established cause of action against the relevant legal entity, then ask whether the evidence
of group systems proves that defendant's own elements of liability.
Samuel Walpole and Matt Corrigan, 'Fighting the System: New Approaches to Addressing
Systematic Corporate Misconduct' (2021) 43(4) Sydney Law Review 489, examines
system-of-conduct offences as a reform proposal. The course directs students to Parts
II.B–C and IV. Penny Crofts, 'Three Recent Royal Commissions: The Failure to Prevent
Harms and Attributions of Organisational Liability' (2020) 42 Sydney Law Review 395,
provides further policy context. ALRC Report 136, Corporate Criminal Responsibility
(2020) contains reform recommendations, which must not be confused with enacted
offences. Use these resources to critique older attribution approaches, not to replace exact
statutory elements.
Worked example. A retailer's billing algorithm overcharges customers. At first, the error may
be a systems failure. Once the business receives repeated complaints and authoritative
reports, continuing to run the flawed process for financial advantage changes the evidential
picture. A lawyer asks: what did the relevant officers know, when did they know it, what did
the company do in response, what legal obligation governed the conduct, and does the
evidence satisfy the precise fault test? That is the teaching value of systems intentionality.
10. The two original Tutorial 3 question families —
why the chosen provisions differ
Lemon Aid (Question 1) is principally a problem about legal formation and internal
allocation of rights. For registration, cite ss 117–119 and say why each is a different stage.
For whether class representatives can approve company decisions, find the constitutional
clause and the statutory s 134 / s 135 / s 140 framework, identifying exactly who can
enforce the relevant clause and in which capacity. For moving from lemonade to t-shirts,
explain s 124(1) and s 125(2), and why a conflict with a company's objects is not itself an
invalid transaction. Where amendment is needed, explain s 136(1)–(2), the special-
resolution definition in s 9, and any limits under s 140(2). Use Gambotto only if the actual
change warrants that analysis.
Corporate criminal liability (Question 2) begins at a different location. Identify the
statutory offence and the relevant legal person; separate strict or absolute liability from
offences requiring fault; then explain Criminal Code ss 12.1–12.3 if applicable. Use
Lennard's, Tesco and Meridian to explain the history and limits of personal attribution, but
keep each tied to its own legal context. Use Productivity Partners and Bant to explain why
systems may evidence corporate intention, remembering that the High Court case concerns
CORPORATE LAW
131 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 133
ACL unconscionability. Use Walpole–Corrigan and the ALRC as reform and policy
discussion, not freestanding liabilities.
The following original tutorial questions and their full model answers now test these
connected principles. A successful answer explains why each statutory provision and
authority is relevant, identifies the facts that must be proved, addresses the strongest
counterargument and reaches a reasoned conclusion.
11. Key legislation summary — what provision
answers which question?
Corporations Act ss 117(1), 118, 119: application; ASIC registration/ACN/certificate;
legal existence.
Corporations Act s 134; s 135(1)–(3); s 141: constitution and replaceable-rule
sources, displacement, statutory-contract rather than automatic civil/criminal penalty,
and the replaceable-rule locator table.
Corporations Act s 136(1)–(3) and s 9: adopting/changing a constitution and special
resolutions.
Corporations Act s 140(1)(a)–(c), (2)(a)–(c): three statutory-contract relationships and
member-protection limits on later alterations.
Corporations Act ss 124(1), 125(1)–(2): corporate capacity and the consequences of
objects/powers restrictions.
Criminal Code Part 2.5, ss 12.1–12.3: when this Commonwealth corporate-attribution
regime applies, how conduct is attributed, and the distinct means of proving specified
fault elements, especially s 12.3(2)(c)–(d).
Australian Consumer Law s 21: the substantive unconscionability provision
considered in Productivity Partners, which is not Criminal Code s 12.3.
12. Week 3 research resources and reading guide
The designated Company Law (3rd ed, 2023) pages are Chapter 1, pp 38–40; entire
Chapter 3; and Chapter 5, pp 135–139 (s 5.7). The supplied 'Chapter 3' PDF contains the
learning-objectives page only, so the surrounding textbook content is not presented as
directly verified. The lecture, final-slide notes, original tutorials, primary legislation and the
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
CORPORATE LAW
132 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 134
following verified public references have been used to create this original additional
explanation:
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), latest authorised compilation — Federal Register —
locate ss 117–119, 124–125 and 134–141 in Volume 1.
Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), current legislation — Federal Register — Schedule,
Chapter 2, Part 2.5, especially ss 12.1–12.3.
Commonwealth Criminal Code, s 12.3 — Attorney-General's Department practitioner
guide — a direct provision-focused explanatory source.
Productivity Partners Pty Ltd v ACCC [2024] HCA 27 — High Court judgment page —
the actual Australian Consumer Law decision and its reasoning.
Walpole and Corrigan, 'Fighting the System' — Australian Law Reform Commission-
hosted original PDF — Parts II.B–C and IV are required reading.
Bant, 'Rethinking Corporate Groups' — university research record and DOI — assigned
pp 1–3, with discussion of the systems framework.
ALRC Report 136, Corporate Criminal Responsibility — reform proposals and policy
context.
The optional Tesco case extract and the Crofts paper remain recommended further reading.
The lecturer's notes on slides 37–39 are essential because the recorded forum ended
before that explanation was completed. A precise citation identifies the relevant legal
provision; a blue research link takes the student to the authoritative source. Where a
reliable deep link to a subsection is not available, the link goes to the official Act and the
subsection is spelled out in full rather than presenting an invented URL.
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
CORPORATE LAW
133 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 135
CHAPTER 3 — TUTORIAL 3
Registration, Corporate Constitutions and Corporate Civil and
Criminal Liability
The following tutorial belongs to Chapter 3 (Week 3 teaching) and was discussed in Week
4. The original university question passages are reproduced from the supplied Tutorial 3
handout. The answers distinguish what the question actually asks from supplementary
explanations students should know as prospective lawyers. The discussion uses the
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), the cases taught in Chapter
3 and the specified scholarly readings. References to legislation concern the law relevant to
the hypothetical, not a finding that the fictional company has committed an offence.
The legal reasoning map: three different questions
Company lawyers must avoid treating incorporation, governance and liability as one rule.
The first question is whether a legal person exists: ss 117–119 answer how a company is
registered and when it comes into existence. The second is how that legal person governs
itself: ss 134–141, along with its constitution and replaceable rules, tell us which internal
arrangements operate and which legal relationships are enforceable. The third question is
how the company incurs liability in civil or criminal law: its separate existence does not itself
prove fault, and the answer depends on the substantive obligation, attribution and the
applicable statutory offence.
The company is not identical to its directors or shareholders. The directors are normally the
management organ, but the company has its own legal personality. An action by a director
may be authorised internally, unauthorised internally but externally effective, or attributable
to the company for a particular legal purpose. Students must keep those distinctions
separate. The Lemon Aid scenario deliberately tests registration, replacement rules, the
constitution as a statutory contract, and the modern treatment of corporate capacity.
The later criminal-liability question asks a deeper theoretical question: can wrongdoing
committed across a corporate system be regarded as the company’s own culpability even
where the fault cannot neatly be located in one senior employee?
CORPORATE LAW
134 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 136
THE ORIGINAL TUTORIAL QUESTIONS — REPRODUCED IN
FULL
Question 1
Assume that our tutorial section has decided to form a class lemonade business as a
proprietary company, Lemon Aid Pty Ltd (“Lemon Aid”), using the example we have
discussed in the lectures this semester. Please give BRIEF answers to the following
questions:
How do we legally create the company? (Please answer this at a general level only (1-2
sentences); for our purposes, you do not need to descend into the minutiae of the process.)
We register Lemon Aid before discussing our mutual expectations regarding the internal
rules as to how the company will be governed. Assume that a dispute arises over whether
and how the class can remove the first directors who were named to the board when we
created the company. Where, if anywhere, can we look to figure out what needs to be
done?
Note: Please do not discuss HOW to do this. This question is merely asking where to look!
We will discuss the mechanics of how to do this later in the semester.
Our class decides that we want our company to have a rule that the Corporate Law class
representatives must approve all removals of directors from Lemon Aid board. Is there any
way to make this expectation legally binding? What procedure (if any) would need to be
followed to do this?
Assuming that there is a way to do this, who would be able to enforce that provision, and
what is the legal authority that creates the right to do so?
Halfway through the semester, we decide to change our business focus from selling
lemonade to selling t-shirts. Is there any legal restriction on our ability to do so? What is the
legal concept at issue here? Consider how this issue was approached historically
compared to now. What has changed? Who gains and who loses under the old versus
modern approaches? Which approach is better?
