CORPORATE LAW · BY DR ADRIAN ADAMS

CHAPTER 2 · Week 2 Forum → Tutorial 2 in Week 3 · BEGINNER-FIRST STUDY GUIDE

Incorporation, limited liability and the corporate veil

A company is not its founder. Incorporation creates another legal person with its own property, contracts and liabilities.

Start with this: how the law works

Imagine Sam forms a company and owns every share in it. Sam also manages the company each day. The business uses Sam's ideas, Sam's contacts and a building that Sam used to own. It is tempting to say the building is now “Sam's company property” and therefore also Sam's property. Legally, these statements must be unpacked. The company is a person distinct from Sam, and title depends on whether the property was actually transferred to it. Share ownership is not direct ownership of company assets.

The central starting point is Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] AC 22. The House of Lords recognised that a properly incorporated company has a legal identity separate from its controlling shareholder, even where one person exercises extensive control. The fact that the shareholder created the company or dominates it does not, by itself, turn the company’s liabilities into the shareholder's liabilities. That principle is an essential protection for commercial investment, but it also means a shareholder cannot claim company property as their own.

Two follow-on authorities help students see the consequences. Lee v Lee's Air Farming Ltd [1961] AC 12 shows that the same natural person can occupy different legal capacities with a company; a controlling shareholder could also enter an employment relationship where the facts and law supported it. Macaura v Northern Assurance Co Ltd [1925] AC 619 illustrates why ownership of shares does not mean ownership of the company’s insured assets. Ask whether the plaintiff has an insurable interest in the particular property rather than confusing ownership of shares with legal title.

What about the 'corporate veil'? That is shorthand for the separation between company and participant. Courts do not disregard corporate personality merely because a company is small, closely controlled, undercapitalised or associated with other companies. A claimed exception requires a recognised legal basis and appropriate evidence. Sometimes the actual route to personal liability is not a veil exception at all: the individual gave a guarantee, made a personal misrepresentation, committed a wrong, or incurred liability under a specific statute.

Corporate groups make this especially important. A parent may own a subsidiary's shares, but that ownership does not automatically make the parent a contracting party to the subsidiary's agreements. Identify the legal person in each transaction and consider separate duties owed by directors to their own company. A group’s commercial strategy does not dissolve its members’ legal identities.

Your step-by-step exam pathway

Use these steps to organise the facts before writing an IRAC answer. Do not jump to a case until you know why it applies.

  1. STEP 1Find the registration date
  2. STEP 2Identify the company versus its members and directors
  3. STEP 3Decide who owns the asset or owes the debt
  4. STEP 4Test any guarantee, agency, personal wrongdoing or statutory exception
  5. STEP 5Apply the separate-entity principle to the evidence

Statute and authority map

Each source answers a different question. Read the actual provision and check the exact subsection and legal context before formal reliance.

Why the cases matter: Salomon explains the basic separation; Lee shows legally distinct capacities; Macaura illustrates that owning shares is not the same thing as owning the company’s assets. State what each case proves before applying it.

Read the current Act at the official Federal Register of Legislation.

Full worked client problem

Facts: Mia owns all shares in OceanTech Pty Ltd. OceanTech buys a machine in its own name. Mia attempts to sell the machine personally to pay her private debt.

High-standard IRAC worked answer: explanation and application

The issue is who owns the machine. A registered company is a separate legal person, and its purchase in its own name ordinarily means the machine belongs to OceanTech, not Mia as shareholder. Under Salomon, complete share ownership does not collapse the two persons into one. Mia may be able to cause properly authorised corporate decisions through lawful governance, but she cannot simply dispose of company property as if it were her own. Check title documents, any agency arrangement, director authority and applicable conflict duties before advising on a transfer.

Study problem authored for this guide, not represented as an original university tutorial question.

Essential reading explained: learn it, reason with it, apply it

Prescribed-reading connection

Chapple et al, Company Law (3rd ed, 2023), ch 1, § 1.6 (companies), as preparatory context for the separately prescribed company-incorporation reading in Week 2.

The Chapter 1 extract is background for Chapter 2; it is not a substitute for the Week 2 assigned textbook Chapter 2 and the Week 2 lecture.

The reading is a course/licensed text; it is cited, not republished. Textbook publisher and table of contents. For the current statutory wording, use the Federal Register of Legislation.

Lecturer-style teaching: what it means and why it matters

Imagine Priya sells handmade furniture from her kitchen. Before registration she contracts in her own capacity. After she sets up a company, the company can itself enter contracts and own property. But the change does not automatically transfer Priya’s earlier contracts to the new entity. Students should draw a vertical line on the timeline: before registration and after registration.

The first legal step is the registration application under s 117. On registration, a company comes into existence as a body corporate by s 119. The registered company has legal capacity under s 124. A company’s internal objects restriction may matter internally, but s 125 stops an act being invalid merely because it contravenes an objects or power restriction.