Question 2
Corporate criminal liability. Note: we will not study the many specific rules that impose
criminal liability on corporations (the separate legal entity, as opposed to the human beings
acting through the corporation). I want you to focus on the big picture conceptual
considerations relevant to this area.
CORPORATE LAW
135 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 137
What are the arguments for and against imposing corporate criminal liability on companies
themselves, rather than (or in addition to) on the individual human beings who used the
corporation to engage in misconduct or who allowed it to take place? Do you agree with the
concept of imposing criminal liability on the separate legal entity (the corporation itself)?
Why or why not?
Where a crime has a mens rea requirement, how do we figure out whose mental state is
treated as the company’s mental state for purposes of satisfying that element of the crime?
What are the problems with the older approaches to doing this and what modern
approaches are being used (or considered) to supplement them? Do you think the modern
approaches are a good idea? Why or why not? See Tesco Supermarkets Ltd v Nattrass in
the Library Resource List for additional context.
Note: to help you answer Question 2(a), please read the assigned selections from the two
extremely interesting law review articles provided in the class’s Library Resource List for
Week 3:
Parts II.B and C and Part IV in the following article: Samuel Walpole and Matt Corrigan,
‘Fighting the System: New Approaches to Addressing Systematic Corporate Misconduct’
(2021) 43 Sydney Law Review 489.
Introduction (Part I) and Part II of the following article: Penny Crofts, ‘Three Recent Royal
Commissions: The Failure to Prevent Harms and Attributions of Organisational Liability’
(2020) 42 Sydney Law Review 395.
CORPORATE LAW
136 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 138
HIGH DISTINCTION TEACHING ANSWERS
Question 1 — Lemon Aid Pty Ltd: registration, governance and
corporate capacity
Question 1(a): How do we legally create Lemon Aid Pty Ltd?
Issue. A collection of students cannot create a company merely by calling their lemonade
venture “Lemon Aid Pty Ltd”. They must incorporate under the applicable statute. The
name identifies the intended legal form, but it is the formal registration that creates the legal
person.
Exact law and its function. The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) makes registration an
Australian Commonwealth process. Section 117(1) allows an application to ASIC for
registration of a company. The application must contain the information required by the
balance of s 117, including the company’s proposed type, name and particulars of relevant
officeholders and members. Section 118 concerns ASIC’s registration of the company and
its issue of a certificate. Section 119 answers the decisive legal question: a company
comes into existence as a body corporate at the beginning of the day on which it is
registered, with the name specified in the certificate and subject to the Act.
Why use these provisions? Section 117 identifies the procedure; s 118 is the regulator’s
action; s 119 establishes the moment the separate legal entity exists. Without the s 119
step, a student may confuse the agreement to start trading with the birth of the incorporated
company. The company’s later capacity and ownership of property depend on the existence
of this separate legal person.
Tutorial-ready answer, matching the requested brevity. Apply to ASIC under s 117 to
register Lemon Aid as a proprietary company and provide the required particulars and
consents. ASIC registers the company under s 118, and s 119 establishes its separate
corporate existence on the registration day. The finer administrative details were expressly
not requested.
Professional note. Before giving real client advice, verify the preferred company type,
availability of name, shareholder arrangements, director eligibility and whether the intended
business needs specific licences. Those due-diligence matters are different from the
narrow registration question.
CORPORATE LAW
137 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 139
Question 1(b): We forgot to negotiate how first directors may be removed.
Where do we look?
Issue. The tutor deliberately asks where the rule can be found, not for a full director-
removal procedure. The problem is to identify the company’s applicable internal rulebook.
Law. Section 134 provides the organising framework for internal management: a
company’s internal management may be governed by replaceable rules, a constitution, or a
combination of the two. Section 135(1) identifies the companies and circumstances to
which replaceable rules apply, and s 135(2) permits constitutional provisions to displace or
modify replaceable rules. Section 141 contains the table of replaceable rules. The relevant
default provision for a proprietary company’s member removal of directors is s 203C(a)–
(b), allowing members by resolution to remove and replace a director. It is a replaceable
rule rather than the mandatory public-company regime under s 203D. Section 203CA,
however, imposes a separate statutory limit where the proposed removal would leave a
proprietary company without a director; this must not be mistaken for a replaceable rule
that can simply be switched off.
Application. Lemon Aid was formed before the classmates negotiated a tailored
governance arrangement. The lawyer should obtain its registration documentation and any
constitution. If no relevant constitution was adopted or if it does not displace the rule,
inspect ss 134–135, the s 141 table and s 203C, subject to applicable mandatory
provisions. Do not automatically apply the public-company removal procedure to a
proprietary company.
Direct answer. Look first at Lemon Aid’s constitution (if it has one) and then at the
applicable replaceable rules in the Corporations Act, especially s 203C, read with ss
134–135 and 141. The exact procedural steps were not requested, so a competent answer
identifies the sources without diverting into meeting notices and voting calculations.
Question 1(c): Can approval by the Corporate Law class representatives
become legally binding?
Issue. Students want a governance restriction requiring class representatives to approve
removal of Lemon Aid directors. The question is not whether that sounds fair; it is how to
create and enforce a legally operative rule, and whether mandatory statutory law constrains
it.
Law. Under s 136(1)(a) a constitution may be adopted on registration if the persons to
become members agreed in writing before the application was lodged. Lemon Aid did not
settle its expectations before registration; s 136(1)(b) therefore provides the principal route:
a company may adopt a constitution after registration by special resolution, or under an
CORPORATE LAW
138 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 140
applicable court order. Section 136(2) similarly permits modification or repeal of a
constitution by special resolution unless the Act provides otherwise. Section 9 defines a
special resolution and its notice/majority requirements; normally at least 75% of votes
cast by members entitled to vote on the resolution is necessary, in accordance with the
statutory meeting and notice rules. That is 75% of the relevant votes cast, not automatically
75% of all shares on issue.
The company’s constitution may displace or modify the replaceable director-removal rule
under s 135(2) and s 203C. A member-only shareholders’ agreement may also embody
contractual voting arrangements, but that is a different instrument and cannot be treated as
the company’s constitution. Statute still prevails over inconsistent internal rules: for
example, s 203CA protects against a proprietary-company member resolution that would
leave no director, subject to statutory exceptions; a constitution cannot make an otherwise
prohibited act valid.
Application. The class should first draft a precise approval provision. Who exactly are the
“class representatives”? How are they chosen and replaced? Is approval to be given in
writing? What if the representatives cannot agree or have left the course? Does the clause
cover all removals or only removals proposed by members? Does it purport to give veto
rights to non-members? These questions matter because a badly defined clause may
create costly disputes over whether valid approval occurred. If a company constitution is
adopted or amended in the required way, its provisions can have legal effect under s 140,
within the statutory framework. The students should distinguish a provision obliging the
members to vote only upon an approval process from a vague promise that a non-member
outsider will possess an automatically enforceable constitutional right.
Counterargument and qualification. A student might answer, “Put the veto into the
constitution and it is binding on everybody.” That is too broad. Section 140 defines
particular contracting relationships, not a contract between the company and every stranger
who happens to be mentioned. Further, if the proposed veto is inconsistent with a
mandatory rule, the statute controls. The question is about a proprietary company, so
students should not copy the public-company override in s 203D(1) without explaining why
it does or does not apply.
Conclusion and drafting advice. Yes, Lemon Aid can pursue a carefully drafted
constitutional approval rule by special resolution under s 136, displacing an inconsistent
replaceable rule insofar as the Act permits. The class should identify the beneficiaries,
voting threshold and procedure precisely, and separately consider whether an enforceable
members’ agreement is desirable. Do not promise that the clause can override mandatory
provisions or bestow direct contractual rights on every non-member representative.
CORPORATE LAW
139 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 141
Question 1(d): Who can enforce the approval clause, and why?
Issue. Once a constitutional clause is adopted, a lawyer must ask who sues whom and in
what legal capacity. A right being mentioned in a constitution is not enough; identify the
precise statutory-contract relationship.
Section 140(1) provides that a company’s constitution and applicable replaceable rules
take effect as a contract: s 140(1)(a) between company and each member; s 140(1)(b)
between company and each director and company secretary; and s 140(1)(c) between
each member and the other members. Each contracting person agrees to observe the
relevant rules so far as they apply to that person. Section 140(2) also protects existing
members against specified after-acquisition changes requiring extra shares, greater
payment obligations or restrictions on transfers without their written consent, subject to its
stated qualifications. It is important not to recite s 140 as if it covers unlimited outside rights.