Separate personality means the company’s assets and obligations are generally distinct from its shareholders’. Do not collapse separate personality into a blanket rule that every person associated with the company is immune. When the facts involve personal misconduct, guarantees, a statute imposing responsibility or abusive structures, analyse the separate rule rather than simply saying “the veil is lifted”.

In tutorials, take care to distinguish a group of companies from one single company. Parent and subsidiary may each be separate legal persons. Common control is not an automatic reason to ignore that separation.

Visual issue-spotting pathway

  1. 1When was the act done?
  2. 2Was the company registered?
  3. 3Who contracted?
  4. 4Which liability rule applies?

This sequence is an issue-spotting tool; the case facts and applicable law still control the answer.

Illustrated tutorial application — the issue and rule in context

Issue. Before incorporation, a founder orders machinery in the name of “soon-to-be-formed” Atlas Pty Ltd. After incorporation, the supplier seeks payment. Rule. The corporation did not exist when the agreement was signed. Examine the specific pre-registration contract rules in s 131 and the actual agreement. Application. Identify who signed, whether the company later registered, whether and when it ratified the arrangement and what the supplier knew. Conclusion. Do not answer “separate legal personality means Atlas owes it”: registration alone is not ratification.

Compare this method with the original tutorial question and full model answer. Do not substitute this illustrative problem for the university question.

What a High Distinction-standard explanation must demonstrate

Identify every material issue and sub-issue; state the exact legislative source and the legal effect of its subsection; distinguish binding rules from commentary; explain the controlling case rather than name-dropping; apply facts for both parties; address limits, remedies and standing; then give a qualified, evidence-based conclusion. The course-participation High Distinction benchmark previously provided is 85%+: thorough preparation, sophisticated legal analysis, synthesis and evaluation, original thinking, practical and wider connections, constructive participation and professionalism. Explain how each issue meets those criteria in a tutorial response. This is not a substitute for an examination-specific marking rubric, nor a guarantee of any mark.

Essential-reading FAQs — questions with explanations

What is the company’s birthday in law?

The date of registration: s 119. This determines whether it could have acted as an incorporated entity at the relevant time.

Is a subsidiary the same legal person as its parent?

Generally no. Share ownership and control do not automatically eliminate the subsidiary’s separate legal existence.

Why is pre-registration timing examinable?

It changes who could have contracted and whether special statutory rules on pre-registration agreements apply.

Essential-reading MCQs — with answer reasoning

Question 1: A company is incorporated after a proposed contract is signed. What is the best starting point?

  1. Its logo
  2. The s 131 pre-registration framework
  3. Its first dividend
  4. Its website
Show answer and reasoning

Answer B. The contract predates the company. Address s 131 rather than presuming registration adopts every earlier bargain.

Question 2: An objects clause restricts business activity. Does breaching it automatically make the company’s act void?

  1. Always
  2. Usually not merely for that reason under s 125
  3. Only if profits fall
  4. Only if a shareholder asks
Show answer and reasoning

Answer B. s 125 is central. However, internal authority and directors’ duties require separate analysis.

Frequently asked questions — and actual answers

Is the company the same as its sole shareholder?

No. A one-person company is still a separate legal person after registration.

Does limited liability mean company debts disappear?

No. The company must meet its debts. The principle addresses when members are personally liable, not whether the debt exists.

Does owning 100% of shares mean owning 100% of equipment?

No. Ownership of shares is distinct from legal ownership of company property.

Can a director ever be personally liable?

Yes, for example under a guarantee, their own wrongdoing, or a particular statutory duty; identify the actual legal basis.

MCQs: reason your way to the answer

Select an answer before revealing the explanation. Memorising an option is less useful than being able to explain why each legal distinction matters.

MCQ 1: Who ordinarily owns an asset purchased by a registered company in its own name?

  • A. The directors personally
  • B. The sole shareholder
  • C. The company
  • D. ASIC
Reveal the correct answer and explanation

Answer: C. Separate personality means title ordinarily belongs to the company.

MCQ 2: Which case best establishes incorporation separates company from controlling shareholder?

Reveal the correct answer and explanation

Answer: A. Salomon is the classic starting point for separate legal personality.

MCQ 3: A parent holds all shares in a subsidiary. What follows automatically?

  • A. The parent becomes party to every subsidiary contract
  • B. The subsidiary loses its legal existence
  • C. The parent owns those shares, while the subsidiary remains distinct
  • D. Directors owe duties only to the parent
Reveal the correct answer and explanation

Answer: C. A corporate group does not automatically merge legal persons or their contracts.

Now return to the full book and original tutorial

The complete chapter contains the fuller narrative, authority discussions and the existing tutorial material. This accessible guide is a supplement, not a replacement or a claim that every case pinpoint has been verified.

Read Chapter 2 in full · Tutorial library · Original approved PDF book