Cases and why they matter. Hickman v Kent or Romney Marsh Sheep-Breeders’
Association [1915] 1 Ch 881 is used to teach that the constitution creates enforceable
relations in the relevant member/company capacity. Eley v Positive Government Security
Life Assurance Co (1876) 1 Ex D 88 is the classic warning that a clause giving a person a
role as solicitor does not necessarily allow that person to sue on the constitutional clause
as solicitor, an outsider capacity. The modern statutory analysis must still turn on the
Australian text in s 140, which is controlling; these older cases illustrate rather than
override the statutory relationships.
Application. A Lemon Aid shareholder whose membership rights are engaged may seek to
enforce an applicable approval requirement against the company, and another member
may have corresponding obligations in the member/member relationship under s 140(1)(c).
If a director or secretary invokes a genuinely applicable rule, consider s 140(1)(b) and the
person’s capacity. However, the class representatives, if they are not members, directors
or company secretaries, cannot simply assume an independent right under s 140
because the constitution names them. A separate contractual arrangement or an
appropriately structured member-based right may be necessary. Remedy depends on
standing, the threatened breach and the substantive clause: declaratory or injunctive relief
may be relevant, but not automatic.
Conclusion. Enforcement is through the specific statutory contract created by s 140(1)
(a), (b) or (c), only to the extent the rule applies to the person in the relevant capacity. This
is why the identity and capacity of each party are essential facts in a lawyer’s advice.
CORPORATE LAW
140 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 142
Question 1(e): Lemonade to t-shirts — the ultra vires problem and why
modern law changed
Issue. Is Lemon Aid legally disabled from changing its business from lemonade to t-shirts?
The issue is corporate capacity and the historical ultra vires doctrine, not simply the
directors’ commercial wisdom.
Historical law. In Ashbury Railway Carriage and Iron Co Ltd v Riche (1875) LR 7 HL 653,
a company established for specified objects purported to enter a contract outside those
objects. The traditional ultra vires doctrine could treat such a contract as beyond the
company’s capacity and void. The rule aimed to protect investors and creditors by
preventing deployment of pooled funds beyond the company purpose, but it created
insecurity for outsiders who might have no practical way to verify or control the company’s
internal objects. That historical rule must not be quoted as the current law for an Australian
company.
Present Act and pinpoint provisions. Section 124(1) gives a company the legal capacity
and powers of an individual and additional powers of a body corporate, subject to the Act.
Section 125(1) allows a constitution to restrict or prohibit the exercise of powers, but states
that an act is not invalid merely because it is contrary to such a restriction. Section
125(2) likewise allows the constitution to state corporate objects but provides that an act is
not invalid merely because it is contrary to or beyond those objects. These two limbs
address different drafting techniques: one restricts powers, the other states purposes.
Neither simply resurrects the historical external-invalidity rule.
Application. If Lemon Aid did not adopt a restrictive constitution, switching from lemonade
to t-shirts is not prohibited merely by its incorporation as a company. Even if it has an
objects clause focused on lemonade, the sale of t-shirts is not automatically void under s
125(2). The new business may nevertheless trigger internal questions about directors’
authority, constitutional compliance and duties, and external requirements such as licences
or trade-mark law. Those matters must be analysed separately from corporate capacity.
Who gained and who lost? Under the old approach, an investor who assumed the
company would never stray from its objects gained a rigid legal protection, but an innocent
trading counterparty could lose the bargain because of undisclosed objects. Under the
modern framework, trading counterparties and companies gain transactional certainty.
Members still have constitutional, statutory and governance rights, but cannot generally
avoid a corporate transaction simply because it goes beyond an objects statement.
Reasoned evaluation. The modern approach is preferable for commercial reliability
because it separates the company’s capacity to transact from accountability for
unauthorised decisions. That preference is a reasoned policy evaluation, not a statement
that governance restrictions or directors’ duties have disappeared.
CORPORATE LAW
141 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 143
Conclusion. The subject is ultra vires. Historically an outside-objects act could be void;
today ss 124(1) and 125(1)–(2) prevent external invalidity merely from a constitutional
restriction or objects clause. Lemon Aid can generally change business activity, while
internal compliance and other laws remain relevant.
Question 2 — Corporate criminal liability: why organisations,
and whose guilty mind?
Question 2(a): Arguments for and against corporate criminal responsibility
Issue. This is a question about the separate corporation’s possible criminal responsibility in
addition to, or sometimes instead of, responsibility of individual offenders. It is not satisfied
by saying that “companies cannot think”, nor by treating every employee crime as
automatically the company’s crime. A criminal conviction requires an actual applicable
offence and proof of its elements under the relevant regime. The tutorial specifically asks
for the conceptual architecture rather than an exhaustive list of offences.
Why corporate responsibility is recognised. A large company can organise and profit
from conduct through authority hierarchies, IT systems, product design, purchasing targets,
incentive schemes and reporting structures. Harm may be produced by the interaction of
those arrangements even where no single employee designs the entire course of
misconduct. If law prosecuted individuals only, a profitable corporate system could survive
their departure; the entity that controls the processes and receives the benefit might have
insufficient incentive to reform. Treating a body corporate as a possible defendant can
better align deterrence and remediation with the organisational source of the risk.
Arguments in favour. Corporate criminal liability can deter directors and senior executives
from designing unlawful operating systems; create incentives to fund training, controls and
reliable reporting; provide a formal public condemnation of serious organisational
wrongdoing; enable sanctions directed at the corporate entity rather than an unlucky low-
level worker; and make it possible to investigate aggregate, repeated patterns of harm. It
also addresses the practical problem of employee turnover: the organisation persists even
if the human agents leave.
Arguments against. A fine imposed on the corporation may ultimately harm innocent
employees, pension funds, shareholders or customers rather than those who chose the
conduct. Large companies may pay fines as a business cost; criminal proof and culpability
concepts designed for natural persons can be stretched unconvincingly; and there is a
serious risk of over-attribution if a rogue employee acting secretly is assumed to embody
the organisation. Criminal liability must not replace personal accountability for decision-
makers, and it must satisfy legality, procedural fairness and the applicable prosecution
CORPORATE LAW
142 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 144
standard. Effective enforcement may sometimes require civil remedies, compensation,
administrative sanctions and governance changes rather than relying on a criminal label
alone.
The two assigned scholarly readings. In Fighting the System: New Approaches to
Addressing Systematic Corporate Misconduct (2021) 43(4) Sydney Law Review 489,
Samuel Walpole and Matt Corrigan, especially Parts II.B–C and IV, analyse why offences
organised around a pattern or system of corporate conduct may respond more effectively to
misconduct dispersed across the organisation than models requiring a single individual
guilty mind. This is a discussion of proposed or alternative offence design, not a licence
to assume that every repeated compliance failure is already a general criminal offence. In
Three Recent Royal Commissions: The Failure to Prevent Harms and Attributions of
Organisational Liability (2020) 42(4) Sydney Law Review 395, Penny Crofts, particularly
the Introduction and Part II, examines serious institutional harms and the inadequacy of
attribution models that fail to recognise organisational structures as a source of culpable
risk. She discusses failure-to-prevent approaches as a reform direction. The two readings
complement each other: one focuses strongly on systematic conduct offences; the other on
institutional harms and failure-to-prevent responsibility.
Law versus policy. Students must explicitly distinguish existing Australian criminal law
from reform proposals. The Commonwealth Criminal Code, Part 2.5 (Division 12),
provides a statutory attribution framework, including corporate culture. Its reach depends
on the particular offence and applicable law. It does not follow that Part 2.5 is an automatic
answer to every State, Commonwealth or common-law offence. That jurisdictional
qualification is essential in a competent legal opinion.
My reasoned position. Corporate criminal liability is justified for offences in which the
company itself, through its agents and governing systems, can fairly be shown to satisfy the
governing legal test. It should be coupled with personal accountability where individual guilt
is proved, and sanctions should be designed to repair institutional controls rather than
simply transfer money from innocent shareholders. A serious lawyer also asks whether the
evidence proves criminal fault rather than assuming the seriousness of an adverse
outcome establishes guilt.
Conclusion. A coherent system should allow corporate criminal responsibility where a
legally defined offence and its elements are proved, especially where the misconduct
reflects organisational systems or culture. But it should not convict by association, conflate
civil regulation and criminal culpability or dispense with the separate analysis of individual
liability and possible remedies.
CORPORATE LAW
143 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 145
Question 2(b): Mens rea — whose state of mind is attributed to the company?
Issue. Many crimes require a physical element (actus reus) plus a fault element such as
intention, knowledge or recklessness (mens rea). A company has no brain, so the legal
question is whether the knowledge or intent of one or more natural persons, or features of
the corporate system recognised by statute, satisfy that particular fault requirement for that
company and offence.
Traditional identification doctrine. In Lennard’s Carrying Co Ltd v Asiatic Petroleum Co
Ltd [1915] AC 705, the court treated the conduct of a sufficiently senior controlling person
as capable of being the company’s own act. In Tesco Supermarkets Ltd v Nattrass [1972]
AC 153, the House of Lords considered the dividing line between the company’s directing
mind and an employee performing delegated work within a system of supervision. The
employee’s wrong did not automatically prove the company’s own mental state. Students
use Tesco to demonstrate the limitation of locating a corporate guilty mind only among
particular senior individuals: modern businesses frequently decentralise decisions, so
serious corporate harm may be distributed across workers, departments and software
processes.
Purpose-specific attribution. Meridian Global Funds Management Asia Ltd v Securities
Commission [1995] 2 AC 500 demonstrates that attribution should be analysed by
reference to the language and purpose of the substantive legal rule. The relevant
manager’s knowledge may be attributed for a particular disclosure obligation if the rule
would be defeated by insisting on knowledge only at board level. It does not follow that the
same manager’s knowledge becomes the corporate mind for every offence or civil duty.
Always identify the statute or substantive obligation first.
Commonwealth statutory model — exact sections. Part 2.5 of the Criminal Code Act
1995 (Cth), Schedule, includes: s 12.1(1)–(2), recognising corporate criminal responsibility
with necessary modifications; s 12.2, attributing physical elements committed by
employees, agents or officers acting within actual or apparent scope of employment or
authority; and s 12.3(1), concerning attribution of intention, knowledge and recklessness
where the corporate body expressly, tacitly or impliedly authorised or permitted the offence.
The non-exhaustive means in s 12.3(2)(a)–(d) include board conduct or authorisation,
relevant high-managerial-agent conduct or authorisation, the existence of a corporate
culture directing, encouraging, tolerating or leading to noncompliance, and failure to create
and maintain a culture requiring compliance. Section 12.3(3) and associated definitions
and qualifications must be considered where reliance is placed on high managerial agents.
Section 12.4 contains the framework for negligence, including assessment through
corporate conduct; it must not be casually substituted for proof of intention. Sections 12.5–
12.6 address particular defences or intervening matters. The section must be read with the
text and application of the offence alleged, and with any contrary legislative intention.
CORPORATE LAW
144 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 146
Why the subsections are not interchangeable. Section 12.2 is about the physical act or
omission. Section 12.3 is about specified fault elements, not negligent conduct
generally. Within s 12.3(2), the board/high-managerial-agent pathways are more person-
centred, while the corporate-culture pathways engage the organisation’s policies, practices
and accepted way of operating. An examiner may provide evidence of ignored safety
warnings, deliberately impossible productivity targets or systematic falsification. That
evidence must be matched to the legal pathway it actually supports, rather than being
treated as automatic proof of each one.
Worked lawyer’s method. Suppose a logistics company routinely instructs employees to
conceal a legally reportable safety incident. Begin by identifying the exact reporting offence,
whether it applies to a body corporate and its elements. Prove the physical element and
examine whether the employee acted within employment or authority for s 12.2. If
knowledge is required, use s 12.3(1) and identify available evidence supporting board or
senior-agent permission or the corporate-culture limbs under s 12.3(2). Policies, emails,
risk reports, executive minutes, staff instructions, whistleblower complaints and
enforcement histories are probative of what the organisation authorised or tolerated.
Defences and qualifications must then be separately analysed; the mere presence of a
safety policy in a handbook is not necessarily proof of a compliant operational culture.
The problem with older models. A business may be deliberately structured so that no
single executive knows every element of the offence. A strict identification-only model may
reward fragmentation of knowledge and fail to capture organisational misconduct. Yet the
opposite approach—pooling everyone’s knowledge without legal authority—risks
manufacturing a guilty mind. Modern purpose-specific attribution and legislation recognising
corporate culture are attempts to avoid both errors.
Reform and academic connection. Walpole and Corrigan argue that a system-of-conduct
or pattern-of-behaviour offence can address sustained wrongdoing where classical
individual-focused elements fit poorly. Crofts explores regulatory and criminal approaches
that focus on organisational failure to prevent harm, drawing on institutional evidence. Their
proposals are reasons to scrutinise how an offence is framed; they should not be described
as if each suggested offence has been enacted in Australia.
Counterarguments, consequences and remedies. The company may argue that an
employee acted secretly outside actual or apparent authority, that the relevant corporate-
culture evidence does not prove the particular mental element, or that the legal rule does
not contemplate that attribution. Prosecutors must prove the actual offence and the
necessary mental elements; corporate culpability is not established simply because an
incident was serious. Possible consequences include corporate fines and offence-specific
orders, regulatory directions or civil liability, depending on the legislation. Individual
employees or officers may separately face proceedings if their own statutory or common-
CORPORATE LAW
145 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 147
law obligations are satisfied. Whether disgorgement, compensation or management
disqualification is available depends on its own source of law: do not invent a universal
remedy.
Conclusion. Start with the specific offence and the correct jurisdiction. Explain Tesco as
the restrictive older identification model, Meridian as purpose-sensitive attribution, and
Criminal Code Pt 2.5 ss 12.1–12.4 as a possible Commonwealth statutory framework
separating physical elements, subjective fault and corporate culture. Compare reform
literature without confusing proposals with enacted rules. Only then make a conclusion
grounded in proved facts.
Chapter 3 — Statutory and case cross-reference for revision
Corporate existence — Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 117(1), 118, 119. Question: when
did Lemon Aid become a separate person? Their practical role is administrative application
→ ASIC registration → corporate legal existence.
Internal management — ss 134, 135(1)–(3), 136(1)(a)–(b), 136(2), 140(1)(a)–(c), 140(2),
141, 203C(a)–(b), 203CA(1)–(2). Question: whose internal rule governs? Can a
constitution change the default? Who can enforce the rule and what non-replaceable
statutory limits remain?
Company capacity and ultra vires — ss 124(1), 125(1)–(2) and Ashbury Railway
Carriage v Riche. Question: is the company legally incapable of the transaction, or did
someone merely breach an internal restriction? Do not treat those as equivalent.
Attribution and corporate wrongdoing — Lennard’s Carrying, Tesco Supermarkets v
Nattrass, Meridian Global Funds and the specific substantive civil or criminal rule.
Question: whose act, knowledge or intention counts for this legal purpose? Do not
confuse company liability with automatic personal director liability.
Commonwealth corporate criminal responsibility — Criminal Code Pt 2.5, ss 12.1–
12.6, especially 12.2 (physical element), 12.3(1)–(3) (specified fault elements and available
attribution pathways) and 12.4 (negligence). Do not assume this Part decides every State
criminal offence.
Academic and reform sources — Samuel Walpole and Matt Corrigan, ‘Fighting the
System: New Approaches to Addressing Systematic Corporate Misconduct’ (2021) 43(4)
Sydney Law Review 489, specified Parts II.B–C and IV; Penny Crofts, ‘Three Recent Royal
Commissions: The Failure to Prevent Harms and Attributions of Organisational Liability’
(2020) 42(4) Sydney Law Review 395, Introduction and Part II. Their arguments help
evaluate the strengths and limitations of established legal doctrine.
CORPORATE LAW
146 | CORPORATE LAW
Original book page 148
Final exam method: (1) classify the company and legal issue; (2) identify governing
legislation at the subsection level; (3) distinguish internal governance, corporate capacity,
attribution and criminal responsibility; (4) explain the case that gives meaning to the legal
rule; (5) apply every relevant fact and strongest counterargument; (6) identify additional
facts and documents needed; (7) advise on the conclusion and lawful remedy with
qualifications. This method is more persuasive than listing cases without explaining why
they apply.
Authoritative online source links
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), compilation effective 19 September 2026, Federal
Register.
Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), current legislation, Federal Register.
Walpole and Corrigan (2021) — published scholarly article (Sydney Law Review
PDF).
Crofts (2020) — published scholarly article (Sydney Law Review PDF).
Publication accuracy note: Authorities and statutes should be checked in the edition’s final
legal-source audit. Where a hypothetical lacks facts, conclusions are conditional; an
academic discussion of reform is not treated as proof that a proposed offence has been
enacted.
•
•
•
•
CORPORATE LAW
147 | CORPORATE LAW